To be honest with you i did say both were possibilities. My only answer is I prefer to see the good in a player rather than the bad. I'm quite happy for others to differ,This sort of nonsense is perhaps why we hang on to players longer than we should, where other teams would be far more ruthless.
Andre Gomes has had as many bad games for us as he has good, if not more.
In that case, why do you consider him a quality Footballer going through a bad patch? Rather than an average player who had a purple patch?
Otherwise known as “The Osman Rule”