Paul Robinson: should he retain his place

[monty]

Robinson has made a series of pathetic blunders over the last 12 months much to the astonishment of most fans. Does he really deserve a place in the international team.? If I had my way Scot Carson would be given the jersey straight away but how do the rest of you feel about McLarens continued faith in this accident prone clown.

 

[SuitsBlue]

he isnt a bad keeper, and all keepers make blunders. hes the only keeper i can recall scoring in the last 12 months.

whatever happened to ben foster, those watford games did him well.

 

[monty]

he isnt a bad keeper, and all keepers make blunders. hes the only keeper i can recall scoring in the last 12 months.

whatever happened to ben foster, those watford games did him well.

I don't know what became of him Suits, disappeared off the face of the earth, may have gone a First Choice holday to Cuba, enough said

 

[Bruce Wayne]

Ben Foster picked up an injury in pre-season, he'll be out for another few months yet I believe.

Lets face it, none of the other keepers are getting a go because they don't play for one of the 'big clubs'. The only reason Carson is even mentioned is because O'Neill is his manager and people think he's the messiah.

As soon as Foster starts playing regularly for Man Utd he'll be straight into the England side, I guarantee.

 

[FCConnecticut]

I thought he looked mediocre in the world cup and England deserves better for sure, but who? English goal keepers seem to be rare these days, good ones anyway. Christ, aging american keepers can start in the prem these days. How is it you have about a 1000 clubs and nary a good keeper???

 

[monty]

I thought he looked mediocre in the world cup and England deserves better for sure, but who? English goal keepers seem to be rare these days, good ones anyway. Christ, aging american keepers can start in the prem these days. How is it you have about a 1000 clubs and nary a good keeper???

He looked mediocre FC because he was and is. I never thought I'd say this but Calamity James is the better man between the posts. We used to pride ourselves on having the best keepers in the world but since the prem started that claiming has certainly gone up in smoke

 

[zero]

He looked mediocre FC because he was and is. I never thought I'd say this but Calamity James is the better man between the posts. We used to pride ourselves on having the best keepers in the world but since the prem started that claiming has certainly gone up in smoke

Completely Agree. I'd have James 'tween the sticks if I was McLaren.

 

[FCConnecticut]

Now way Calamity James, that dude has bad karma. There has be someone, somewhere playing better than either of them.

 

[atrottel]

Now way Calamity James, that dude has bad karma. There has be someone, somewhere playing better than either of them.

How's Robert Green doing these days? Wasn't he supposed to be there or thereabouts for a while?

 

[TX Bill]

Whoever you get, I think that on his current form, they'd be an improvement over Robinson.

I can't imagine he instills much confidence in his whole team much less the defense.

 

[zero]

English keeper on form...........
.......
......
.....
....

[Poor language removed] me, now there's a puzzle. It would have to be Scott Carson.

 

[loosecranks]

Completely Agree. I'd have James 'tween the sticks if I was McLaren.

I'd have James pierced with sticks.

 

[SuitsBlue]

isnt him at stoke doing well?

 

[monty]

English keeper on form...........
.......
......
.....
....

[Poor language removed] me, now there's a puzzle. It would have to be Scott Carson.

and where did we start?

It is surprising when you think about it, possibly Green of WH but after that boy do you struggle, could explain why Drop'em Robbo has kept the job

 

[loosecranks]

I hear Jags is handy between the sticks.

Jags for England!