Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

AndyC's car guide...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Today's review is the Audi A3 Sportline

This 70-plate A3 was a 6-speed manual petrol engine model and on an early morning run over to Stamford Bridge near York returned a very creditable 61.9mpg albeit without breaking any speed limits. The steering and brakes are fine, the suspension though felt stiff and transmits every little bump in the road surface into your backside, pot holes definitely need to be avoided !! It's a shame about the harsh ride really as the car is actually quite a nice drive.

This was a four door model finished with grey faux leather interior that was comfortable and with good wipe-clean quality.
All the controls, satnav, radio, phone etc are standard Audi fixtures with USB and USC charging ports beneath the satnav display screen.

If you stray slightly off your lane line, as well as the steering wheel letting you know, there's an audible warning and a visual warning in the instrument cluster that reads "Please take control of steering".

As a small family car, the A3 ticks a number of boxes but, that stiff suspension might not be too good for kids in the back seat.

My marks out of ten...
Comfort 6.5 - due to that suspension issue
Fuel Economy 8
Performance 8
Build Quality 8
Practicality 7

If it's anything like mine Audi let you decide what springs you want when you spec the car. My S-line runs on just 'sports suspension' which is lowered by 15mm as the full S-line option that sits a further 10mm lower again was too hard on a previous car I owned. If you want comfort you could just have the standard unlowered option. Of course this is a trade off as the car looks a lot better without the large gap in the wheel arches and the squatter stance.
 
Possibly of interest to @Chewbacca and @SerenityNigh today's review is another plug-in hybrid, the Audi Q7 E-tron

An almost brand new motor, this Q7 is a petrol-engined, plug-in hybrid model.
It's a really nice drive but, so it should be with a price tag of £60,000+ depending upon specification.
As you'll see in picture 3, the car comes with an array of different charging cables and like other plug-in hybrid/electric cars, depending upon which cable is used will determine how quickly the under-the-boot floor battery cells can be topped up or completely recharged.

The petrol engine returned just under 36mpg on a run from north London to Warrington (picture 4) but as with the Mercedes hybrid reviewed earlier, the self-charging element is in all honesty laughable... see picture 6 as it gained just one mile worth of electric charge in the above journey. I'm told that on a full charge, the Q7 has about 40-50 miles in its battery cells, so it's only really effective in stop start in-town traffic when the car drives on electric to begin with before the engine kicks in from around 10mph.

The seating is comfortable with excellent leg room in the back, and the car is well equipped with all the usual Audi fixtures in terms of climate control, say nav, in-car entertainment etc. Boot space is generous as you would expect from a big SUV, although due to the battery cells, there's no space for a spare wheel.

Steering, brakes and suspension all seem ideally matched to the size and weight of the car, and on a long journey, it's as nice a drive as the MB GLE and Range Rovers reviewed earlier... all though the RR Sport and Vogue have a slighter taller seat height that I personally prefer.

In summary, it's a really nice car but, and it's a huge but for me, as with other plug-in hybrids, the range on electric is poor and if looking for an electric car, right now, Tesla knocks all the hybrids into a cocked hat.

My marks out of ten…
Comfort 8
Fuel Economy 6.5 due to the weight of the battery cells
Performance 8
Build Quality 8
Practicality 8 the hybrid element would reduce this to 6.5/7
 

Attachments

  • Q7e1.webp
    Q7e1.webp
    63.1 KB · Views: 8
  • Q7e2.webp
    Q7e2.webp
    19.9 KB · Views: 7
  • Q7e3.webp
    Q7e3.webp
    44.2 KB · Views: 6
  • Q7e4.webp
    Q7e4.webp
    24.1 KB · Views: 7
  • Q7e5.webp
    Q7e5.webp
    27.8 KB · Views: 7
  • Q7e6.webp
    Q7e6.webp
    27.4 KB · Views: 8
I’m currently looking at 3 options for full EV and 2 are basically the same car

Kia EV6
Hyundai Ioniq5
Polestar 2

all in the low £40k area and 260-300 mile range. The Germans are yet to convince me with their electric efforts (not to mention their current blind spot around aesthetics).
 
