James Patrick
Player Valuation: £8m
Cyclists, runners, hotel guests etc use it quite frequently - clearly not loads but it still needs to be accommodated.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
Well, trying not to sound glib, they'll just have to deal with it. I went in for a drink after crossing the bridge, the huge swathe of people had passed and it was quite accessible. Also, for many years I have battled against the flow coming out of Goodison. Jutst get on with it FFS. For most it will be a one time experience.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
The Everton stadium, a briefing document. More to follow.....
Overall Themes and Sentiment:
The dominant theme throughout the forum posts is a strong desire and anticipation for a new stadium. This hope has been a long-standing aspiration for Everton fans, evident from the early discussions in 2014 about potential locations like Clarence Dock:
ToffeeDan (April 14, 2014): "On the North Dock Road - Clarence Dock - massive piece of land.. Some piccies for you.." tenaciousj (April 14, 2014): "TD, it has been considered previously."
Over the years, this anticipation has been mixed with periods of skepticism and frustration due to numerous false dawns and a perceived lack of progress, particularly concerning the ownership and financial situation of the club under Bill Kenwright:
degsy (January 26, 2015): "Not being funny mate but we have had enough false dawns to last two life times 'The kings dock money is ring fenced' hmmm, what happened there? We have been fed so much bullshit from Bill and his cronies over the years that it's laughable."
The arrival of Farhad Moshiri brought renewed optimism and the Bramley-Moore Dock site became the primary focus. However, the sheer length of the planning and development process has continued to test the patience of the fanbase.
As the project has moved from initial discussions to actual construction, the forum has become a hub for information sharing (and often mis-information), speculation, and emotional responses to every development, rumor, and perceived setback.
More recently, with the stadium visibly taking shape, the sentiment has shifted towards excitement and pride, although concerns about potential relegation impacting the new stadium experience persist:
Barry Rathbone (November 27, 2019): "Possibly the ultimate 'everton that' scenario is a new stadium and relegation within months."
Key Ideas and Facts Discussed:
Several usernames appear frequently throughout the threads, suggesting a core group of active forum members who have followed the stadium project closely over many years. These include:
Everton New Stadium Forum Posts Review: A Briefing Document
This briefing document summarizes the main themes, important ideas, and key sentiments expressed by Everton supporters on the GrandOldTeam.co.uk forum regarding the proposed new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock (BMD). The analysis covers excerpts from pages 1 to 8627 across multiple PDF sources, spanning from April 2014 to February 2025.Overall Themes and Sentiment:
The dominant theme throughout the forum posts is a strong desire and anticipation for a new stadium. This hope has been a long-standing aspiration for Everton fans, evident from the early discussions in 2014 about potential locations like Clarence Dock:
ToffeeDan (April 14, 2014): "On the North Dock Road - Clarence Dock - massive piece of land.. Some piccies for you.." tenaciousj (April 14, 2014): "TD, it has been considered previously."
Over the years, this anticipation has been mixed with periods of skepticism and frustration due to numerous false dawns and a perceived lack of progress, particularly concerning the ownership and financial situation of the club under Bill Kenwright:
degsy (January 26, 2015): "Not being funny mate but we have had enough false dawns to last two life times 'The kings dock money is ring fenced' hmmm, what happened there? We have been fed so much bullshit from Bill and his cronies over the years that it's laughable."
The arrival of Farhad Moshiri brought renewed optimism and the Bramley-Moore Dock site became the primary focus. However, the sheer length of the planning and development process has continued to test the patience of the fanbase.
As the project has moved from initial discussions to actual construction, the forum has become a hub for information sharing (and often mis-information), speculation, and emotional responses to every development, rumor, and perceived setback.
More recently, with the stadium visibly taking shape, the sentiment has shifted towards excitement and pride, although concerns about potential relegation impacting the new stadium experience persist:
Barry Rathbone (November 27, 2019): "Possibly the ultimate 'everton that' scenario is a new stadium and relegation within months."
Key Ideas and Facts Discussed:
- Site Location and History: Early discussions considered various locations, with Clarence Dock being mentioned in 2014. Bramley-Moore Dock eventually became the chosen site, leading to discussions about its size, the inclusion of the water area in the land deal, and potential heritage issues related to filling in the docks.
- allen (September 19, 2016): "If the acreage includes the water, the following covers the ~17 acres: If it doesn't include the water, this is ~17 acres:" ToffeeDoug (September 19, 2016): "would a land deal with Peel Ports have to include the 'water' area as such, or is it just the hard-standing area on its own?" Jacko93 (September 19, 2016): "My understanding is that the purchase will be for the area within the boundary of BMD, therefore inclusive of the water area."
- Financing and Ownership: The financial aspects of the stadium have been a constant source of debate, including discussions about potential investors, loans (like the VIBRAC loan), and the role of Farhad Moshiri and Alisher Usmanov. Concerns about Financial Fair Play (FFP) regulations and related party transactions have also been raised.
- Moomin (December 4, 2014): "Depends really, Mike Ashley done it with Newcastle a few years back on the debt. Saves them 9 million a year on interest. He will get it back when he eventually sells, he is not doing it from the goodness of his heart." Lanolin (May 5, 2020): "City's case involved £100m per year of sponsorship from companies which their owner was chairman of, that is absolutely nothing like the situation we're talking about."
- Design and Features: Forum members have actively discussed and speculated about the stadium's design, capacity (ranging from 55-60k being a frequently mentioned target), and features. Ideas have ranged from the aesthetic use of royal blue bricks to the inclusion of statues and fan tributes. The industrial look of the docklands has been seen as a potentially magnificent architectural theme.
- Yarrgh (May 9, 2017): "I want a stadium that makes the delegates from Fifa and Uefa wet themselves with anticipation of getting their events staged. I want the stadium to be beautiful and be the standard against what every other stadium is measured against." TheFinnFan (October 18, 2016): "that window crowns that magnificent industrial look imho."
- Planning Permission and Red Tape: The lengthy planning permission process and potential obstacles, including concerns from UNESCO and local opposition (often humorously attributed to rival Liverpool supporters), have been frequently discussed.
- vintage-toffees (September 28, 2016): "The docks is known to be the 'statement' option but there is so much red tape" silent bob (November 16, 2016): "At this stage we are hopeful that the fish don't lodge an objection, but knowing our luck..."
- Construction Progress: As construction began, the forum became a place to share updates, photos, and videos of the progress. Discussions have included the filling of the dock with sand, the construction of stands, and logistical considerations.
- dublinbluenose (October 1, 2021): "Ship has arrived carrying the sand ready to be pumped into dock" windymiller (October 8, 2021): "The sand in the dock has nowhere to go so once it is in and compacted it'll be a great built base..."
- Matchday Experience: Supporters have considered various aspects of the matchday experience at the new stadium, including pricing, accessibility, transport (including potential ferry services), catering (Budweiser and San Miguel being rumored), and the atmosphere. Concerns about maintaining a strong Everton identity and not becoming "soulless" have been voiced.
- maccavennie (September 22, 2016): "It's important that we price it right for mums and dads to be able to make a day of it and take kids with them..." TrailerTrash (March 16, 2023): "A ferry terminal at BMD could work, couldn't it?" edwardcrompton (November 10, 2024): "It's massive but souless...can't describe it any other way."
- Naming Rights and Sponsorship: The potential for stadium naming rights and other commercial partnerships has been a topic of speculation and discussion regarding the financial benefits for the club.
- "ITK" (In The Know) Culture: The forum exhibits a strong "ITK" culture, with users claiming to have inside information about the stadium project and club developments. These claims are often met with skepticism and humor.
- orly (November 18, 2016): "Dan, Dan, he made a play to be the forum ITK but now his cred has gone away because he mentioned 'on Friday'..."
- Fan Tributes and Legacy: Discussions have touched upon how the club's history and traditions will be reflected in the new stadium, including the "Everton Way" brick tributes.
- Toffeeslam (March 24, 2023): "So these bricks……are there to throw at Kenwright if he shows up ?"
- Humor and Banter: Despite the seriousness of the stadium project, the forum is characterized by a significant amount of humor, banter, and in-jokes among the Everton supporters. This ranges from lighthearted remarks about rival fans ("dyslexic kopite," "kopite tears") to more elaborate and sometimes crude exchanges.
