Squad Numbers

[McBain]

M David Moyes 10m (if SAF/Wenger were worth 20m say)
24 Tim Howard 5m
13 Iain Turner 1m
33 Stefan Wessels 2m
30 John Ruddy 500k
19 Jorge Nuno Valente 1.5m
3 Leighton Baines 8m
4 Joseph Yobo 8m
29 Patrick Boyle 1.2m
16 Joleon Lescott 6m
15 Alan Stubbs 1.5m
2 Tony Hibbert 1.5m
7 Andy van der Meyde 2m
10 Thomas Gravesen 3m
26 Lee Carsley 1.5m
17 Tim Cahill 8m
16 Phil Jagielka 6m
20 Steven Pienaar 4m
18 Phil Neville 4m
21 Leon Osman 4m
31 Bjarni Thor Vidarsson 1.5m
6 Mikel Arteta 12m
11 James McFadden 7m
22 Aiyegbeni Yakubu 12m
14 James Vaughan 10m
27 Lucas Jutkiewicz 1m
8 Andrew Johnson 10m
28 Victor Anichebe 4m

= 136.2m

What do you think? What would you think our squad is worth?

 

[Neiler]

Em we dont own Grav or Piennar.

Id go a conservetive 120 as i think you undervalued Yobo. But overvalued Ossie McF.

 

[Sim]

If we could get 7M for McFadden I'd be laughing all the way to the bank with that! Also 4M for Anichebe seems a bit high for a player who currently doesnt really look good enough for the prem.

But then Lescott for 6M? I'd say he's worth at least £10 maybe more. Also the following we wouldnt get anything for or just a small compensatory amount:

Wessells
Valente
Stubbs
VDM
Carsley

And I think as much potential as Vaughan has, his injury history would mean we'd never get anywhere near £10M unless he proves himself.

So in all honesty I dont think our squad value is near that figure.

 

[TX Bill]

The only one that really jumped out at me was Lescott. I think he'd easily be closer to 10M than 6M.

That said, you could make a good case for most of the others that they're fairly valued.

 

[zero]

err Arteta I would think we could snatch 16 million easy possibly more.

 

[neonleon]

If we could get 7M for McFadden I'd be laughing all the way to the bank with that! Also 4M for Anichebe seems a bit high for a player who currently doesnt really look good enough for the prem.

But then Lescott for 6M? I'd say he's worth at least £10 maybe more. Also the following we wouldnt get anything for or just a small compensatory amount:

Wessells
Valente
Stubbs
VDM
Carsley

And I think as much potential as Vaughan has, his injury history would mean we'd never get anywhere near £10M unless he proves himself.

So in all honesty I dont think our squad value is near that figure.

agree with above, and I think we'd only sell arteta for 18 plus, as try buying a replacement with anything less.

Lets face it, he's pretty much irreplacable.

 

[Piijt]

Lescott 6m Add another 10m please.
We'd get a lot more than 10m for AJ as well

 

[chicoazul]

Bang them all up on Ebay and see what happens.

Dont expect a bidding war for item 2: Hibbert, Anthony.

 

[TX Bill]

Bang them all up on Ebay and see what happens.

Dont expect a bidding war for item 2: Hibbert, Anthony.

"Sorry, but reserve not yet met."

 

[Dylan]

Which greedy [Poor language removed] set a reserve on Hibbert? You know it won't get met, therefore never sell.

 

[Bainsey]

I think you've over valued the young lads.

Paddy Boyle at £1.3m and he hasnt even played a competitive game lol.

Also Wessels at £2m is to much considering we picked him up at the end of the transfer window for nothing.

 

[McBain]

I think you've over valued the young lads.

Paddy Boyle at £1.3m and he hasnt even played a competitive game lol.

Also Wessels at £2m is to much considering we picked him up at the end of the transfer window for nothing.

Yeah, thats great. So what are they worth then? If if you know Im wrong, what the right answer??

EVERYONE LOOK HERE!! - I know we dont own blah blah and such and such. I know some guys you get for free. DERRR. The simple question is what do you think they are worth? Is a player worth nothing coz u got him on a free? Or is he worth nothing because he was free? So we can sign him to a contract and only sell him for nothing?

Come on peoples. Its not really that complicated.

 

[SuitsBlue]

prices are dictated by how much another club is prepared to pay for a player.

2.5mill marcus bent?

25 mill seba veron?

1.7 mill cahill?

its a [Poor language removed] gamble every which way.....

fabregas on a free.... only wenger.

financial value means [Poor language removed] all, arteta didnt fit at atletico, howard didnt fit at manure, weir was picked up for pocket lint,

There Are No Guarantees In Football.

 

[McBain]

Yeah, thats ok, but you wouldnt say they are worth nothing. Youd say they would have a value. Like if Lescott was bought for 4 mil, but is he worth that now? Its just a valuation exercise. Arteta more that 12mil? no way. See its just what you think they are worth, right now in time.

Why do simple people make simple things complicated! Bah!

I dont mean that in a complicatingly simple way.

 

[Neiler]

Its a difficult to appraise how much a player is worth, it depends on wheather the club want to sell himor not.

Hypothethicly Man U come in for Arteta during next Summer, we reject an offer of 10 mill. Player becomes unhappy, club reaqlises he wants to go, but begin a long drawn out transfer saga, do get the best deal safe in knowledge that they can keep the player or rub Uniteds nose in it to get anything close to 15 mill.

But not taking account any of these varibles id say as before 120 Mill, Fact.