I’m currently looking at 3 options for full EV and 2 are basically the same car

Kia EV6
Hyundai Ioniq5
Polestar 2

all in the low £40k area and 260-300 mile range. The Germans are yet to convince me with their electric efforts (not to mention their current blind spot around aesthetics).
I have to agree with what you say about the German attempts at EV, as having driven two different Audi EV and the Mercedes GLE350de, I find all their self-charging rates to be not much short of pathetic.
And their plug-in charging rates and range are equally unimpressive.

More later as I’m in a Tesla X right now and there’s seriously no comparison.
 
Here you go @Chewbacca - Tesla Model X

This car shown is a 19-plate Model X 100D, six-seater SUV in red with black vegan leather interior.
Fitted with the portrait central display screen that controls literally everything in the car from opening the doors to moving the seats, climate control, satnav, entertainment, even internet access... you can catch up on and read the @GrandOldTeam forum whilst charging the battery cells ;)

Approach the car with the car shaped keyfob in your pocket and the drivers door opens itself for you, handy if carrying things, no need to put them down whilst fumbling for your key.
Getting in behind the steering wheel and all you need to do it put your foot on the brake pedal, press the column mounted gearlever down to D and away you go... one pedal driving as you squeeze the accelerator pedal and the car gets off the mark. And it gets off the mark quickly if want it to, even in Chill mode - that equates to Comfort in the likes of Audi/Mercedes etc.

The SatNav offers the choice of either map or Google Earth view and to pan in or out, simply open or squeeze two fingers together as you would on a smartphone or iPad. Using the extensive menu options on the console and you can automatically adjust suspension ride height, seating positions, and a myriad of other screens... and most importantly, you can keep an eye on rate of battery recharge when plugged in.

It takes a few minutes to get acquainted to the system but anyone with an iPad of smartphone will get used to it no time at all.
On the steering wheel are just two rotary controls, the left hand one for the radio/satnav volume adjustment and the right hand one to make telephone calls with your bluetooth enabled phone.

The steering column mounted gear lever, wiper stalk and cruise control are Mercedes stock items and extremely simple to use - good thinking by Tesla in using tried and trusted controls from the German giant.

The seating is comfortable, offers loads of legroom in the front and more than enough in the rear seats as well. With no central transmission tunnel hump, there's plenty of space throughout the interior and the cavernous boot - with the third row of seats lying flat - offers plenty of space for suitcases, luggage, folded pushchairs etc etc. Headroom is fantastic and the swept back windscreen offers a panoramic skylight certainly for the driver and front seat passenger.

Driving the Model X is simplicity itself, you simply press the accelerator pedal to go and because the car is full electric, as soon as you ease off the throttle, the regenerative braking kicks immediately and the car slows down quickly... there is practically no glide as you get with a conventional ICE car. And it's this instant 'engine' braking that's coined the phrase 'one-pedal driving' - as the need to use the brakes is massively reduced, and if you're driving sensibly almost rendered unnecessary, not 100% obviously, but you very quickly get to realise that regenerative braking and the bonus of the self-charging it provides is a massive plus point of electric vehicles.

Steering and the brakes if/when needed are precise and excellent, the (rear) suspension might at first appear to be a bit stiff when driving over a speed hump but that's possibly because the Model X is a heavy car and it might take a little getting used to. Personally, and today was the third decent journey of 200 miles plus I've done in this car, I don't find it stiff but that's maybe just me.

A full charge in this 19-plate Model X showed a 260-mile range and allowing for the use of lights, wipers, heating, satnav, radio etc that all eat into the battery power, you can reasonably expect 210-230 miles on a full charge... unless driving at night in heavy rain, when range might drop to 180-200 miles.

Tesla EVs can be plugged in at any EV charging station but, for optimum charging rates and the quickest charging time, it's always best to hook up to a Tesla Supercharger point such as the one in Picture 2. Connect the cable and then go take a comfort break, buy a cup of coffee, pan through the magazine rack in the services and you can add a hundred miles of charge in about 20-25 minutes.