Several usernames appear frequently throughout the threads, suggesting a core group of active forum members who have followed the stadium project closely over many years. These include:
- tommye (often involved in "ITK" and banter)
- roydo (long-term contributor)
- allen (provides analytical posts, e.g., on land size)
- Goat (high "Player Valuation" indicative of forum status/humor)
- Jacko93 (offers informed opinions)
- blulouie
- ToffeeDan (initiated early discussions about alternative sites)
- orly (known for moderating and humorous contributions)
- BNJ1878 (known for direct and often humorous responses)
- Exeter_Gently (offers considered opinions)
- matty1878 (frequent poster, sometimes involved in humorous or less serious posts)
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
Negativity and positivity.....
Based on the excerpts from the "New Everton Stadium forum posts," it's possible to identify members who are repeatedly portrayed as negative or positive, although these are subjective perceptions within the forum discussions.
Members Frequently Portrayed as Negative:
Members Frequently Portrayed as Positive:
It's harder to pinpoint specific individuals consistently labeled as "positive" in the same way as negative members. However, the forum discussions reveal a general sentiment among many members who express:
It's important to remember that these are perceptions based on forum posts, and what one user considers negative, another might see as realistic or critical thinking. The thread appears to have a recurring dynamic between optimistic and pessimistic viewpoints regarding the new Everton Stadium.
Based on the excerpts from the "New Everton Stadium forum posts," it's possible to identify members who are repeatedly portrayed as negative or positive, although these are subjective perceptions within the forum discussions.
Members Frequently Portrayed as Negative:
- davek: davek is consistently mentioned by other users as embodying a negative perspective on the stadium and related club matters. He is described as the forum’s "counter-balance" to optimistic views, someone with a "stadium half empty" outlook, and as someone who often presents a contrary opinion. Some users find his contributions "tedious" and accuse him of "derailing every thread with negative comments". He is even likened to Piers Morgan in terms of his perceived negativity. davek himself acknowledges that he tries to put forward an alternative view and cautions against a "Pollyanna view". Another user refers to him as a "cryarse".
- The Esk: The Esk is mentioned as having a history of negativity and is described as a "parasite" who has "leeched off our fanbase for years with his negativity".
- Tom Hughes: While Tom Hughes sees himself as raising valid points and backing them with facts, some other users perceive him as being overly critical and attempting to "spoil this thread" by focusing on potential issues and comparisons with past stadium proposals. His posts are sometimes described as lengthy and not fitting some users' positive narratives. Some find his contributions annoying.
- General mentions of certain posters or a "clique" who are consistently negative across various threads, including the stadium thread, are frequent. These individuals are often accused of "moaning," "whining," and having a "constant negative outlook". Some are suspected of being rival supporters ("Rawkists" or "reds") attempting to stir negativity.
Members Frequently Portrayed as Positive:
It's harder to pinpoint specific individuals consistently labeled as "positive" in the same way as negative members. However, the forum discussions reveal a general sentiment among many members who express:
- Enthusiasm and excitement for the new stadium project. These users often look forward to updates, drone footage, and the eventual opening of the stadium.
- A desire to focus on the positive aspects of the stadium development, especially when faced with negativity. They often criticize those who they perceive as unnecessarily negative and want the thread to be a source of optimism.
- A tendency to defend the club's decisions and progress regarding the stadium.
It's important to remember that these are perceptions based on forum posts, and what one user considers negative, another might see as realistic or critical thinking. The thread appears to have a recurring dynamic between optimistic and pessimistic viewpoints regarding the new Everton Stadium.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
When did it start to feel real?......
Based on the information in the sources, the period around September-October 2016 appears to be a significant moment when the new stadium started to feel like a real possibility for many forum members. Before this time, discussions were often characterized by skepticism and references to past failed attempts. However, several developments around this period contributed to a shift in perception:
While the formal planning application and the start of construction were later milestones, this period in late 2016 seems crucial as it marked a point where the long-talked-about new stadium began to coalesce around a specific, seemingly viable plan and location in the minds of many supporters on the forum, moving beyond mere speculation and into the realm of a real possibility.
Based on the information in the sources, the period around September-October 2016 appears to be a significant moment when the new stadium started to feel like a real possibility for many forum members. Before this time, discussions were often characterized by skepticism and references to past failed attempts. However, several developments around this period contributed to a shift in perception:
- Increased discussion of a specific waterfront location, Bramley Moore Dock (BMD), as the likely site. While other locations like Walton Hall Park had been mentioned earlier, the focus on BMD became more intense in this period.
- Growing anticipation of an official announcement from the club. Users started mentioning that an announcement might be imminent, suggesting that behind-the-scenes progress was being hinted at or rumored.
- A noticeable increase in excitement and belief among some forum members. Phrases like "starting to get excited" indicate a shift in sentiment from the prevailing skepticism.
- Discussions about the logistics of the BMD site, such as potential transportation links and even concerns like the smell from a nearby sewerage farm, suggest that members were starting to consider the practicalities of a stadium at this specific location.
- Comparisons being drawn with other clubs' stadium developments, such as Tottenham Hotspur's project, provided a tangible real-world context and potentially fueled optimism that Everton could follow suit.
While the formal planning application and the start of construction were later milestones, this period in late 2016 seems crucial as it marked a point where the long-talked-about new stadium began to coalesce around a specific, seemingly viable plan and location in the minds of many supporters on the forum, moving beyond mere speculation and into the realm of a real possibility.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
What concerns have been held with regards to transport and transportation around the proposed site??
Yes, there has been significant discussion regarding the potential issues with travel and transportation to the new Everton Stadium (BMD) throughout the forum posts, starting as early as April 2014 and continuing up to December 2024 (the latest dates in the provided excerpts). These discussions have occurred in various periods, reflecting the ongoing nature of the stadium project and the evolving understanding of the transportation challenges.
Here's a breakdown of when these discussions took place, grouped by the dates of the forum posts:
These excerpts demonstrate a consistent and often detailed discussion surrounding the potential challenges and necessary solutions for travel and transportation to the new Everton Stadium at Bramley Moore Dock, spanning from the early stages of the project's consideration to periods closer to its anticipated opening.
Yes, there has been significant discussion regarding the potential issues with travel and transportation to the new Everton Stadium (BMD) throughout the forum posts, starting as early as April 2014 and continuing up to December 2024 (the latest dates in the provided excerpts). These discussions have occurred in various periods, reflecting the ongoing nature of the stadium project and the evolving understanding of the transportation challenges.
Here's a breakdown of when these discussions took place, grouped by the dates of the forum posts:
- April 2014: Early in the discussions, even before a specific site was confirmed, infrastructure was mentioned as a positive aspect of the Edge Lane location.
- 2016:
- September: Following increasing speculation about the Bramley Moore Dock site, concerns about transport began to surface. Users discussed the listed dock wall and potential access issues for a large number of people. The distance from James Street Station was also noted.
- October: The potential for traffic to be relevant was mentioned.
- 2017:
- April: A user questioned whether a temporary running track could be incorporated without it being a "bowl," hinting at considerations beyond just the playing surface that could affect stadium design and potentially access. The delay in asking basic questions about design and capacity was also raised.
- June: The pace of development compared to previous stadium schemes was questioned, implying concerns about the overall planning, which includes transportation.
- September: The planning application timeline was discussed.
- 2018:
- September: The need for transport and logistics to be addressed within the planning application was stated. Specific suggestions like a train station, decent parking, and amended bus routes were made. A fan survey regarding transport issues was also mentioned as upcoming.
- October: The timing of the consultation process, which would include transport, was questioned.
- 2019:
- November: Transport links were specifically raised as a major issue in terms of planning permission, with the idea of a monorail being mentioned, albeit humorously. The BMD location was described as "not a great one" in terms of walking distance from Lime Street, and concerns about transport were reiterated.
- December: Road improvements and the reopening of the Waterloo line were mentioned in the context of addressing transport links.
- 2020:
- January: Accessibility was highlighted as a valid concern for the waterfront location, with a need for more detail on the transport plan beyond taxis, existing Merseyrail, and shuttle buses.
- February: The sketchiness of the transport plan was noted, even while acknowledging Goodison's relatively quick dispersal rates, and the importance of mass transit links to the city centre/Northern Line was emphasized. The non-viability of a new ferry terminal was mentioned.
