It is awful,
We havnt won a trophy there for 28 years
We havnt won the league there for going on 40 years
We bearly won a home game there the last 3 years.
Clearly a BK idea this, deliberately handicapping ourselves for no reason
You may love Goodison but the truth is it’s been a weight around our neck for decades
All those things may be true, however I think there's a slight case of false equivalence here. Goodison is not
THE reason all those are true.
It may have been a part of a much wider problem, but I think it's grossly unfair to attribute our demise with Goodison. In other ways, it's been a positive.
Goodison for many years was a fortress: its bear-bit atmosphere has certainly contributed to us winning games over the past few decades.
Yes we've missed out on revenue and commercial opportunities, however I would suggest you could attribute those issues to a wider problem - governance.
Arguably, we've been poorly run since the halcyon days of the 80s. A better stadium wouldn't have completely rectified Johnson and his abject failings.
It wouldn't have changed the fact that Kenwright was completely skin, nor would it have resolved Moshiri's scattergun approach and general mismanagement.
I completely get while we have to move on, and in many ways I'm looking forward to it. Nevertheless, the stadium isn't going to a magic bullet that repairs all.
The reason we haven't lifted a trophy or won the league is because of other gross failings. Unless off the pitch issues are resolved, BMD won't change that.