Now what this means is that longer journeys, 200 miles or more, need a little more planning in order to factor in a recharging stop but if fully charged with 260 miles in the batteries, normal day-to-day running around town and/or short commuting trips should be easily achievable, and leaving charging then until you get home and hooking up to the mains or a home charging unit.

The Tesla Model X is not a cheap car but, you're getting an awful lot of the best EV technology currently available AND you're not contributing toxic exhaust gases into the atmosphere.
I firmly believe electric cars are the way to go, if not right now, they very soon will be as Tesla - in particular as purely an EV car manufacturer - are utterly committed to making EVs cheaper and more affordable in the very near future.

It's not hype but their battery cell technology is considerably ahead of all the major car manufacturers and this is likely to be the case for number of years to come. The Model X is right at the top end of the Tesla range and carries a price tag to match, so it's a lottery win for most of us... the cheaper Model 3, soon to arrive Model Y and the future Model B will be much more affordable and more than worthy of serious, serious consideration.

My marks out of ten…
Comfort 8
Battery Range 7 - remember this is an older 19-plate car and the latest Model X has a 320-340+mile range.
Performance 8.5
Build Quality 8 - Early Tesla cars did have some BQ issues but the current standards are far higher than a few years ago.
Practicality 8 - Spacious, comfortable, clean and massive luggage space.
 

Attachments

  • Tesla X1.webp
    Tesla X1.webp
    76.2 KB · Views: 5
  • Tesla X2.webp
    Tesla X2.webp
    56.6 KB · Views: 6
  • Tesla X3.webp
    Tesla X3.webp
    13.2 KB · Views: 6
  • Tesla X4.webp
    Tesla X4.webp
    16.8 KB · Views: 6
  • Tesla X5.webp
    Tesla X5.webp
    28.9 KB · Views: 6
  • Tesla X6.webp
    Tesla X6.webp
    26 KB · Views: 6
  • Tesla X7.webp
    Tesla X7.webp
    50.3 KB · Views: 5
  • Tesla X8.webp
    Tesla X8.webp
    21.7 KB · Views: 5
  • Tesla X9.webp
    Tesla X9.webp
    24.6 KB · Views: 4
Last edited:

I’ve ridden in a few Tesla P85’s as they are the default taxi at Schipol airport. Very impressive performance and the drivers love them. All except the 3 are out of my price range when new and I find the 3 as aesthetically challenged as the German cars.

Secondhand might be an option but I’d have to check properly to make sure it wasn’t an ex-taxi.
 
I’ve ridden in a few Tesla P85’s as they are the default taxi at Schipol airport. Very impressive performance and the drivers love them. All except the 3 are out of my price range when new and I find the 3 as aesthetically challenged as the German cars.

Secondhand might be an option but I’d have to check properly to make sure it wasn’t an ex-taxi.
Waiting for the Berlin plant to begin Model Y production, that's what I'm aiming for either late this year or early 2022 when hopefully, the range will be getting up towards 400 miles (fingers crossed)
 
Here you go @Chewbacca - Tesla Model X

This car shown is a 19-plate Model X 100D, six-seater SUV in red with black vegan leather interior.
Fitted with the portrait central display screen that controls literally everything in the car from opening the doors to moving the seats, climate control, satnav, entertainment, even internet access... you can catch up on and read the @GrandOldTeam forum whilst charging the battery cells ;)

Approach the car with the car shaped keyfob in your pocket and the drivers door opens itself for you, handy if carrying things, no need to put them down whilst fumbling for your key.
Getting in behind the steering wheel and all you need to do it put your foot on the brake pedal, press the column mounted gearlever down to D and away you go... one pedal driving as you squeeze the accelerator pedal and the car gets off the mark. And it gets off the mark quickly if want it to, even in Chill mode - that equates to Comfort in the likes of Audi/Mercedes etc.

The SatNav offers the choice of either map or Google Earth view and to pan in or out, simply open or squeeze two fingers together as you would on a smartphone or iPad. Using the extensive menu options on the console and you can automatically adjust suspension ride height, seating positions, and a myriad of other screens... and most importantly, you can keep an eye on rate of battery recharge when plugged in.