- 2021:
- September: The transport plan was again referred to as something the club should be able to sell without needing to make misleading comparisons. The limited parking within walking distance of BMD compared to Goodison was brought up.
- December: The transport provisions for the Kings Dock proposal were questioned, drawing parallels with potential issues at BMD. The current transport strategy was described as "sketchy," relying heavily on walking and existing public transport, with a need for substantial improvement.
- 2022:
- March: The transport strategy documents were described as "outline non-technical documents" that referenced analysis docs, with comparisons drawn to the rubbished transport plans for "Destination Kirkby".
- 2023:
- February: The existence of a dedicated transport section in the planning application was confirmed.
- March: The transport information offered was described as "fairly sketchy," with reservations based on local knowledge and the club's history.
- 2024:
- September: Concerns about the ease of getting to and from BMD for 50,000+ people were raised, with the transport plan described as "pretty vague" and requiring a substantial shift to public transport. The limited public transport options around BMD and the distance from city centre hubs were highlighted. The absence of modelled dispersal times in the planning docs was also noted. A detailed response defended the transport plan, mentioning extensive modelling, consultation, and specific details about shuttle bus services from the city centre and Bootle. The need to bridge the gap and effectively transport people to and from town was reiterated.
- December: The "how are we going to get there?" discussion was explicitly identified as an important and ongoing topic. The distance from Sandhills station was debated, and the capacity of Sandhills to handle large crowds was questioned. The vagueness of specific plans for all forms of public transport was raised again. Comparisons were made with Anfield's transport situation, and some users expressed frustration with the continued focus on potential transport problems. The idea that transport issues "can't be issues at this point" was countered by a user pointing out their local knowledge and suggestions for improvement. The transport plan was described as one where "everything gets ironed out as you go," with a perceived absence of strategic planning.
- 2025:
- February: The potential for extra trains was mentioned. The capacity of Sandhills compared to Aintree for large events was questioned. The transportation issue was characterized by a lack of strategic planning and potential unwanted headlines. The idea of a new station closer than Sandhills was discussed.
These excerpts demonstrate a consistent and often detailed discussion surrounding the potential challenges and necessary solutions for travel and transportation to the new Everton Stadium at Bramley Moore Dock, spanning from the early stages of the project's consideration to periods closer to its anticipated opening.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
How about a general timeline of this particular thread?
September 14, 2014: Discussion revolves around the potential usage of the Goodison Park pitch, with users jinkyali, Brennan, and Pat's Van exchanging comments.
September 16, 2014: Users blulouie, kithnou, toffeejack, and bluemangroup engage in lighthearted banter.
October 30, 2014: User EverBlue86 mentions US businessman John Moores potentially investing in Swansea, expressing concern for Everton's new stadium plans and ownership.
December 4-5, 2014: Users Moomin, Neiler, and arch stanton discuss the concept of club owners loaning money to their own clubs, referencing Mike Ashley's actions with Newcastle and Bill Kenwright.
January 26, 2015: Users kithnou, mrb85, degsy, and LouReedwalkonthewildside discuss the possibility of redeveloping Goodison Park if the club were relegated to the Championship, along with skepticism regarding investment and Bill Kenwright's intentions.
February 16, 2015: Users summerisle and royvernon39 discuss Everton Resources' mining interests in the Dominican Republic. Further discussion involves user interactions and opinions on the club's ownership (blulouie, magicjuan, joey_macmo).
September 18-19, 2016: Users Goat, EFCEFC4LIFE engage in humorous exchanges. Allen provides measurements and analysis of the Bramley Moore Dock (BMD) and Nelson Dock area, questioning the boundaries and inclusion of water. Jacko93 and ToffeeDoug also contribute to the discussion on land purchase and potential heritage issues.
September 22, 2016: Users The Esk, The Cowboy, and maccavennie discuss West Ham's stadium lease conditions and the importance of affordable pricing for Everton's new stadium.
September 28, 2016: Users Sharpys top lip, vintage-toffees, Brennan, Moomin, peatzwaterman, and orly discuss rumors of land purchase for the new stadium, with peatzwaterman citing Land Registry information showing Peel Land and Property still as the owner of BMD.
October 13-14, 2016: Humorous exchanges between users like Boss_Blue, dublinbluenose, Jacko93, davek, Duncan Disordely, Goat, terry nodder, and Frank Gallagher.
October 18, 2016: Users fandjango and davek discuss the potential design and aesthetics of the new stadium.
November 2, 2016: Users Kaiser Soysauce, orly, Sharpys top lip, terry nodder, and The Cowboy anticipate an AGM announcement.
November 16, 2016: Users silent bob and The binman chronicles engage in wordplay regarding the dock location. roydo and boris discuss the timing of land purchase in relation to planning permission. Dario Terracotta mentions "Metro mayor" Steve Rotherham's potential influence.
November 18, 2016: Users orly, tommye, ToffeeDan, and a Deleted member discuss forum "ITK" (In The Know) individuals and rumors.
November 24, 2016: Users Julius Geezer and The binman chronicles discuss puns on the forum and the potential acquisition of a yard near the dock.
November 26, 2016: Brief comments from users Jacko93, GwladysBlue, and peteblue. peteblue and roydo reminisce about the history and potential of Liverpool Docks.
May 3, 2017: Users RaleighBlue and roydo debate the financial sustainability of football broadcasting rights.
May 9, 2017: Humorous exchanges between fandjango and Julius Geezer. User Yarrgh expresses grand ambitions and desires for the new stadium's design and impact.
May 15, 2017: Users Toffeeslam, malcson, bazzer25, and Gob Bluth discuss potential stadium design elements like brick color and shape, with general skepticism.
May 17, 2017: User Exeter Gently expresses hope for a precedent-setting stadium design from Mr. Meis.
June 3-4, 2017: Users ToffeeTim, nsno-chris, Connor, tommye, and TheFinnFan reference "Dan" and expectations for the stadium plans.
June 8, 2017: Humorous exchanges between nsno-chris, Ernie, OneTrueLegend, Stephen Gibson, and orly involving blue slush puppies and potentially inappropriate images.
June 21, 2017: Users The binman chronicles, banno, orly, and kev engage in banter about forum rumors and "ITK" individuals.
June 29-30, 2017: Users nsno-chris, ianefc, James Patrick, and mrb85 discuss the potential smell around the Bramley Moore Dock location.
July 1, 2017: User Bluelad1878 suggests a phased construction for the stadium's end sections and asks @MorgsGoat to arrange this with Dan Meis.
July 27, 2017: Users TommyDavo, peteblue, and orly discuss the release of stadium planning application drawings.
August 14, 2018: Users davek, roydo, and Frang discuss the situation with Alisher Usmanov and his connection to Arsenal and geopolitical events.
September 11-12, 2018: Users Goat, roydo, orly, Brisan123, peteblue, WA Toffee, Baldynut, Eggs, and davek discuss potential funding and shareholder changes, with some skepticism and humorous remarks.
October 2, 2018: Users Pabbers and deipnosophist comment on their changing opinions and a humorous discussion about the geometry of trapeziums.
November 11, 2018: Users degsy, Baldynut, jackyboy, and Toffeelover discuss the feasibility and methods of filling in Bramley Moore Dock, considering the dock walls and adjacent docks.
November 16-17, 2018: Users blulouie, GrandOldTeam, toffee-boy, WA Toffee, and mccole engage in discussions about filling in the dock and the sensitive topic of gender-neutral toilets at the new stadium.
December 16, 2018: Users dockroad, summerisle, deipnosophist, Goat, Azza, and MarcelsGoat discuss "skinny lager" and its characteristics.
November 27, 2019: Users Barry Rathbone and malfosse express concerns about the financial implications of a new stadium amidst potential team struggles.
May 5, 2020: Users roydo, H.H., Lanolin, and tommye discuss Alisher Usmanov's potential involvement in funding the stadium and UEFA Financial Fair Play regulations.
June 2, 2020: User tjf suggests potential delays to the stadium project timeline.
June 5, 2020: Users TommyDavo and Tommy. discuss potential delays to enabling works due to UNESCO challenges and engage in humorous banter.
June 21, 2020: Users BNJ1878 and cronullasharks have a confusing exchange.
September 16, 2021: Humorous exchanges between marnie and tommye regarding forum interactions, and Sinski comments on Dave's negativity.
