I get why he's a scapegoat but again - we were 19th and widely condemned and accepted as "down" without Keane playing a single minute.
The emphasis on Keane is way OTT.
Oh and enjoy Coadys last game for us;
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
2022/23 Michael Keane
- Thread starter VentureBrosEFC
- Start date
- Status
I get why he's a scapegoat but again - we were 19th and widely condemned and accepted as "down" without Keane playing a single minute.
The emphasis on Keane is way OTT.
Oh and enjoy Coadys last game for us;
It’s tough to see people flailing about so obviously embarrassed about defending this atrocity in the past.
Hold up there chief
Well technically by your metrics, that Coady mistake didn’t cost us points because we were already a goal down. So again I’ll ask, tell me which Coady mistakes cost us points.
He hasn't.
Spurs collapse was on Doucoure. Give away a pen but cancelled out with an equaliser.
"Lost Soyuncu for Leicester equaliser"
I mean, cmon
I actually was happy to sign him when we were first linked. Took me less than a season to change my mind.
He hasn't.
Spurs collapse was on Doucoure. Give away a pen but cancelled out with an equaliser.
"Lost Soyuncu for Leicester equaliser"
I mean, cmon
What? Can you explain what’s so funny about that? He ghosts in behind him and Keane doesn’t have a clue where he is or what’s going on around him, like he doesn’t 100% of the time.
Again.
We were 19th when Dyche tookover/without Keane kicking a ball.
You and others are putting way too much on Keane.
"Keane will relegate us!!!"
He's not cost us a point since coming in.
Coady is as poor, if not worse. At least Keane is more of a threat in the opposition box.
Mina - I think he will have checked out. A player waiting on his last pay day in a relegation scrap? He'd last 30 minutes anyway.
Ah so it's okay when he gives away another easy goal next game then.He hasn't.
Spurs collapse was on Doucoure. Give away a pen but cancelled out with an equaliser.
"Lost Soyuncu for Leicester equaliser"
I mean, cmon
He tried his best to give away 3 but luckily when Vardy outpaced him every single time he hit the bar once and had Pickford make a save. Oh also the pen thing.
???
So you can’t tell me which Coady mistakes cost us points. Ok then, that’s fine.
Still my point remains.
Some are desperate to attribute blame to him.
Some will have been glad he conceded the penalty over any other player.
He's a scapegoat.
But let's remember we were 19th and on the deck before he played a single minute.
There's no quick fix.
Dog of a player. Fully expecting him to play the remaing 4 games.
Tbf we've lost 10 of past 15 games Coady has played. Lost only 4 of the last 10 Keane has played.
I don't think Keane has been brilliant but Coady is definitely no better than him. Got humiliated in his last game v Villa.
Goodisongang
Player Valuation: £25m
so because we havent moved position he isnt at fault for lost points? not sure how that makes sense?
we'd have likely picked up a few more points if he hadnt played, the stats under dyche with and without keane back that up
As people have already pointed out, a lot of those games were under the worst manager in the league who didn’t play a midfield and not necessarily as a result of defensive errors. The numbers since Dyche came in with and without Keane in the side speak for themselves. He is a huge, huge problem and has been since we signed him.
- Status