Toffeeslam
Player Valuation: £35m
It doesn’t require “liability” for a crime. Civil and equitable remedies exist.
It may help to put yourself in “Joe’s” shoes.
If Sam lies to you to gain access to your money and then loans that money to Everton, should you not have some right to get it back from Everton?
Now, if Everton owes Sam loan repayments for that same money, should you have rights to the loan repayment?
Note: I’m speaking purely hypothetically. I don’t even know if these things happened or scared TFG. I’ve only said that it’s legally possible. The fraud case makes it at least a possibility.
The club or new owners should be able to pay back the sum to a court and free itself from this matter.
The dispute can go through the courts without holding the club hostage, and Joe and Sam can then duke it out without Everton stuck in the middle.