It takes a few minutes to get acquainted to the system but anyone with an iPad of smartphone will get used to it no time at all.
On the steering wheel are just two rotary controls, the left hand one for the radio/satnav volume adjustment and the right hand one to make telephone calls with your bluetooth enabled phone.

The steering column mounted gear lever, wiper stalk and cruise control are Mercedes stock items and extremely simple to use - good thinking by Tesla in using tried and trusted controls from the German giant.

The seating is comfortable, offers loads of legroom in the front and more than enough in the rear seats as well. With no central transmission tunnel hump, there's plenty of space throughout the interior and the cavernous boot - with the third row of seats lying flat - offers plenty of space for suitcases, luggage, folded pushchairs etc etc. Headroom is fantastic and the swept back windscreen offers a panoramic skylight certainly for the driver and front seat passenger.

Driving the Model X is simplicity itself, you simply press the accelerator pedal to go and because the car is full electric, as soon as you ease off the throttle, the regenerative braking kicks immediately and the car slows down quickly... there is practically no glide as you get with a conventional ICE car. And it's this instant 'engine' braking that's coined the phrase 'one-pedal driving' - as the need to use the brakes is massively reduced, and if you're driving sensibly almost rendered unnecessary, not 100% obviously, but you very quickly get to realise that regenerative braking and the bonus of the self-charging it provides is a massive plus point of electric vehicles.

Steering and the brakes if/when needed are precise and excellent, the (rear) suspension might at first appear to be a bit stiff when driving over a speed hump but that's possibly because the Model X is a heavy car and it might take a little getting used to. Personally, and today was the third decent journey of 200 miles plus I've done in this car, I don't find it stiff but that's maybe just me.

A full charge in this 19-plate Model X showed a 260-mile range and allowing for the use of lights, wipers, heating, satnav, radio etc that all eat into the battery power, you can reasonably expect 210-230 miles on a full charge... unless driving at night in heavy rain, when range might drop to 180-200 miles.

Tesla EVs can be plugged in at any EV charging station but, for optimum charging rates and the quickest charging time, it's always best to hook up to a Tesla Supercharger point such as the one in Picture 2. Connect the cable and then go take a comfort break, buy a cup of coffee, pan through the magazine rack in the services and you can add a hundred miles of charge in about 20-25 minutes.

Now what this means is that longer journeys, 200 miles or more, need a little more planning in order to factor in a recharging stop but if fully charged with 260 miles in the batteries, normal day-to-day running around town and/or short commuting trips should be easily achievable, and leaving charging then until you get home and hooking up to the mains or a home charging unit.

The Tesla Model X is not a cheap car but, you're getting an awful lot of the best EV technology currently available AND you're not contributing toxic exhaust gases into the atmosphere.
I firmly believe electric cars are the way to go, if not right now, they very soon will be as Tesla - in particular as purely an EV car manufacturer - are utterly committed to making EVs cheaper and more affordable in the very near future.

It's not hype but their battery cell technology is considerably ahead of all the major car manufacturers and this is likely to be the case for number of years to come. The Model X is right at the top end of the Tesla range and carries a price tag to match, so it's a lottery win for most of us... the cheaper Model 3, soon to arrive Model Y and the future Model B will be much more affordable and more than worthy of serious, serious consideration.

My marks out of ten…
Comfort 8
Battery Range 7 - remember this is an older 19-plate car and the latest Model X has a 320-340+mile range.
Performance 8.5
Build Quality 8 - Early Tesla cars did have some BQ issues but the current standards are far higher than a few years ago.
Practicality 8 - Spacious, comfortable, clean and massive luggage space.
I'd love a model X. I think they are utterly superb!!
 
I’m not hung up on the range. Anything over 250 miles is ok for me. When I drove long distances with work we had it drilled into us by EHS that stopping at 200 miles was very much advisable and I still drive like that today, so charging isn’t the chore it seems to be for some.

