First xi against Tottenham XI who is better?

[BlondeArtist - karl.thornhill@gmail.com]

Howard vs Lloris -
Coleman vs Walker -
Jagielka vs Gallas -
Distin vs Caulker -
Baines vs Vertonghen -
Mirallas vs Lennon -
Gibson vs Parker -
Osman vs Dembele -
Pienaar vs Bale -
Fellaini vs Adebayor -
Jelavic vs Defoe -

tottenham are flat track bullies they beat rubbish cant beat anyone good unless they catch them cold. there best xi isnt that good to be brutally honest considering theyve spent nearly 400m

 

[Connor]

Ours but it would line up:

Lloris
Coleman Jagielka Vertonghen Baines
Mirallas Gibson Dembele Pienaar
Fellaini
Defoe

For me, Vertonghen is a very good centre half and that's why i've moved him there.

 

[Herk]

Howard vs Lloris - Lloris
Coleman vs Walker - Coleman (Walker was good last year)
Jagielka vs Gallas - Jagielka
Distin vs Caulker - Caulker (On age)
Baines vs Vertonghen - Baines
Mirallas vs Lennon - Mirallas
Gibson vs Parker - Parker
Osman vs Dembele - Osman
Pienaar vs Bale - Bale
Fellaini vs Adebayor - Fellaini
Jelavic vs Defoe - Defoe

 

[WuTangToffee]

Lloris
Coleman Jagielka Caulker Baines
Mirallas Gibson Dembele Pienaar
Fellaini
Defoe

 

[Ihaters]

Howard vs Lloris - Lloris
Coleman vs Walker - Walker
Jagielka vs Gallas -Jags
Distin vs Caulker - Draw
Baines vs Vertonghen - Baines
Mirallas vs Lennon - Draw
Gibson vs Parker - Gibson
Osman vs Dembele - Osman
Pienaar vs Bale - Bale
Fellaini vs Adebayor - Fellaini
Jelavic vs Defoe -Defoe

tottenham are flat track bullies they beat rubbish cant beat anyone good unless they catch them cold. there best xi isnt that good to be brutally honest considering theyve spent nearly 400m

That's how I see it but several are very close.. Jelavic for example

 

[Brennan]

Howard vs Lloris - Lloris
Coleman vs Walker - Tie
Jagielka vs Gallas - Jagielka
Distin vs Caulker - Distin
Baines vs Vertonghen - Baines
Mirallas vs Lennon - Mirallas
Gibson vs Parker - Gibson
Osman vs Dembele - Dembele
Pienaar vs Bale - Bale
Fellaini vs Adebayor - Fellaini
Jelavic vs Defoe - Defoe

tottenham are flat track bullies they beat rubbish cant beat anyone good unless they catch them cold. there best xi isnt that good to be brutally honest considering theyve spent nearly 400m

.....

Would line up like this:

Lloris
Cole/Wal Jagielka Distin Baines
Mirallas Gibson Fellaini Bale
Dembele
Jelavic​

 

[Allezfan]

Mostly agree with Ihaters except I think Distin is better than Caulker outright,

 

[RFUS]

Howard vs Lloris -
Coleman vs Walker -
Jagielka vs Gallas -
Distin vs Caulker -
Baines vs Vertonghen -
Mirallas vs Lennon -
Gibson vs Parker -
Osman vs Dembele -
Pienaar vs Bale -
Fellaini vs Adebayor -
Jelavic vs Defoe -

tottenham are flat track bullies they beat rubbish cant beat anyone good unless they catch them cold. there best xi isnt that good to be brutally honest considering theyve spent nearly 400m

Lloris, Walker, Jagielka, Distin, Baines, Mirallas, Gibson, Osman, Bale, Fellaini, Defoe.

 

[nsno-chris]

-----------Friedel--------------
Walker - Jags - Vertonghen - Baines
-------Dembele -Gibson---------
------------Fellaini-----------
-----Mirallas - Jelavic - Bale---

Friedel is better than both options

 

[LTblue]

Howard vs Lloris (Lloris)
Coleman vs Walker - (Walker)
Jagielka vs Gallas -(Jagielka)
Distin vs Caulker -(Distin)
Baines vs Vertonghen - (Baines
Mirallas vs Lennon - (Mirallas)
Gibson vs Parker -(Gibson)
Osman vs Dembele -(Dembele-just)
Pienaar vs Bale -(Bale, but Bale<Bainaar)
Fellaini vs Adebayor -(Fellaini)
Jelavic vs Defoe -(Jelavic)
Everton-6 Spurs-5
Ours is better.

 

[Azzurri]

Howard vs Lloris - Lloris
Coleman vs Walker - Coleman (Walker was good last year)
Jagielka vs Gallas - Jagielka
Distin vs Caulker - Caulker (On age)
Baines vs Vertonghen - Baines
Mirallas vs Lennon - Mirallas
Gibson vs Parker - Parker
Osman vs Dembele - Osman
Pienaar vs Bale - Bale
Fellaini vs Adebayor - Fellaini
Jelavic vs Defoe - Defoe

How does that matter?

 

[By god I'm blue]

I aint playing to your rules, I have devised my own line up

Tough call on keeper, I couldn't differentiate between Howard or either of their 2.

Walker
Jagielka
Distin
Baines

Lennon
Bale
Dembele
Fellaini

Jelavic
Defoe

 

[Pabbers]

Lloris
Walker
Jagielka
Caulker
Baines
Mirallas
Gibson
Dembele
Bale
Fellaini
Jelavic

5 Spurs
6 Blue's

 

[eagleowl]

I'd go for something different.
Lloris
Coleman - Jagielka - Vertongen - Baines
Mirallas - Fellaini - Dembele - Bale
Jelavic - Defoe
Most of the subs would be from Everton
Subs
Friedel, Distin, Osman, Gibson and on current form Anichebe
OhPienaar would be in there as well

 

[toffeenut84]

howard,coleman,jagielka,distin,baines,mirallas,gibson,osman,bale,fellaini,defoe.