Lot of discord surrounding the appointment of our current manager and you can’t ignore the decent job our former boss is doing at West Ham… out of interest then who would you prefer here now ?
- Status
SteStocksDJ
Player Valuation: £8m
I was always happy if Moyes came back.
But please can you specify my cheese option as I may change.
But please can you specify my cheese option as I may change.
Deffo … but it’s a valid question I think. Moyes has proved that when given time and a little backing at the right time he is quite good at fashioning a competitive team, do we give Benitez the time to do that here or would fans prefer to boot him and replace yet another manager.
The binman chronicles
Player Valuation: £80m
Already said this in the Moyes thread but will say it again, there is no guarantee that you take a manager who is doing well from one club and put him here and he will do the same. It's a pointless argument.
ForeverBlue92
Player Valuation: £80m
Moyes was a dinosaur before he went to WHU and relegated Sunderland with no decent track record since Everton job.
Benitez was a dinosaur, went down with Newcastle with no decent track record since the Chelsea job.
Maybe the gobshites in the fanbase should pipe down and give the fella time and see him bring HIS own players in like Moyes has done there - Soucek (£18 million) Coufal (8 million) Bowen (£17 million) Behrama (£25 million) Zouma (£25 million)
Benitez has had £1.7m to spend.
Some right mugs in our fanbase thinking any manager can do much with our squad outside of DCL, Richarlison, Doucoure, Mina, Allan, Gray in which 4 of them have been out for weeks this season leaving us with crap replacements.
everton1953
Player Valuation: £40m
I will go for Harry Catterick or Kendall.
Very reactive.
Wasn't long ago West Ham fans wanted Moyes out - the covid break saved him.
He got a bit of time but come the end of both Benitez and Moyes careers there will only be one answer on who was the more successful/better manager.
There's also only 3 points seperating the sides.
Benitez will say 8th means nothing.
Moyes will say 8th means manager of the season.
Wasn't long ago West Ham fans wanted Moyes out - the covid break saved him.
He got a bit of time but come the end of both Benitez and Moyes careers there will only be one answer on who was the more successful/better manager.
There's also only 3 points seperating the sides.
Benitez will say 8th means nothing.
Moyes will say 8th means manager of the season.
I'd prefer Walter Smith
Isn't the question referring to who was the more successful/better manager for Everton not just in general?
No.
Read the poll title.
And comparing the two for their impact at Everton would be beyond pathetic.
helpimonfire
Player Valuation: £35m
I would prefer Duncan in charge. At least we get passion from him.
From the options above the Cheese looks the best.
From the options above the Cheese looks the best.
Yeh, who would you prefer for Everton?
Why would we give a toss what these lads do in Sociedad or Napoli come the end of their careers.
You generally look at credentials of a manager to determine likelihood of success.
That's why we don't appoint Phil from Skem FC
- Status
