Carlito's latest activity

  • Carlito
    Carlito reacted to Swagger's post in the thread 2023/24 Jarrad Branthwaite with Like Like.
    Actually that's an excellent point. I.e., if he plays Branthwaite in a friendly chances are he will light it up and as a left footed, 6'5, quick centre back who is comfortable on the ball, the media will bang the drum for him to start over his...
  • Carlito
    I just assume that every right-footed wide forward cuts in from the left now.
  • Carlito
    Carlito reacted to Raino85's post in the thread Everton Summer 2024 Transfer Thread with Like Like.
    Maybe because he was just Bobby Reid until around 2016-17
  • Carlito
    Decordova-Reid isn't a bad player; I think he'd be a decent option on the left. Surprised he's as old as that, though.
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Jarrad Branthwaite.
    I honestly believe that the issue with Branthwaite is how much better he is than Maguire. Southgate was a good centre-back himself. He knows what he's seeing in training.
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell.
    Alli and Gomes haven't even left yet, never mind been replaced for cheap. Coady and Mina were replaced by Branthwaite, who was already here before Thelwell arrived.
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell.
    Diego Costa would have been a laugh.
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell.
    It wouldn't take a goal-scoring sensation to be better value than Beto at £25m. Even if he just matched the three league goals while being able to control the ball reliably, it would be a major improvement. Chermitti, assuming another forward...
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell.
    I'm not sure they'll be happy to live with it when the fees start coming due, nor would I be surprised to see all three of Thelwell's forward purchases going out on loan next season. I just hope he doesn't waste another chunk of the summer...
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell.
    Which should have been a red flag in and of itself. It's just more short-term thinking, kicking the can down the road and hoping things somehow work themselves out. As much as it was frustrating at the time - and he was really just covering for...
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell.
    For a club in Everton's position, if the choice is £25m for Beto (regardless of when it has to be paid) or nobody, you go with nobody. Virtually any forward who went out on loan or was available on a Bosman would have been better. He and Maupay...
  • Carlito
    Carlito reacted to Goat's post in the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell with Like Like.
    Very similar to his Everton career.
  • Carlito
    In my time, Jagielka and Lescott has been the best pairing by a good distance. I wasn't too sure about Jagielka at first, mainly due to his height and distribution, but he's the best individual defender I've seen here.
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Dominic Calvert-Lewin.
    He's already on far more money than he's worth to a serious club, but Everton isn't a serious club. Pay him.
  • Carlito
    Carlito replied to the thread 2023/24 Kevin Thelwell.
    Chermiti is young enough to escape proper scrutiny, but Beto is 26 and can't control the ball.
Top