Watched the game Sunday -- one of the rare games we can get over here these days because the TV rights have switched to DAZN -- and it was clear to me bypassing the midfield would have worked just as well and playing from the back. Pickford's distribution, has has been noted, was more toward the sideline, trapping the receiving player. And neither Mina nor Holgate are capable of launching pinpoint long passes -- 90% of the time those efforts find an opposition player.
We did get those great chances in the first half, so something was working, but you can't play from the back when the midfielders are unwilling or incapable of quickly playing the ball forward. Schneiderlin is not a playmaker (nor is he a defensive midfielder as that would require some tackling ability) and Sigurdsson is more of a set-piece specialist than anything (he doesn't play enough quality through balls for my liking to be considered a playmaker; one great pass every four games just doesn't cut it). Delph is just off an injury and Gomes is out, meaning Davies is probably the best CM we have. And that sums up the problem.
What Carlo MIGHT have done is go three at the back and move Holgate into midfield, but that really wouldn't have made that much of a difference, IMO. Bottom line, and especially in light of this apparent dressing room spat, is that this team needs an enema and Carlo is going to wield the hose.