Well it makes no sense as an argument for Coady who is a loan signing. And Tarkowski is a no brainer on a free transfer. I probably agree with him on Gueye though.
- Status
Well it makes no sense as an argument for Coady who is a loan signing. And Tarkowski is a no brainer on a free transfer. I probably agree with him on Gueye though.
blue in oxford
Player Valuation: £1m
hope he does sign and we keep all the others gonna need big squad with this stupid 5 subs rule
Houghty19
Player Valuation: £15m
The thing is with gueye he strikes me as a player who could keep going for another five years.
He could, but I don't think it's wise to expect any outfield player to still be capable of playing in the PL at 38. If we got 3 good years I'd be more than happy.
Tim , if you take Coady , Tarkowski and Gana out of our team every other player has a good resale potential
That's a decent balance for me.
Oddball
Player Valuation: £20m
how about we get the players in before we start looking to sell them. it`s this season that counts
Marius57
Player Valuation: £50m
Also, for what, 8m for Gana, it's essentially a nominal fee in the current footballing market. We aren't signing him to ever sell him.
Ring master
Player Valuation: £90m
I've always been of the thought that we get players to play, not for how much we could sell in the future - I've not cared about this resale stuff that a lot seem worried about. after all if they are on to much we cant get rid of most of them and they run contracts out anyway
McNeill, Onana and Vinagre.
It's a valid point though. It's fine for you not to care about it, but it doesn't make the point any less relevant. People still sneering at the idea of resale value being important after everything that's happened is quite incredible. We should definitely get a klaxon for when people who laugh at resale value moan about the wage bill and us being financially hamstrung though, possibly a dunce's hat too.
lieneverton
Player Valuation: £8m
There's a world of difference between these type of signings vs what we've been doing for years. Think he's trying to make a point that just isn't there.
If we had only signed these players and nothing else then I could understand some concern.
If we had only signed these players and nothing else then I could understand some concern.
No what I'm saying is that the resale argument really can only be made for Gueye who is a bit older, and unlikely to be a free transfer/loan signing like the other two. I'm very happy with the Tarkowski signing - I've wanted him for a long time. Coady isn't someone I'd have gone for personally, but he's looking like a loan signing so I have no idea why resale would be an issue. You can't sell loan players....
AsiaAsia82
Player Valuation: £35m
We need a Conor Coady, shame it has to be him though
….I have no doubt they’d bite anybody’s hand off if offers came in for Mina, Holgate or Keane. As you say, there are options for Mykolenko and Coleman to play in a three & let’s not forget young Reece Welsh (19 next month) who must be rated by Lampard given he’s often on the bench.
Loan makes sense regards FFP
- Status