Disappointingly, the Y still has the constipated frog visage. I like my cars to be good looking. I understand that is a matter of personal taste but mine is better than everyone else’s
 

As a special favour to @GrandOldTeam who's seriously thinking of buying one out of his ill-GOTten gains ;)...
today's review is a McLaren 570S Coupe

This little darling is a 19-plate two-seater low-flying machine with a 3.8 litre motor under the rear cover that will power you from 0-60 in considerably less than the time it takes to shoehorn oneself into the drivers seat.
In all seriousness, this is rightly termed a supercar, in similar fashion to the Ferrari Portofino that launched this thread but, with more of a roar. Where the Portofino goes like stink, it's refined... the McLaren feels more like something that will very quickly see your license in danger of being confiscated by those nice people with hand-held speed cameras.

So apart from blistering acceleration and (especially when cold) accompanying throaty exhaust roar, what does the McLaren offer?
On the motorway, far from its best environment in my opinion, the 570S cruises along at a steady 75mph at just 2000rpm and is surprisingly quiet considering the engine is right behind you.

Fill the tank up (with 98 octane super unleaded) and initially it suggests you have around 180-200 miles of range but, once you get going the car 'adjusts' to how you drive it and a full tank will provide 300+ miles.

The brakes are excellent as you would expect from a car packing as many horses as this does and the suspension understandably feels stiff.
Now given this is a supercar, that stiffer and low suspension affords you superb road holding and cornering when you exit the motorway and head off onto the A and B road network. You can take this car quicker into bends that you would normally take easy as, to put it bluntly, the car sticks to the road like baby poo to a blanket.

Inside the car, space is somewhat limited. Headroom is acceptable but, those of who stand over 6 feet tall soon begin to run out of legroom. The seats feel hard at first but are not uncomfortable - that maybe because you tend to be concentrating on the speedo rather than worrying about the feel of the seat squab ;) On a more serious note, I'm 6ft 4ins and have driven this car up to the north-west coast of Scotland with only one brief stop and it wasn't uncomfortable at all.
There's space behind the two seats for a small backpack and the front boot will take a small suitcase and not a lot more... this is not a car to send the wife out in to do a full weeks shopping !!

My marks out of ten…
Comfort 7 - not as nice as the Ferrari but (imo) better than the Porsche Cayman in the background of picture 2
Fuel Consumption 7 - much better than you might imagine for a supercar
Performance 9 - outstanding road holding and a powerful motor that work extremely well together
Build Quality and Reliability - is a bit difficult to judge as these cars are practically hand built rather than coming rolling a production line but, having driven a couple of these cars, this coupe was really well put together, with no iffy paintwork as earlier cars suffered from.
Practicality 5 - Largely impractical as a day-to-day car but, loads of fun if tearing round country lanes is your cup of tea.
 

Attachments

  • 570S 1.webp
    570S 1.webp
    68 KB · Views: 5
  • 570s 2.webp
    570s 2.webp
    64 KB · Views: 5
  • 570s 3.webp
    570s 3.webp
    39.1 KB · Views: 5
Last edited:
As a special favour to @GrandOldTeam who's seriously thinking of buying one out of his ill-GOTten gains ;)...
today's review is a McLaren 570S Coupe

This little darling is a 19-plate two-seater low-flying machine with a 3.8 litre motor under the rear cover that will power you from 0-60 in considerably less than the time it takes to shoehorn oneself into the drivers seat.
In all seriousness, this is rightly termed a supercar, in similar fashion to the Ferrari Portofino that launched this thread but, with more of a roar. Where the Portofino goes like stink, it's refined... the McLaren feels more like something that will very quickly see your license in danger of being confiscated by those nice people with hand-held speed cameras.

So apart from blistering acceleration and (especially when cold) accompanying throaty exhaust roar, what does the McLaren offer?
On the motorway, far from its best environment in my opinion, the 570S cruises along at a steady 75mph at just 2000rpm and is surprisingly quiet considering the engine is right behind you.

Fill the tank up (with 98 octane super unleaded) and initially it suggests you have around 180-200 miles of range but, once you get going the car 'adjusts' to how you drive it and a full tank will provide 300+ miles.

The brakes are excellent as you would expect from a car packing as many horses as this does and the suspension understandably feels stiff.
Now given this is a supercar, that stiffer and low suspension affords you superb road holding and cornering when you exit the motorway and head off onto the A and B road network. You can take this car quicker into bends that you would normally take easy as, to put it bluntly, the car sticks to the road like baby poo to a blanket.

