Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

  • Participation within this subforum is only available to members who have had 5+ posts approved elsewhere.

ECHO Comment: "Fears of Witch-hunt Against Liverpool FC"

Status
Not open for further replies.
I meant that he didn't deserve the award when he won it, it was a token gesture but he wasn't the best player in the league that season.

The award should go to the best player otherwise it's a farce and means nothing.

The "best player" is pretty much subjective, is it not?

Personally I think Yaya Toure or Silva were the two best players in the league last season.

And if one of those boys had won it, the award could not have been described as meaning nothing as either would have been worthy recipients.
 
Moment_of_the_week__623694a.jpg


article-2623207-1D66477500000578-774_634x351.jpg



article-0-1EF05C4600000578-60_634x489.jpg




53881_o.gif
 

The "best player" is pretty much subjective, is it not?

Personally I think Yaya Toure or Silva were the two best players in the league last season.

And if one of those boys had won it, the award could not have been described as meaning nothing as either would have been worthy recipients.

Of course it is, his past behaviour (he actually wasn't that bad last season) should not affect his best status as best player. If you think that Silva and Toure were better then fair enough. I disagree with you but you're entitled to your opinion.
 
Knobbys come out to have his say....

http://www.theguardian.com/football/2014/jun/28/liverpool-luis-suarez-kenny-dalglish

"It is my belief that when you bring a player to a football club, he becomes your responsibility."

Well said, so take the punishment on the chin and sod off.

The thing is they have stood by him, through racism, cheating and a lengthy ban for biting. How many chances do you give someone before you realise there is no shame in cutting your losses.
 
Ronaldo didnt have the best of seasons by the standards he had set the year before and was outscored by Anelka.

His all round game was awesome that season, I remember it well. He commanded an £80m bid from Real afterwards.
 

Of course it is, his past behaviour (he actually wasn't that bad last season) should not affect his best status as best player. If you think that Silva and Toure were better then fair enough. I disagree with you but you're entitled to your opinion.

I know I am.

That is why I say one cannot describe the award as bing a "farce and meaning nothing" if it goes to a player one doesn't think was the best player.
 
I know I am.

That is why I say one cannot describe the award as bing a "farce and meaning nothing" if it goes to a player one doesn't think was the best player.

You were saying his past actions should affect his nomination and not his ability. That is exactly what you insinuated in your initial post. I disagreed. Ce la vie.
 
His all round game was awesome that season, I remember it well. He commanded an £80m bid from Real afterwards.

He commanded £80m from Real the year before. There was a lot of frustration with Ronaldo that year from United fans because the general feeling was he wasn't playing to the same standards as the two years previous.
 
He commanded £80m from Real the year before. There was a lot of frustration with Ronaldo that year from United fans because the general feeling was he wasn't playing to the same standards as the two years previous.

Not how I remember it, he was excellent. He was in the premier league team of the year and was a major reason why they won the league.
 
Not how I remember it, he was excellent. He was in the premier league team of the year and was a major reason why they won the league.

The way you remember it is wrong :p

Vidic was the best performer for United that season.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top