I’m a huge Astley fan , so it’s disappointing in some ways that Branthwaite has shot ahead of him. The talent he first showed must still be there so has anything changed? Well he’s still only 18, played mainly RB for the U23s where his reluctance to cross the half way line and attacking ability will count against him, dropped down for a few u18 games at CB but we seem to have him on a steady rather than rapid development plan.
He hasn’t as yet developed as physically as I’d hoped , but maybe that will come. My slight worry about Astley is that he was outstanding so young, a natural captain for club and country , seeing and doing things others his age didn’t do in a “ captains” kind of way but as he’s got older maybe others have caught him up . My nagging comparison is with the other Ryan, Ryan Ledson , a standout at his age , captain of his country etc, but stalled in his progress for a while. Astley at 16 was one of the most talented defenders I’ve seen , he won’t have lost that completely and time is very much on his side at 18, e.g. Holgate has only just established himself at 23, Keane was 24 when we bought him.