September 29, 2021: Users tommytowne and ForeverBlue92 humorously describe the conditions of the toilets at Goodison Park. roydo is mentioned as a frequent poster.
October 1, 2021: Users Johnnytotal, marnie, dublinbluenose, and devo85 discuss sand delivery to the dock, with devo85 outlining the process.
October 8, 2021: Users Gwladys St. Glory, Johnnytotal, windymiller, arch stanton, allen, and Davideeyore discuss the sand filling process and related topics.
October 14, 2021: Users Johnnytotal, ste d' indica, and Bungle humorously refer to vessels in the dock as potential "enemies."
November 24, 2021: Users tommye and ste d' indica discuss why the sand stays in the dock during the filling process.
November 29-30, 2021: Users tommye and ste d' indica engage in personal insults.
December 31, 2021: Users BullensRoad and MickA discuss the lighting regulations for the stadium in relation to shipping.
March 4, 2022: Users BNJ1878 and Exeter_Gently comment on speculation and the connection with Alisher Usmanov.
December 29, 2022: Humorous and suggestive exchanges between tommye, matty1878, and Daytripper.
February 21, 2023: Users DualityNSNO and Dixieslaces intervene in a potential bullying situation. MaupsGoat shares a gym view, leading to a definition of "hess hessing."
March 16, 2023: Users TrailerTrash and ste d' indica discuss the possibility of a ferry service to the stadium and humorous anecdotes about car minders.
March 24, 2023: Users Toffeeslam and Stephen Gibson discuss purchasing bricks for Everton Way, with humorous intent towards Bill Kenwright.
April 17, 2023: Users Jacko93 and Toffeeslam discuss the possibility of selling the club and the stadium.
May 1, 2023: Users tonka1878 and BNJ1878 engage in banter about a potential "treble" and tonka1878's medical prescriptions.
May 7-8, 2023: Users Johnnytotal, tommye, DualityNSNO, and tonka1878 have a series of sarcastic and insulting exchanges regarding the stadium's construction and Johnnytotal's comments.
May 26, 2023: Users BlueStevie35 and suave 1878 comment on someone being a "pillock." BNJ1878 and Fred85Efc have a heated exchange regarding rumors of work halting due to unpaid installments.
September 9, 2024: Users Exeter_Gently and goldfinchmule engage in brief banter.
September 19, 2024: Users tr_efc, Rich1878, Ruairi77, and Connor mcloud discuss a photo of the stadium and the idea of a ferry service.
October 3, 2024: Users matty1878 and Toffeeslam discuss rumors of land purchase for potential expansion.
October 11, 2024: Users Damo_1878 and tommye have a hostile exchange, with Damo_1878 reporting tommye's post. Scarecrow and goldfinchmule make brief comments.
October 23, 2024: Users Infernus, GoldenToffee, and tommye discuss security concerns for bikes outside the stadium.
November 10, 2024: Users edwardcrompton and tommye have a terse exchange about the stadium's atmosphere.
November 19, 2024: Users Jacko93, allen, matty1878, Exeter_Gently, and AndyRJ discuss the potential impact of stand orientation on sunlight.
January 11, 2025: Users Charles Plastusz, Connor mcloud, kev, and Tipp blue comment on the frozen docks and the possibility of stadium tours.
January 17, 2025: Users matty1878 and dockroad discuss the use of the word "tranche."
January 21, 2025: Users mickefc, Toffeelover, and allen discuss the meaning of "pants."
January 25, 2025: Users welshtoffee, The binman chronicles, kev, and davek discuss the amenities around the stadium and rumors about Dave's access.
January 27, 2025: Users allen, Wizard, gedefc, and maccavennie discuss trademark filings and the view from different tiers of the stadium.
January 29, 2025: Users Dutch Toffee and tommye discuss the availability of Everton Way bricks.
February 6, 2025: Users toffeeblue9, The Littlest Yobo, Budweiser, InBev, Corona, San Miguel, Exeter_Gently, and Jimishorts discuss potential beer offerings at the stadium and cycling to matches.
February 17, 2025: Users gmb, ste d' indica, aj79, 1878SC, Marius57, Exeter_Gently, PKwalnuts, and GrandOldTeam discuss development in the surrounding area, circulation within the stadium, and a request to photoshop a wall blue.
New Everton Stadium Forum Posts Timeline:
April 14, 2014: User tenaciousj mentions the North Dock Road - Clarence Dock as a potential stadium location, sharing pictures. ToffeeDan responds that it has been considered previously.September 14, 2014: Discussion revolves around the potential usage of the Goodison Park pitch, with users jinkyali, Brennan, and Pat's Van exchanging comments.
September 16, 2014: Users blulouie, kithnou, toffeejack, and bluemangroup engage in lighthearted banter.
October 30, 2014: User EverBlue86 mentions US businessman John Moores potentially investing in Swansea, expressing concern for Everton's new stadium plans and ownership.
December 4-5, 2014: Users Moomin, Neiler, and arch stanton discuss the concept of club owners loaning money to their own clubs, referencing Mike Ashley's actions with Newcastle and Bill Kenwright.
January 26, 2015: Users kithnou, mrb85, degsy, and LouReedwalkonthewildside discuss the possibility of redeveloping Goodison Park if the club were relegated to the Championship, along with skepticism regarding investment and Bill Kenwright's intentions.
February 16, 2015: Users summerisle and royvernon39 discuss Everton Resources' mining interests in the Dominican Republic. Further discussion involves user interactions and opinions on the club's ownership (blulouie, magicjuan, joey_macmo).
September 18-19, 2016: Users Goat, EFCEFC4LIFE engage in humorous exchanges. Allen provides measurements and analysis of the Bramley Moore Dock (BMD) and Nelson Dock area, questioning the boundaries and inclusion of water. Jacko93 and ToffeeDoug also contribute to the discussion on land purchase and potential heritage issues.
September 22, 2016: Users The Esk, The Cowboy, and maccavennie discuss West Ham's stadium lease conditions and the importance of affordable pricing for Everton's new stadium.
September 28, 2016: Users Sharpys top lip, vintage-toffees, Brennan, Moomin, peatzwaterman, and orly discuss rumors of land purchase for the new stadium, with peatzwaterman citing Land Registry information showing Peel Land and Property still as the owner of BMD.
October 13-14, 2016: Humorous exchanges between users like Boss_Blue, dublinbluenose, Jacko93, davek, Duncan Disordely, Goat, terry nodder, and Frank Gallagher.
October 18, 2016: Users fandjango and davek discuss the potential design and aesthetics of the new stadium.
November 2, 2016: Users Kaiser Soysauce, orly, Sharpys top lip, terry nodder, and The Cowboy anticipate an AGM announcement.
November 16, 2016: Users silent bob and The binman chronicles engage in wordplay regarding the dock location. roydo and boris discuss the timing of land purchase in relation to planning permission. Dario Terracotta mentions "Metro mayor" Steve Rotherham's potential influence.
November 18, 2016: Users orly, tommye, ToffeeDan, and a Deleted member discuss forum "ITK" (In The Know) individuals and rumors.
November 24, 2016: Users Julius Geezer and The binman chronicles discuss puns on the forum and the potential acquisition of a yard near the dock.
November 26, 2016: Brief comments from users Jacko93, GwladysBlue, and peteblue. peteblue and roydo reminisce about the history and potential of Liverpool Docks.
May 3, 2017: Users RaleighBlue and roydo debate the financial sustainability of football broadcasting rights.
May 9, 2017: Humorous exchanges between fandjango and Julius Geezer. User Yarrgh expresses grand ambitions and desires for the new stadium's design and impact.
May 15, 2017: Users Toffeeslam, malcson, bazzer25, and Gob Bluth discuss potential stadium design elements like brick color and shape, with general skepticism.
May 17, 2017: User Exeter Gently expresses hope for a precedent-setting stadium design from Mr. Meis.
June 3-4, 2017: Users ToffeeTim, nsno-chris, Connor, tommye, and TheFinnFan reference "Dan" and expectations for the stadium plans.
June 8, 2017: Humorous exchanges between nsno-chris, Ernie, OneTrueLegend, Stephen Gibson, and orly involving blue slush puppies and potentially inappropriate images.
June 21, 2017: Users The binman chronicles, banno, orly, and kev engage in banter about forum rumors and "ITK" individuals.
June 29-30, 2017: Users nsno-chris, ianefc, James Patrick, and mrb85 discuss the potential smell around the Bramley Moore Dock location.
