I don’t think Stones should come back. Given the circumstances of his departure, I think it would be mentally difficult for him to perform at his best level.John Stones is a big improvement on any of our defenders. He is a better defender, and less importantly he’s much better on the ball than all our CBs.
You usually get better as a team by buying or developing better players. Players that are an improvement on the incumbent. John Stones is considerably better than all our current CBs.
If he’s available and circumstances are right for us, then we should bring him back.
Holgate is quality, and I think has a very high ceiling, keep him and partner him with Stones or another elite CB, and then throw Michael Keane and Mina at any one who will take them.
I also remember the mistakes. My heart was in my mouth too often and that is his problem at City. If him and Pickford were in the same team, we would have bin z cars and run out to the sound of trombones.