The Great Player Rating Thread 2023/24

[LocalNative]

Mods delete this muck if it's already been done.

Season ratings for each player that featured 5+ times for us with no comment - I dare someone to disagree and if you're right Ill sort you a meat and potato pie and carling next season.

Without justification:

Pickford: 9.5

Mykoelnko: 6.5
Godfrey: 7
Young: 5
Coleman: 5
Tarkowski: 8.5
Keane: 5
Braithwaite: 9

Gueye: 8.5
Gomes: 6
Garner: 6.5
Onana: 6.5
Doucoure: 8

McNeil: 7.5
Harrison: 7
Danjuma: 5
Dobbin: 5.5

DCL: 8
Beto: 6
Chermiti: 5

Cannot argue with that.

 

[chrismpw]

I bet people will.

 

[Yorkiebars89]

Mods delete this muck if it's already been done.

Season ratings for each player that featured 5+ times for us with no comment - I dare someone to disagree and if you're right Ill sort you a meat and potato pie and carling next season.

Without justification:

Pickford: 9.5

Mykoelnko: 6.5
Godfrey: 7
Young: 5
Coleman: 5
Tarkowski: 8.5
Keane: 5
Braithwaite: 9

Gueye: 8.5
Gomes: 6
Garner: 6.5
Onana: 6.5
Doucoure: 8

McNeil: 7.5
Harrison: 7
Danjuma: 5
Dobbin: 5.5

DCL: 8
Beto: 6
Chermiti: 5

Cannot argue with that.

Young 5 I know for name sakes that seems right however by real terms he's deffo 86

 

[Rita_Poon]

Without justification:

Pickford: 9.5

Mykoelnko: 6.5
Godfrey: 7
Young: 5
Coleman: 5
Tarkowski: 8.5
Keane: 5
Braithwaite: 9

Gueye: 8.5
Gomes: 6
Garner: 6.5
Onana: 6.5
Doucoure: 8

McNeil: 7.5
Harrison: 7
Danjuma: 5
Dobbin: 5.5

DCL: 8
Beto: 6
Chermiti: 5

Without justification is right. Jesus!

 

[RomanReigns]

Mykolenko is at least a 9

 

[Goat]

Pickford: 10

Mykoelnko: 3
Godfrey: 3
Young: 3
Coleman: 3
Tarkowski: 10
Keane: 3
Braithwaite: 10

Gueye: 8.5
Gomes: 3
Garner: 3
Onana: 1
Doucoure: 8

McNeil: 7.5
Harrison: 6
Danjuma: 3
Dobbin: 1

DCL: 11
Beto: 3
Chermiti: 3

 

[Yorkiebars89]

Pickford: 10

Mykoelnko: 3
Godfrey: 3
Young: 3
Coleman: 3
Tarkowski: 10
Keane: 3
Braithwaite: 10

Gueye: 8.5
Gomes: 3
Garner: 3
Onana: 1
Doucoure: 8

McNeil: 7.5
Harrison: 6
Danjuma: 3
Dobbin: 1

DCL: 11
Beto: 3
Chermiti: 3

That's better but Young is getting younger

 

[LocalNative]

Pickford: 10

Mykoelnko: 3
Godfrey: 3
Young: 3
Coleman: 3
Tarkowski: 10
Keane: 3
Braithwaite: 10

Gueye: 8.5
Gomes: 3
Garner: 3
Onana: 1
Doucoure: 8

McNeil: 7.5
Harrison: 6
Danjuma: 3
Dobbin: 1

DCL: 11
Beto: 3
Chermiti: 3

I wish this was the original post. Far better than mine I was far too conservative

Except Godrey. He'd be a 3 but pulled us out of sticky situation in wrong position so get his 7 for that

 

[Goat]

I wish this was the original post. Far better than mine I was far too conservative

Except Godrey. He'd be a 3 but pulled us out of sticky situation in wrong position so get his 7 for that

NSNO mate, you are either a 10 or a 3.

 

[Gwladys St. Glory]

I bet people will.

 

[Eggs]

….’great player’ is a bit wide of the mark.

 

[Zatara]

Mods delete this muck if it's already been done.

Season ratings for each player that featured 5+ times for us with no comment - I dare someone to disagree and if you're right Ill sort you a meat and potato pie and carling next season.

Without justification:

Pickford: 9.5

Mykoelnko: 6.5
Godfrey: 7
Young: 5
Coleman: 5
Tarkowski: 8.5
Keane: 5
Braithwaite: 9

Gueye: 8.5
Gomes: 6
Garner: 6.5
Onana: 6.5
Doucoure: 8

McNeil: 7.5
Harrison: 7
Danjuma: 5
Dobbin: 5.5

DCL: 8
Beto: 6
Chermiti: 5

Cannot argue with that.

Based on the whole season overall games:

Pickford: 9

Mykolenko: 9
Godfrey: 6
Young: 4
Coleman: 2
Tarkowski: 9
Keane: 2
Braithwaite: 9

Gueye: 6.5
Gomes: 3
Garner: 6.5
Onana: 8
Doucoure: 6

McNeil: 7
Harrison: 5.5
Danjuma: 3
Dobbin: 5

DCL: 6.5
Beto: 5
Chermiti: 5.5

 

[ElGato]

Michael Keane DNF

 

[Zezti]

Pickford: 10

Mykolenko: 7
Godfrey: 5
Young: 4
Coleman: 4
Tarkowski: 10
Keane: 2
Braithwaite: 10

Gueye: 7
Gomes: 3
Garner: 5
Onana: 7
Doucoure: 5

McNeil: 7
Harrison: 5
Danjuma: 2
Dobbin: 4

DCL: 6
Beto: 5
Chermiti: 4

 

[MikeH72]

Young - 0
Branthwaite - 10

Everyone else - 5