Inside the car, space is somewhat limited. Headroom is acceptable but, those of who stand over 6 feet tall soon begin to run out of legroom. The seats feel hard at first but are not uncomfortable - that maybe because you tend to be concentrating on the speedo rather than worrying about the feel of the seat squab ;) On a more serious note, I'm 6ft 4ins and have driven this car up to the north-west coast of Scotland with only one brief stop and it wasn't uncomfortable at all.
There's space behind the two seats for a small backpack and the front boot will take a small suitcase and not a lot more... this is not a car to send the wife out in to do a full weeks shopping !!

My marks out of ten…
Comfort 7 - not as nice as the Ferrari but (imo) better than the Porsche Cayman in the background of picture 2
Fuel Consumption 7 - much better than you might imagine for a supercar
Performance 9 - outstanding road holding and a powerful motor that work extremely well together
Build Quality and Reliability - is a bit difficult to judge as these cars are practically hand built rather than coming rolling a production line but, having driven a couple of these cars, this coupe was really well put together, with no iffy paintwork as earlier cars suffered from.
Practicality 5 - Largely impractical as a day-to-day car but, loads of fun if tearing round country lanes is your cup of tea.
Thought my subscription fees where going on brasses and dodgy meth....might reconsider my stance.
 
I’m not hung up on the range. Anything over 250 miles is ok for me. When I drove long distances with work we had it drilled into us by EHS that stopping at 200 miles was very much advisable and I still drive like that today, so charging isn’t the chore it seems to be for some.

Disappointingly, the Y still has the constipated frog visage. I like my cars to be good looking. I understand that is a matter of personal taste but mine is better than everyone else’s

hah, same for me but my range is comfort limited (sometimes ya gotta go) and not fatigue limited. But the way I drive my stops are short. How much charge can you get in 15 mins or less?
 
Today’s review is a Porsche Carrera T

Let me state right up front that I am not a big fan of the Porsche sports cars, based largely on me being tall and them being small and somewhat cramped.

This particular Carrera T in red was an 18-plate model and I guess if you like the brand, it ticks the boxes.

It’s quick off the mark, is nimble in traffic and acceleration when overtaking on the motorway is very good.

Brakes are very good and the steering is very precise.

As far as fuel economy goes, around town and/or in stop/start traffic, the mpg is in the low 20s but surprisingly, on a long run - yesterday was 380 miles and almost entirely motorway driving - the Carrera returned over 40mpg which is pretty good.

Where the car falls down for me is with the suspension which is stiff to harsh, you feel every single bump in the road... and noise.
As well as the engine noise, cars like this and it’s stablemates the 911, Cayman and Boxster, all suffer (in my opinion) from excess road/tyre noise.

It really is intrusive and means you need to turn the radio up far more than is needed in other sports cars, and even in the cramped cabin, talking to a passenger ends up becoming a shouting match.

The Carrera T is ostensibly a two-door four-seater but trust me, there is very, very little room in the back seats for other than small children.

The front seats are firm and offer decent back support for a car of this nature, while legroom for taller than 6-footers is at best average.

The front boot is only good for a couple of small overnight suitcases or backpacks.

My marks out of ten...
Performance 8.5
Comfort 6 due to it being cramped for anyone over 6ft tall
Fuel economy 7
Build quality/Reliability 8/8
Practicality 4
 

Attachments

  • 728AB4E4-D288-43EA-BB29-AA2E331E17C6.webp
    728AB4E4-D288-43EA-BB29-AA2E331E17C6.webp
    596.2 KB · Views: 5
  • CFA357B2-DF00-4F6C-AD4C-1D7B0C16B3FF.webp
    CFA357B2-DF00-4F6C-AD4C-1D7B0C16B3FF.webp
    2.3 MB · Views: 5
  • 1E9EC259-BBD6-41E7-AD9B-8E0A2BCD7C0C.webp
    1E9EC259-BBD6-41E7-AD9B-8E0A2BCD7C0C.webp
    331 KB · Views: 5

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top