Recent content by smileychap

  1. smileychap

    Summer Transfer Window 2025 Thread

    We need a RB (who can get forward), CB (cover for JoB and Tarks), a CF, 2 x CM. Ideally right winger, too. That's 6 players, mostly who'll be first choice if decent, with approx 5 weeks to prep for an away game in front of Leeds who'll be bang up for it. Crack on TFG and Davey boy, crack on...
  2. smileychap

    2024/25 James Garner

    Yeah keep Garner and McNeil. Effort and attitude good. Both young-ish on an upward curve.
  3. smileychap

    2024/25 Michael Keane

    Is it over yet? Good luck Michael. Not your fault someone thought you were a £30m centre half when that was proper dough. Hope you carry on banging in a few anywhere but against Everton :)
  4. smileychap

    2024/25 Dominic Calvert-Lewin

    Yeah, that about nails it. I think DCL and for example - Michael Keane - embody a period in Everton's time when maybe not the 'best' players also took on a lot of responsibility in a side / club undergoing major flux, mismanagement under grim ownership. Both lads had some OK spells and moments...
  5. smileychap

    Lee Carsley

    Phew (to Charlie Adam going).
  6. smileychap

    Lee Carsley

    Making a great case for it. U21s ping it around far better than senior team.
  7. smileychap

    Summer Transfer Window 2025 Thread

    I agree with this when I look at the over financed disgrace that is MUFC. BUT... Strangely the absolutely disgraceful mediocrity of well moneyed clubs like them, Spurs, City last year is not everything, and conversely creates the opportunity others need. The way Brighton, Brentford ( who I...
  8. smileychap

    2024/25 Michael Keane

    I hope so, they'll do ok... Both CB's got a goal in em and all those guys at some point scrambled Everton over the line, when the writing was on the wall after higher spending mgt and higher paid players.
  9. smileychap

    2024/25 Michael Keane

    I like to think I give anyone who turns out for us a fair go. Especially in this era where they've played for a side almost constantly under pressure and often under mgt / squad flux, and with some absolute triple hangers on knocking around training sessions. Like DCL, I think that's been...
  10. smileychap

    Summer Transfer Window 2025 Thread

    Great post. Quansah and JB different players. I don't think anyone's doing that kinda dough for those two Reds, though. Maybe 40 and 60 tops (not that we even care!). Jarrad needs to stay put, great couple of seasons, see us solid top half/ europa and if then it's more obvious to everyone...
  11. smileychap

    Transfer Rumour Kyle Walker

    Uhh, I just dislike the guy. His head's not right. I don't recall him putting a great cross in for ages, he was clearly goal shy at the Euros where Spain repeatedly pulled him out of position for both winners. He's not top drawer now. Time's caught up with him. Italian league slower, would...
  12. smileychap

    2024/25 Dominic Calvert-Lewin

    DCL lacks in power, pace and consistency. Successful center forwards tend to have those qualities. He can occasionally hit the box at the right time and poke a goal in. I think he's genuine enough, he just is what he is, and we've watched him be that for a very long time now.
  13. smileychap

    Transfer Rumour Kyle Walker

    Whilst they nabbed stones n lescott.
  14. smileychap

    Transfer Rumour Jack Grealish

    Can't remember the last time I saw grealish play / well / at all. Never _really_ thought he fitted at city. Fair play he made a bundle and had an ok season once. Swerve
  15. smileychap

    2024/25 Iliman Ndiaye

    Keep ndiaye ffs. What's this thread for?
Back
Top