Saint Domingo
Player Valuation: £90m
To be fair he did have significantly more goes than the other managers and with far better teams.
Agreed, but I think some people used to be harsh on his derby record because he didn’t win at Anfield. He’s got our biggest PL win over them (the 3-0) and you’ve got to go back to the 60s before you see any results better than that one agaisnt that lot. He outplayed a very strong Liverpool team over 2 legs and won it in extra time in the cup (can barely imagine us getting close to that now).
The semi final was disappointing but I think people at the time overestimated our team (without our best player Pienaar) and underestimated how good Suarez was for them. Ultimately if Distin doesn’t do that back pass we probably win that as well. There were a few others he should have got over the line (if Howard doesn’t jump in on Kuyt for no reason we win at Anfield) and there were a few times he was downright robbed by scandalous refereeing.
I got more annoyed at the times they went down to 10 and we somehow contrived to lose much more than the cup semi. I remember us having an annoyingly bad injury record for derbies as well with Arteta especially missing a lot of them when he was in his peak.