July 1, 2017: User Bluelad1878 suggests a phased construction for the stadium's end sections and asks @MorgsGoat to arrange this with Dan Meis.
July 27, 2017: Users TommyDavo, peteblue, and orly discuss the release of stadium planning application drawings.
August 14, 2018: Users davek, roydo, and Frang discuss the situation with Alisher Usmanov and his connection to Arsenal and geopolitical events.
September 11-12, 2018: Users Goat, roydo, orly, Brisan123, peteblue, WA Toffee, Baldynut, Eggs, and davek discuss potential funding and shareholder changes, with some skepticism and humorous remarks.
October 2, 2018: Users Pabbers and deipnosophist comment on their changing opinions and a humorous discussion about the geometry of trapeziums.
November 11, 2018: Users degsy, Baldynut, jackyboy, and Toffeelover discuss the feasibility and methods of filling in Bramley Moore Dock, considering the dock walls and adjacent docks.
November 16-17, 2018: Users blulouie, GrandOldTeam, toffee-boy, WA Toffee, and mccole engage in discussions about filling in the dock and the sensitive topic of gender-neutral toilets at the new stadium.
December 16, 2018: Users dockroad, summerisle, deipnosophist, Goat, Azza, and MarcelsGoat discuss "skinny lager" and its characteristics.
November 27, 2019: Users Barry Rathbone and malfosse express concerns about the financial implications of a new stadium amidst potential team struggles.
May 5, 2020: Users roydo, H.H., Lanolin, and tommye discuss Alisher Usmanov's potential involvement in funding the stadium and UEFA Financial Fair Play regulations.
June 2, 2020: User tjf suggests potential delays to the stadium project timeline.
June 5, 2020: Users TommyDavo and Tommy. discuss potential delays to enabling works due to UNESCO challenges and engage in humorous banter.
June 21, 2020: Users BNJ1878 and cronullasharks have a confusing exchange.
September 16, 2021: Humorous exchanges between marnie and tommye regarding forum interactions, and Sinski comments on Dave's negativity.
September 29, 2021: Users tommytowne and ForeverBlue92 humorously describe the conditions of the toilets at Goodison Park. roydo is mentioned as a frequent poster.
October 1, 2021: Users Johnnytotal, marnie, dublinbluenose, and devo85 discuss sand delivery to the dock, with devo85 outlining the process.
October 8, 2021: Users Gwladys St. Glory, Johnnytotal, windymiller, arch stanton, allen, and Davideeyore discuss the sand filling process and related topics.
October 14, 2021: Users Johnnytotal, ste d' indica, and Bungle humorously refer to vessels in the dock as potential "enemies."
November 24, 2021: Users tommye and ste d' indica discuss why the sand stays in the dock during the filling process.
November 29-30, 2021: Users tommye and ste d' indica engage in personal insults.
December 31, 2021: Users BullensRoad and MickA discuss the lighting regulations for the stadium in relation to shipping.
March 4, 2022: Users BNJ1878 and Exeter_Gently comment on speculation and the connection with Alisher Usmanov.
December 29, 2022: Humorous and suggestive exchanges between tommye, matty1878, and Daytripper.
February 21, 2023: Users DualityNSNO and Dixieslaces intervene in a potential bullying situation. MaupsGoat shares a gym view, leading to a definition of "hess hessing."
March 16, 2023: Users TrailerTrash and ste d' indica discuss the possibility of a ferry service to the stadium and humorous anecdotes about car minders.
March 24, 2023: Users Toffeeslam and Stephen Gibson discuss purchasing bricks for Everton Way, with humorous intent towards Bill Kenwright.
April 17, 2023: Users Jacko93 and Toffeeslam discuss the possibility of selling the club and the stadium.
May 1, 2023: Users tonka1878 and BNJ1878 engage in banter about a potential "treble" and tonka1878's medical prescriptions.
May 7-8, 2023: Users Johnnytotal, tommye, DualityNSNO, and tonka1878 have a series of sarcastic and insulting exchanges regarding the stadium's construction and Johnnytotal's comments.
May 26, 2023: Users BlueStevie35 and suave 1878 comment on someone being a "pillock." BNJ1878 and Fred85Efc have a heated exchange regarding rumors of work halting due to unpaid installments.
September 9, 2024: Users Exeter_Gently and goldfinchmule engage in brief banter.
September 19, 2024: Users tr_efc, Rich1878, Ruairi77, and Connor mcloud discuss a photo of the stadium and the idea of a ferry service.
October 3, 2024: Users matty1878 and Toffeeslam discuss rumors of land purchase for potential expansion.
October 11, 2024: Users Damo_1878 and tommye have a hostile exchange, with Damo_1878 reporting tommye's post. Scarecrow and goldfinchmule make brief comments.
October 23, 2024: Users Infernus, GoldenToffee, and tommye discuss security concerns for bikes outside the stadium.
November 10, 2024: Users edwardcrompton and tommye have a terse exchange about the stadium's atmosphere.
November 19, 2024: Users Jacko93, allen, matty1878, Exeter_Gently, and AndyRJ discuss the potential impact of stand orientation on sunlight.
January 11, 2025: Users Charles Plastusz, Connor mcloud, kev, and Tipp blue comment on the frozen docks and the possibility of stadium tours.
January 17, 2025: Users matty1878 and dockroad discuss the use of the word "tranche."
January 21, 2025: Users mickefc, Toffeelover, and allen discuss the meaning of "pants."
January 25, 2025: Users welshtoffee, The binman chronicles, kev, and davek discuss the amenities around the stadium and rumors about Dave's access.
January 27, 2025: Users allen, Wizard, gedefc, and maccavennie discuss trademark filings and the view from different tiers of the stadium.
January 29, 2025: Users Dutch Toffee and tommye discuss the availability of Everton Way bricks.
February 6, 2025: Users toffeeblue9, The Littlest Yobo, Budweiser, InBev, Corona, San Miguel, Exeter_Gently, and Jimishorts discuss potential beer offerings at the stadium and cycling to matches.
February 17, 2025: Users gmb, ste d' indica, aj79, 1878SC, Marius57, Exeter_Gently, PKwalnuts, and GrandOldTeam discuss development in the surrounding area, circulation within the stadium, and a request to photoshop a wall blue.
Cast of Characters with Brief Bios:
- tenaciousj: An early forum poster who, in April 2014, suggested the North Dock Road - Clarence Dock as a potential stadium location.
- ToffeeDan (in memoriam - 1961-2023): A forum member who responded to tenaciousj's suggestion, noting it had been considered before. His username indicates he passed away in 2023.
- jinkyali: A forum user involved in discussions about the potential usage of Goodison Park in September 2014.
- Brennan: A user who engaged in discussions about the practicality of using the existing pitch frequently in September 2014.
- Pat's Van: A forum member who supported jinkyali's point in the September 2014 discussion.
- blulouie: A user who participated in lighthearted banter in September and February 2015.
- kithnou: A user who commented on stadium plans in September 2014 and January 2015, expressing skepticism.
- toffeejack: A user involved in lighthearted banter in September 2014.
- bluemangroup: A user who made a humorous comment in September 2014.
- EverBlue86: A user who expressed concern about potential new ownership and the stadium plans in October 2014.
- John Moores: A US businessman mentioned in October 2014 as potentially investing in Swansea, which raised concerns among Everton fans about investment in their club.
- Moomin: A user who discussed club ownership and loans in December 2014 and rumors in September 2016.
- Neiler: A user who discussed the financial aspects of club ownership with Moomin in December 2014.
- Mike Ashley: The owner of Newcastle United at the time, referenced in December 2014 for his financial dealings with the club.
- Bill Kenwright: The Chairman of Everton at the time, frequently mentioned with a degree of skepticism regarding investment and the new stadium.
- arch stanton: A user who provided insight into business loans and club finances in December 2014.
- mrb85: A user who discussed the potential for redeveloping Goodison Park if relegated in January 2015 and the smell around BMD in June 2017.
- degsy: A user who expressed skepticism about false dawns and Kenwright's intentions in January 2015 and the dock filling process in November 2018.
- LouReedwalkonthewildside: A user who shared degsy's skepticism about the club's progress in January 2015.
- summerisle: A user who mentioned Everton Resources' mining interests in February 2015 and later discussed skinny lager in December 2018.
