Everton transfer reliability guide

[Eggs]

….can we have: ‘his own thread ‘ in tier 5 please.

 

[Raino85]

 

[Yorkiebars89]

Blues,

Every transfer window, we get comments like this;



This thread is to help us create a working, community updated journalist and media reliability guide/tier list. It works well on other platforms (example) so we're pinching the concept to see how it works on here...

I figure we can submit sources in this thread, and discuss who are the kings, and weasels of the transfer ITK battleground. Submissions in this thread will be included on a poll, and we can all vote which tier they belong.

I've got us started with a few to provide an illustration;

Tier Voting

Tier Guide​

Eventually, as it's built and substantiated with community votes - the guide will be shared at the top of the transfer thread to help give an indication on reliability. "This source said this...." and if people like, they can check how reliable the community believes that source is.

Tiers defined as the below.

Tier 1: Most Reliable
As close as it gets to receiving the news from an official source. These journalists are known for consistently accurate and well-sourced information.

Tier 2: Usually Reliable
Information shared by the source can be seen as trustworthy.

Tier 3: Sometimes Reliable
We're entering the hit and miss, 50/50 territory here.

Tier 4: Less Reliable
Untrustworthy journalists or media sources who could occasionally be right once in a while, but usually not the case. clickbait, sensational titles and so on.

Tier 5: Waste Of Time / Blacklisted
Clickbait with no insight or credibility whatsoever.

Tier Aggregators: These are not the original source of news, they merely report news from other sources. Please make the effort to share direct sources, rather than aggregators.

Feedback, and involvement very much appreciated. It's something we'll all need to chip in/develop to see if it's a worthwhile exercise for the forum.

I'd go with blind leading the blind tbh

 

[Shibbywiggles]

This is superb and I’m gonna share it with my dad so he stops reading everything off newsnow

 

[trueblue84]

What a way to start the day. Looks like we're signing n'diaye and that [Publication is blacklisted] bellend's twitter has been deleted

@GrandOldTeam, looks like you can remove it from the list.

 

[Nymzee]

What a way to start the day. Looks like we're signing n'diaye and that [Publication is blacklisted] bellend's twitter has been deleted

View attachment 262084
@GrandOldTeam, looks like you can remove it from the list.

He's reactivated it. Does it all the time.

 

[Connor]

Blues,

Every transfer window, we get comments like this;



This thread is to help us create a working, community updated journalist and media reliability guide/tier list. It works well on other platforms (example) so we're pinching the concept to see how it works on here...

I figure we can submit sources in this thread, and discuss who are the kings, and weasels of the transfer ITK battleground. Submissions in this thread will be included on a poll, and we can all vote which tier they belong.

I've got us started with a few to provide an illustration;

Tier Voting

Tier Guide​

Eventually, as it's built and substantiated with community votes - the guide will be shared at the top of the transfer thread to help give an indication on reliability. "This source said this...." and if people like, they can check how reliable the community believes that source is.

Tiers defined as the below.

Tier 1: Most Reliable
As close as it gets to receiving the news from an official source. These journalists are known for consistently accurate and well-sourced information.

Tier 2: Usually Reliable
Information shared by the source can be seen as trustworthy.

Tier 3: Sometimes Reliable
We're entering the hit and miss, 50/50 territory here.

Tier 4: Less Reliable
Untrustworthy journalists or media sources who could occasionally be right once in a while, but usually not the case. clickbait, sensational titles and so on.

Tier 5: Waste Of Time / Blacklisted
Clickbait with no insight or credibility whatsoever.

Tier Aggregators: These are not the original source of news, they merely report news from other sources. Please make the effort to share direct sources, rather than aggregators.

Feedback, and involvement very much appreciated. It's something we'll all need to chip in/develop to see if it's a worthwhile exercise for the forum.

Just noticed Ad Jones is on this and he hasn't worked for the Echo in ageeeeeeeess

 

[trueblue84]

He's reactivated it. Does it all the time.

Knew it was too good to be true.

 

[davep]

Please add Liam Cello to his own tier at the very pinnacle of world football news.

Is he our Italian correspondent??

 

[davep]

Tier 3. He was outed as putting rumours as facts to help other clubs unsettle players for some cash.

Voted him T5 now for this.

 

[chicoazul]

Is he our Italian correspondent??

Half Italian. A man of word and integrity.

 

[davep]

Half Italian. A man of word and integrity.

I don't know if this man exists, or if it's just a piss-take, so can't decide if I should Like or LoL this post.

 

[Gwladys St. Glory]

This thread is to help us create a working, community updated journalist and media reliability guide/tier list.

​

 

[chicoazul]

I don't know if this man exists, or if it's just a piss-take, so can't decide if I should Like or LoL this post.

He looks very real to me pal.

 

[Curtis]

Where does Jac talbot rate? I see him attached to transfer news all the time now