Changes Coming To GOT

GrandOldTeam

Moderator
Staff member
Short Version

The UK government is forcing us to remove the Current Affairs forum, and NSFW type threads. Maybe also user to user private messaging.

Google 'Online Safety Act' if interested.

Long Rambling Version;

We're of course, an Everton Forum.

But in our 18+ years (not one of you wished the forum a happy birthday last week ffs), we've become a community beyond Everton.

Since 2017, we've sought to best accomodate 'current affairs' discussion in it's own sub forum - out the way, with a 'enter at own risk'/hands off moderation policy.

It's worked well.

Or as well as it could have done. Online. Politics.

However, the Online Safety Act (OSA) in the UK comes into effect on March 17, 2025. Someone much more articulate than I provides some commentary here. Also some more background info and it's implications here.

The implications of the act has already caused forums in their entirety to close, others have closed the ability to post. Some discussion on here of this act from December.

Moderating a Everton forum is challenging enough - we don't have the resource, ability, diplomacy to moderate politics in a way that would make us compliant with the act. Even if we did, I don't think we'd have the inclination to. Nor be prepared to accept the personal liability to do so.

Sadly then, we need to close the Current Affairs forum from 1st March.

We'll also need to close 'Not Safe For Work' threads, like 'The Fit Birds' thread.

There's a chance we may also need to disable user to user private messaging but I'm awaiting clarification on that.

But fear not. We can still fume about Everton.
 

Hmmm governments making forums close down on the basis of safety. A bit Orwellian or even Soviet state that, isn't it? A bit like the general strategy of using the environment to justify the latest tax hike, or saying we'll never need ID cards, but you all need photo driving licences now to vote.

So glad I'm nearer the end of my life and not near the start. I don't want to live too much into this future Britain is creating. And the "woke" generation don't even see what's happening to them.
so many aspects of 1984 (the book) are coming to fruition
 
I'd counter that with some Goebbels' quotes that I referred to in another thread. Social media, search algorithms and viral media are the tools of fascist dictators. His words are scarily relevant to today:

View attachment 294390

View attachment 294391View attachment 294392

Hmm.

The thing is, the bigger platforms are the ones most resilient.

Some wider context below from a forum that's closing;

 

Obviously this is GOT's show and we are merely background characters in it, but I must say I don't think there is anything about how the CA forum was run (or FWIW any part of this forum, including the fit birds thread) that would be in danger of even conceivably come close to breaching the new OSA.
 
Obviously this is GOT's show and we are merely background characters in it, but I must say I don't think there is anything about how the CA forum was run (or FWIW any part of this forum, including the fit birds thread) that would be in danger of even conceivably come close to breaching the new OSA.

Please setup a politics forum and I'll signpost the CA forum here to it.
 

Obviously this is GOT's show and we are merely background characters in it, but I must say I don't think there is anything about how the CA forum was run (or FWIW any part of this forum, including the fit birds thread) that would be in danger of even conceivably come close to breaching the new OSA.
Yes, I've just had a quick run through the requirements and while OSA is a bit of a scrappy regulation (most of them are) the type of content it's intending to police is clearly defined and pretty sensible and serious.
It's stipulating, I think, that site owners need to proactively remove any content - of this type - flagged to them in reasonable time, given the resources they have.
Ofcom are not going to start throwing fines around for any minor infractions on user forums.
Legislative enforcement is an extremely arduous and costly process for a regulator, and any overreach would be immediately subject to challenge in the tribunal system.
Completely the boss man's call of course, and I understand a lot of site owners will be risk averse with new regs, but people shutting down cycling forums per the Naughton article is, in my view, a complete overreaction.
 
Yes, I've just had a quick run through the requirements and while OSA is a bit of a scrappy regulation (most of them are) the type of content it's intending to police is clearly defined and pretty sensible and serious.
It's stipulating, I think, that site owners need to proactively remove any content - of this type - flagged to them in reasonable time, given the resources they have.
Ofcom are not going to start throwing fines around for any minor infractions on user forums.
Legislative enforcement is an extremely arduous and costly process for a regulator, and any overreach would be immediately subject to challenge in the tribunal system.
Completely the boss man's call of course, and I understand a lot of site owners will be risk averse with new regs, but people shutting down cycling forums per the Naughton article is, in my view, a complete overreaction.

"I've just had a quick run through the requirements"

I suggest you read more and if you can't see why our approach to CA (unmoderated) would be problematic then read again.
 

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Shop

Back
Top