- royvernon39 (in memoriam - 1965-2024): A user who commented on summerisle's post in February 2015 and later discussed the docks in November 2016 and funding in May and September 2018.
- magicjuan: A user involved in a brief exchange in February 2015.
- joey_macmo: A user who defended Bill Kenwright against some criticisms in February 2015.
- Goat: A user known for humorous interjections, particularly in September 2016 and December 2018.
- EFCEFC4LIFE: A user who engaged in humorous exchanges with Goat in September 2016.
- allen: A user who provided detailed analysis of the Bramley Moore Dock area in September 2016 and later discussed sand dredging in October 2021 and trademark filings in January 2025.
- Jacko93: A user who commented on the nature of the land deal in September 2016 and the potential sale of the club in April 2023.
- ToffeeDoug: A user who also analyzed the dock area in September 2016.
- The Esk: A user who provided information about West Ham's stadium lease in September 2016.
- The Cowboy: A user who made a sarcastic remark about West Ham's ticket allocation in September 2016 and anticipated an AGM announcement in November 2016.
- maccavennie: A user who expressed optimism about the new stadium's impact in September 2016 and the stadium tiers in January 2025.
- Sharpys top lip: A user who dismissed rumors in September and November 2016.
- vintage-toffees: A user who shared hearing about a potential land purchase in September 2016.
- peatzwaterman: A user who checked the Land Registry for ownership of Bramley Moore Dock in September 2016.
- orly: A user who frequently commented on forum rumors and "ITK" individuals, as well as more lighthearted banter, between September 2016 and July 2017.
- Boss_Blue: A user who made a brief, suggestive comment in October 2016.
- dublinbluenose: A user who responded to Boss_Blue in October 2016 and commented on sand delivery in October 2021.
- davek: A user who participated in discussions about stadium design in October 2016, shareholder changes in September 2018, and access during test events in January 2025.
- Duncan Disordely: A user who cautioned davek about falling for forum wind-ups in October 2016.
- terry nodder: A user involved in humorous exchanges in October and November 2016.
- Frank Gallagher: A user who made a vivid and humorous comment about a potential Moshiri statue in October 2016.
- fandjango: A user who discussed stadium aesthetics in October 2016 and humorous anecdotes in May 2017.
- Kaiser Soysauce: A user involved in a brief, humorous exchange in November 2016.
- silent bob: A user who engaged in wordplay related to the dock location in November 2016.
- The binman chronicles: A user who continued the wordplay in November 2016 and discussed potential land purchase and stadium capacity in June 2017 and amenities in January 2025.
- roydo (in memoriam - 1965-2024): (Repeated, likely a very active user).
- boris: A user who commented on the timing of land purchase in November 2016.
- Dario Terracotta: A user who mentioned Steve Rotherham's potential influence in November 2016.
- Steve Rotherham: The "Metro mayor" mentioned in November 2016, potentially relevant to planning permissions.
- tommye: A very active user known for strong opinions, humorous (and sometimes offensive) banter, and claims of inside information, appearing frequently throughout the timeline.
- Deleted member 41045: A user who responded to orly in November 2016.
- Julius Geezer: A user known for puns and lighthearted comments in November 2016 and May 2017.
- Gardocki: A user who made a self-deprecating remark in November 2016.
- Jacko93: (Repeated).
- GwladysBlue: A user who made a comment about defeat and news in November 2016.
- peteblue: A user who reminisced about the docks in November 2016 and discussed planning applications in July 2017 and shareholder changes in September 2018.
- RaleighBlue: A user who debated financial matters in May 2017.
- Kal El: A user involved in a brief, humorous exchange in May 2017.
- Yarrgh: A user who expressed ambitious desires for the new stadium in May 2017.
- Toffeeslam: A user who discussed stadium design elements like brick color and the potential sale of the club in May 2017 and April 2023.
- malcson: A user who expressed a preference against red brick in May 2017.
- bazzer25: A user who questioned the shape of the new stadium in May 2017.
- Gob Bluth: A user who expressed skepticism in May 2017.
- Exeter Gently: A user who hoped for a unique stadium design in May 2017 and commented on Usmanov and cycling in February 2025.
- Mr. Meis (likely Dan Meis): The architect or designer expected to be involved in the new stadium project, mentioned in May 2017.
- ToffeeTim: A user who made a lighthearted comment about boats in June 2017.
- nsno-chris: A user who referenced "Dan" and expectations in June 2017 and engaged in humorous banter in June 2017.
- Connor: A user who agreed with nsno-chris in June 2017 and commented on photos in January 2025.
- TheFinnFan: A user who commented on persistence and "ITK" in June 2017.
- Ernie: A user who reacted humorously in June 2017.
- Stephen Gibson: A user who commented on slush puppy flavors in June 2017 and brick inscriptions in March 2023.
- OneTrueLegend: A user who suggested blueberry slush puppies in June 2017.
- banno: A user who provided a numerical reference in June 2017.
- kev: A user who engaged in humorous banter and commented on test events in June 2017 and January 2025.
- ianefc: A user who reacted humorously in June 2017.
- James Patrick: A user who repeatedly mentioned the potential smell around Bramley Moore Dock in June 2017.
- Bluelad1878: A user who suggested phased construction in July 2017.
- MorgsGoat (likely a forum admin/moderator): Mentioned in July 2017 and December 2022.
- TommyDavo: A user who claimed to have seen planning application drawings in July 2017 and mentioned UNESCO challenges in June 2020.
- MarcelsGoat: A user who provided information about skinny lager in December 2018.
- Frang: A user who made a humorous remark about davek's geopolitical analysis in August 2018.
- Brisan123: A user referenced by orly in September 2018 and who made a comment about safety in September 2024.
- WA Toffee: A user who discussed forum "WUMs" in September and November 2018.
- Baldynut: A user who was mentioned as being on ignore in September 2018 and commented on dock walls in November 2018.
- Eggs: A user who commented on shareholder changes in September 2018 and potential trouble from rival fans in November 2016.
- Pabbers: A user who changed his mind about the stadium happening in October 2018.
- deipnosophist: A user who engaged in a humorous discussion about trapeziums in October 2018 and skinny lager in December 2018.
- jackyboy: A user who apologized for misinformation about ground progress in November 2018.
- Toffeelover: A user who discussed the complexities of filling the dock in November 2018 and the quality of the stadium in January 2025.
- GrandOldTeam (Moderator): A forum moderator who made comments in November 2018 and February 2025.
- toffee-boy: A user who expressed concern about planning permission in November 2018.
- mccole: A user who discussed toilet provisions at the new stadium in November 2018.
- dockroad: A user who discussed skinny lager and the meaning of "tranche" in December 2018 and January 2025.
- Azza: A user who commented on a stand design in December 2018.
- Barry Rathbone: A user who expressed concerns about the financial risks of a new stadium in November 2019.
- malfosse: A user who made a comment about "little bells" in November 2019.
- H.H.: A user who questioned the nature of financial support in May 2020.
- Lanolin: A user who defended the club against FFP concerns in May 2020.
- RobSpurs: A user from a rival club who raised concerns about stadium funding and FFP in May 2020.
- tjf: A user who suggested delays to the project in June 2020.
- Tommy.: A user who shared a humorous anecdote about firefighters in June 2020.
- firefighterblue: A user whose comment prompted the anecdote in June 2020.
- BNJ1878: A user who engaged in confusing and confrontational exchanges in June 2020 and May 2023, and rumors in May 2026.
- cronullasharks: A user who had a confusing exchange with BNJ1878 in June 2020 and made inappropriate comments in September 2021.
- marnie: A user who engaged in banter in September and October 2021.
- Sinski: A user who commented on forum negativity in September 2021.
- tommytowne: A user who described the state of the toilets at Goodison Park in September 2021.
- ForeverBlue92: A user whose comment prompted the toilet description in September 2021.
- Johnnytotal: A user known for sometimes controversial or seemingly obtuse comments, particularly regarding the stadium construction, in October 2021 and May 2023.
- dublinbluenose: (Repeated).
- devo85: A user who provided details about the sand filling process in October 2021.
- Gwladys St. Glory: A user who made a humorous comment about rival fans' tears in October 2021.
- windymiller: A user who commented on the sand compaction process in October 2021.
- arch stanton: (Repeated).
- Davideeyore: A user who made a brief comment about bricks in October 2021.
