2023/24 James Garner

[Cameron Manning]

Not everyone...no.



Garner is a solid 6/10 every game. But he has flashes of 7/10 and above.

Love him in our team.




Indeed



Does he go missing or is he strategic and covering space while making interceptions?

Last season his interceptions were up there...when he was 'missing'.

Intelligent player.



Hes a DM naturally so...but most here look back at the Parkinson bite in tackles or all action play of others and arent used to seeing his type of DM.

Its fair. I loved Gattuso.

When he plays the full game,not part time, he might become the player you think he is, and I will appreciate him more, ‘til then I will continue to point out his faults.

 

[Cels]

I like James Garner and rate him as a top player, but I forgot he was playing at times today. Needs to be more consistent really IMHO.

 

[marsh]

I like James Garner and rate him as a top player, but I forgot he was playing at times today. Needs to be more consistent really IMHO.

Seem to appear once Onana came on tried to play actual football

 

[Rodebaard]

Looks better playing with Onana. But his delivery was poor all night I think. Plus aside from Doucoure's open goal, had our best chance that he didn't do enough with.

 

[DanEFC92]

Awful.

 

[maccavennie]

He was poor, really poor.

That effort was so half arsed it was embarrassing.

 

[GrandOldTeam]

I think that's the worst performance he's had for us tonight. If you're going to shoot lad, have some conviction.

Keep him next to Onana.

Drop Gana.

 

[pfim]

He’s been mediocre to poor for a while.

 

[Walken]

I don't think theres any lack of effort but he was really off it

 

[MACCA75]

People were calling for him to be in the England squad a while back! The lad is crap I’m afraid. A minor upgrade on Tom Davies.

 

[blueblood]

He plays best when he’s next to Onana. Gana can play in the games where we’re going to see little of the ball and need to sit back. In home games we need players who can get us forward and get the ball to wingers or a centre forward. Far too negative in team selection again today.

 

[irishgoose]

People were calling for him to be in the England squad a while back! The lad is crap I’m afraid. A minor upgrade on Tom Davies.

Ha when ? Nuts if true and really like him but still nuts

 

[dannyboy]

He very much looks like a player who'd shine in the Championship but just about do a decent job in this league. All this hyperbole of him being some top tier footballer is just because we've been so starved of any quality in this position since Arteta left.

 

[God Benfrey]

I genuinely think he'd be a good right back

 

[Mozza1987]

He has been extremely poor for a while now. Would have dragged him off tonight over Gana.