- ste d' indica: A user known for humorous and sometimes sarcastic remarks, particularly in October and November 2021, March 2023, and February 2025.
- Bungle: A user who made a humorous comment about vessels in the dock in October 2021.
- BullensRoad: A user who discussed stadium lighting in December 2021 and rumors in May 2023.
- Moderatelywarmwater: A user who asked for clarification in March 2022.
- Exeter_Gently: (Repeated).
- matty1878: A user known for frequent posting and sometimes nonsensical or suggestive comments, appearing in December 2022, October and November 2024, and January 2025.
- Daytripper: A user who commented on the interaction between tommye and matty1878 in December 2022.
- DualityNSNO: A user who intervened in a potential bullying situation in February 2023 and made a sarcastic comment in May 2023.
- Dixieslaces: A user who responded to MaupsGoat in February 2023.
- MaupsGoat: A user who shared a gym view in February 2023.
- TrailerTrash: A user who suggested a ferry service in March 2023.
- GoldenToffee: A user who made a humorous remark about car minders in March 2023 and raised security concerns in October 2024.
- Mark_EFC: A user who purchased a brick for Everton Way in March 2023.
- tonka1878: A user who engaged in banter about a "treble" and his medical conditions in May 2023.
- LEONARD: A user who expressed excitement in May 2023.
- BlueStevie35: A user who made a comment about someone's persuasion in May 2023.
- suave 1878: A user who pointed out a bank holiday in May 2023.
- Fred85Efc: A user who shared a rumor about work halting in May 2023.
- goldfinchmule: A user who discussed metric threads and pineapple rings in September and October 2024.
- tr_efc: A user who commented on a photo in September 2024.
- Rich1878: A user who shared the breathtaking photo in September 2024.
- Ruairi77: A user who responded to the ferry idea in September 2024.
- Connor mcloud: A user who suggested the ferry idea in September 2024 and commented on frozen docks in January 2025.
- Damo_1878: A user who had a hostile exchange with tommye in October 2024.
- Scarecrow: A user who commented on matty1878's forum activity in October 2024.
- Ferfuxake: A user who apologized for skipping pages in October 2024.
- chunks: A user mentioned by matty1878 in October 2024.
- Jimishorts: A user to whom Scarecrow apologized in October 2024 and who discussed cycling in February 2025.
- Infernus: A user who made a humorous comment about bike security in October 2024.
- edwardcrompton: A user who commented on the stadium's atmosphere in November 2024.
- AndyRJ: A user who commented on stand orientation in November 2024.
- Charles Plastusz: A user who made a humorous comment about David Moyes in January 2025.
- Tipp blue: A user who inquired about stadium tours in January 2025.
- toffee66: A user who provided a definition of "portion" in January 2025.
- mickefc: A user who questioned the meaning of "pants" in January 2025.
- Wizard: A user who shared trademark information in January 2025.
- gedefc: A user who hoped for a good view from the upper tier in January 2025.
- Dutch Toffee: A user who inquired about Everton Way bricks in January 2025.
- toffeeblue9: A user who mentioned potential beer offerings in February 2025.
- The Littlest Yobo: A user who suggested Budweiser as a potential beer option in February 2025.
- gmb: A user who inquired about surrounding development in February 2025.
- aj79: A user who shared information about seating restrictions in February 2025.
- 1878SC: A user who explained how blocks might work within the stadium in February 2025.
- Marius57: A user who mentioned being blocked by someone on the forum in February 2025.
- PKwalnuts: A user who requested a photoshop in February 2025.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
Who started the rumour about the pitch not fitting?
Based on the provided forum excerpts, the worry about the pitch not fitting into the new Everton Stadium seems to have emerged somewhat later in the discussions, after the location at Bramley Moore Dock became more certain. While there might have been earlier, more general concerns about the stadium design and size, the specific worry about the pitch dimensions appears to gain traction in early 2022.
Specifically, the user Johnnytotal seems to be a prominent early voice expressing doubt about the pitch fitting correctly within the stadium footprint.
While other users also pick up on this concern and make jokes or express similar worries, Johnnytotal appears to be one of the earliest, if not the first, in the provided excerpts to articulate a specific worry, backed by some rough calculations, about whether a regulation-sized football pitch would comfortably fit within the new stadium at Bramley Moore Dock. This worry persists among some users for a significant period, even as the stadium construction progresses and the pitch installation nears. By February 2025, after pitch lines have been drawn, there are mentions of these earlier worries being hopefully put to rest.
Based on the provided forum excerpts, the worry about the pitch not fitting into the new Everton Stadium seems to have emerged somewhat later in the discussions, after the location at Bramley Moore Dock became more certain. While there might have been earlier, more general concerns about the stadium design and size, the specific worry about the pitch dimensions appears to gain traction in early 2022.
Specifically, the user Johnnytotal seems to be a prominent early voice expressing doubt about the pitch fitting correctly within the stadium footprint.
- On February 3, 2022, Johnnytotal states, "Still not convinced it can fit a football pitch East to west". This post is a clear expression of concern regarding the pitch size in relation to the stadium dimensions.
- Later on February 4, 2022, Johnnytotal provides more detailed calculations, saying: "I think it's touch and go myself. 105m pitch 2m touchline lines x 2 2m path around pitch x 2 Leaves 41m either end for fans in seats 0.5m per row ? Concourse? Bars? Sounds iffy". This post elaborates on the initial worry with a breakdown of potential space constraints.
- Johnnytotal continues to express this doubt in subsequent posts throughout February 2022 and even later in 2023.
While other users also pick up on this concern and make jokes or express similar worries, Johnnytotal appears to be one of the earliest, if not the first, in the provided excerpts to articulate a specific worry, backed by some rough calculations, about whether a regulation-sized football pitch would comfortably fit within the new stadium at Bramley Moore Dock. This worry persists among some users for a significant period, even as the stadium construction progresses and the pitch installation nears. By February 2025, after pitch lines have been drawn, there are mentions of these earlier worries being hopefully put to rest.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
An FAQ on the new development (using only this thread as a source)
The new stadium is being constructed at Bramley-Moore Dock, located on the waterfront along the River Mersey in Liverpool. This site is part of the larger North Docks regeneration project. Early discussions in the forum (around 2014) identify this location as a potential site that had been considered previously.
2. When was the idea of a new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock first seriously discussed by fans in this forum?
Based on the provided excerpts, discussions about the North Dock Road/Clarence Dock (which appears to be an early consideration of the Bramley-Moore Dock area) were taking place as early as April 2014. By September 2016, there were detailed discussions about the specific Bramley-Moore Dock site, including land acreage, potential inclusion of water areas in the purchase, and logistical considerations.
3. What were some of the initial reactions and concerns raised by fans regarding the Bramley-Moore Dock location?
Initial reactions were a mix of excitement about a potential "statement" location on the waterfront and concerns about various aspects. These included the potential for red tape and planning permission challenges, especially concerning the dock's history and potential UNESCO implications. There were also practical questions about whether the land deal would include the water area of the dock and the feasibility of filling it in. Some fans also expressed skepticism based on past failed stadium proposals.
4. How did fan discussions evolve regarding the design and features of the new stadium?
As the project progressed, fan discussions moved towards the desired design and features. There was a strong sentiment for a stadium that would be iconic and set a new standard, rather than a generic "bowl" design. Ideas included incorporating Everton's history and the city's maritime heritage into the architecture. Fans also debated practical aspects like stadium capacity, pricing for families, and the overall matchday experience. There were even specific suggestions regarding brick color (royal blue) and the inclusion of fan tributes like personalized bricks.
5. What were some of the financial aspects and potential investors discussed by the forum members?
Discussions touched on the complexities of funding, potential investors (including early mentions of John Moores and later more prominent figures like Moshiri and Usmanov), and the nature of loans and investments in the club. Fans debated whether the club was for sale or seeking investment and analyzed the implications of owner financing. There were also concerns raised about Financial Fair Play (FFP) regulations and the scrutiny of stadium funding and sponsorships.
6. How did the progress of the stadium development (e.g., land purchase, planning permission, construction) feature in the forum discussions?
The forum served as a space for fans to share and analyze news and rumors regarding the stadium's progress. Members discussed the land registry status, the granting of planning permission, and the commencement of enabling works like sand dredging. There was often speculation about timelines, potential delays (e.g., due to UNESCO), and the significance of official announcements versus unofficial "inside information." The forum also captured the growing anticipation as construction became more visible.
7. What role did humor, banter, and fan culture play in the forum discussions about the new stadium?
Humor, banter, and strong expressions of fan culture were pervasive throughout the forum discussions. Members frequently used playful insults ("kopite," "wham"), in-jokes, and football-related humor to comment on news, rumors, and each other's posts. There were running gags, playful disagreements, and a strong sense of collective identity and passion for Everton. Even serious topics were often interspersed with lighthearted exchanges, reflecting the social nature of the online community.
8. As the stadium construction progressed, what were some of the more recent topics of discussion among the fans in the forum?
More recent discussions (leading up to late 2024/early 2025) focused on the tangible progress of the stadium, such as photos of the construction, discussions about the internal layout and features (like potential segregation of supporters in different blocks), and practical considerations for attending matches at the new ground, including transport (ferry possibilities), security (bike theft), and the surrounding area's development. There was also anticipation about test events and potential stadium tours.
Frequently Asked Questions: The New Everton Stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock
1. Where is the new Everton stadium being built?The new stadium is being constructed at Bramley-Moore Dock, located on the waterfront along the River Mersey in Liverpool. This site is part of the larger North Docks regeneration project. Early discussions in the forum (around 2014) identify this location as a potential site that had been considered previously.
2. When was the idea of a new stadium at Bramley-Moore Dock first seriously discussed by fans in this forum?
Based on the provided excerpts, discussions about the North Dock Road/Clarence Dock (which appears to be an early consideration of the Bramley-Moore Dock area) were taking place as early as April 2014. By September 2016, there were detailed discussions about the specific Bramley-Moore Dock site, including land acreage, potential inclusion of water areas in the purchase, and logistical considerations.
3. What were some of the initial reactions and concerns raised by fans regarding the Bramley-Moore Dock location?
Initial reactions were a mix of excitement about a potential "statement" location on the waterfront and concerns about various aspects. These included the potential for red tape and planning permission challenges, especially concerning the dock's history and potential UNESCO implications. There were also practical questions about whether the land deal would include the water area of the dock and the feasibility of filling it in. Some fans also expressed skepticism based on past failed stadium proposals.
4. How did fan discussions evolve regarding the design and features of the new stadium?
As the project progressed, fan discussions moved towards the desired design and features. There was a strong sentiment for a stadium that would be iconic and set a new standard, rather than a generic "bowl" design. Ideas included incorporating Everton's history and the city's maritime heritage into the architecture. Fans also debated practical aspects like stadium capacity, pricing for families, and the overall matchday experience. There were even specific suggestions regarding brick color (royal blue) and the inclusion of fan tributes like personalized bricks.
5. What were some of the financial aspects and potential investors discussed by the forum members?
Discussions touched on the complexities of funding, potential investors (including early mentions of John Moores and later more prominent figures like Moshiri and Usmanov), and the nature of loans and investments in the club. Fans debated whether the club was for sale or seeking investment and analyzed the implications of owner financing. There were also concerns raised about Financial Fair Play (FFP) regulations and the scrutiny of stadium funding and sponsorships.
6. How did the progress of the stadium development (e.g., land purchase, planning permission, construction) feature in the forum discussions?
The forum served as a space for fans to share and analyze news and rumors regarding the stadium's progress. Members discussed the land registry status, the granting of planning permission, and the commencement of enabling works like sand dredging. There was often speculation about timelines, potential delays (e.g., due to UNESCO), and the significance of official announcements versus unofficial "inside information." The forum also captured the growing anticipation as construction became more visible.
7. What role did humor, banter, and fan culture play in the forum discussions about the new stadium?
Humor, banter, and strong expressions of fan culture were pervasive throughout the forum discussions. Members frequently used playful insults ("kopite," "wham"), in-jokes, and football-related humor to comment on news, rumors, and each other's posts. There were running gags, playful disagreements, and a strong sense of collective identity and passion for Everton. Even serious topics were often interspersed with lighthearted exchanges, reflecting the social nature of the online community.
8. As the stadium construction progressed, what were some of the more recent topics of discussion among the fans in the forum?
More recent discussions (leading up to late 2024/early 2025) focused on the tangible progress of the stadium, such as photos of the construction, discussions about the internal layout and features (like potential segregation of supporters in different blocks), and practical considerations for attending matches at the new ground, including transport (ferry possibilities), security (bike theft), and the surrounding area's development. There was also anticipation about test events and potential stadium tours.
Jacko93
Player Valuation: £35m
Based on the provided excerpts from the "New Everton Stadium forum posts," it's challenging to definitively quantify who the absolute biggest contributors, most positive, most negative, or most humorous users are without analyzing the entire 8000+ pages. However, we can identify some users who appear frequently and exhibit tendencies towards these categories within the given extracts.
Frequent Contributors:
Several usernames appear multiple times throughout the excerpts, suggesting they are active participants in the forum. Some of these include:
Potentially Most Positive:
Potentially Most Negative:
Potentially Most Humorous:
Humor is subjective, but some instances of banter and lightheartedness include:
It's important to remember that these are just snapshots based on the provided excerpts. A more comprehensive analysis of the entire forum would be needed to definitively identify the key figures in each category.
Frequent Contributors:
Several usernames appear multiple times throughout the excerpts, suggesting they are active participants in the forum. Some of these include:
- kithnou: Appears in excerpts from 2014 and 2015.
- tommye: Appears across multiple years from 2015 to 2025.
- davek: Is present from 2016 to 2025 and seems to offer commentary frequently.
- roydo: Appears from 2015 to 2021.
- orly: Active in 2017.
- The binman chronicles: Present from 2018 to 2025.
- allen: Appears from 2020 to 2025.
- Tom Hughes: Active from 2021 to 2025 and often engages in detailed discussions.
- Groucho: As a moderator, this user appears periodically to manage discussions.
Potentially Most Positive:
- Users expressing excitement at the prospect of a new stadium in the early days, such as TheFinnFan who posted "HELLLLLL YESSSSS" when the forum for the new stadium was created.
- Jacko93 seemed optimistic about an imminent announcement regarding the stadium in 2015.
- Users expressing strong belief in the project happening later on, such as peteblue stating in 2020, "Anyone who thinks this isn’t going to happen is sadly mistaken.....".
- Toffeelover expressed strong positive sentiment in 2024, stating "BMD will be THE STADIUM of the PL".
Potentially Most Negative:
- Users expressing skepticism or doubt about the project over the years. For example, in 2016, Not convinced you have a mate tbh responded to an overly optimistic post.
- davek often presents a more cautious and sometimes critical perspective, frequently mentioning funding concerns and questioning official communications. In 2016, davek and swright1990 seemed doubtful of information being shared.
- arch stanton expressed cynicism about fan surveys having any real impact.
- IllinoisBlue noted in 2017 that DaveK is more of a "'stadium half empty' than 'stadium half full' guy".
- Users expressing frustration with the lack of progress or information, such as peteblue in 2018 lamenting the lack of communication from key figures.
Potentially Most Humorous:
Humor is subjective, but some instances of banter and lightheartedness include:
- The initial exchange between kithnou and Warwick Hunt referencing Martin Jol's brother.
- The discussion about the thread potentially running longer than "Corrie".
- degsy's sarcastic remark to kithnou about "creeping round looking for a mods job".
- The playful exchange between tommye and others involving "lollol".
- The suggestion of a "SATNAV" accolade for The Esk after a directional blunder.
- Various users making light of the forum discussions and the emotional investment of posters.
- Exeter_Gently making a self-aware comment about the "points scoring thread" in 2024.
- The humorous suggestions for stone inscriptions.
It's important to remember that these are just snapshots based on the provided excerpts. A more comprehensive analysis of the entire forum would be needed to definitively identify the key figures in each category.
tonka1878
Player Valuation: £20m
I think you have too much time on your hands?
The new owners should buy as much of the waterway as they can and with as little change as needed use if as a dock for a ferry service from all along the Wirral because the land on that side is probably cheaper and the Club could run 4/5 free Ferry's.
brieverton
Player Valuation: £50m
Wow to all that. Never seen anything like it, can't say never read anything like it, as I havent got a month to spare.
Look to the future
Player Valuation: £5m
AI?
Welcome
Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.
Shop
