I get that but it’s a big step up and I don’t think he will be able to develop so much under the spotlight here. One bad pass or missed tackle and the crowd will be on him, at an early age, confidence is a massive thing.People wanting him to go on another loan seem to think we have an abundance of quality midfield options for some unknown reason
3 of them are not currently contracted with us next season and another 2 aren't midfielders.Gana, McNeil, Ndiaye, Alcaraz, Garner, Iroegbunam, maybe even Doucoure, likely at least two new midfielders joining in the transfer window - that's sufficient for a club aiming for a top half finish. Obviously it would be great if we could give him loads of minutes to improve here, but he wont be in position to start loads of games next season, so imo it makes total sense to loan him and have the option to recall if we so wish.
Under Moyes at the same age - 18 - Rooney had made 67 appearances for Everton, started for England at a euros and then moved for a world Record fee to United. Theres a dozen academy players you could use as an example to prove your point and you chose by far the worst one.Hes just gone on 18, hes very young, i think its incredible hes starting games in the Championship at his age.
Would 100% send him out on loan and let him play a full season n the Championship - invaluable.
He wont get the mins he needs to develop here.
We had arguably one of the greatest players England has ever produced in Rooney here under Moyes at the same age and he still didn't get a regular game.
Under Moyes at the same age - 18 - Rooney had made 67 appearances for Everton, started for England at a euros and then moved for a world Record fee to United. Theres a dozen academy players you could use as an example to prove your point and you chose by far the worst one.
Yes he started Barkley at 17 first game of the season v QPR I think it was and then that was that, he went on loan a couple of times, but hardly got a look in under Moyes and then started straight away under MartinezThink you have the wrong of it mate.
In his first season he averaged 17 mins per league game.
In his second he averaged 27 mins per league game.
I dont need to tell anyone most would have lived through it.
Rooney was one of the best the country ever produced at that age - like i said wasn't guaranteed starts or mins, so id suggest Harrison wont either.
I haven't had a look at the numbesr but going from memory i remember there was some annoyance about the lack of mins Barkley was getting toward the tail end of Moyes first stint here as well.
Yes he started Barkley at 17 first game of the season v QPR I think it was and then that was that, he went on loan a couple of times, but hardly got a look in under Moyes and then started straight away under Martinez
You definitely have it wrong mate. Wayne Rooney did not average 27 mins a game in his second season. He started 26 games for that season including the final like 10 on the bounceThink you have the wrong of it mate.
In his first season he averaged 17 mins per league game.
In his second he averaged 27 mins per league game.
I dont need to tell anyone most would have lived through it.
Rooney was one of the best the country ever produced at that age - like i said wasn't guaranteed starts or mins, so id suggest Harrison wont either.
I haven't had a look at the numbesr but going from memory i remember there was some annoyance about the lack of mins Barkley was getting toward the tail end of Moyes first stint here as well.
You definitely have it wrong mate. Wayne Rooney did not average 27 mins a game in his second season. He started 26 games for that season including the final like 10 on the bounce
I have no idea how you've calculated those figures but they're massively off.
Think you have the wrong of it mate.
In his first season he averaged 17 mins per league game.
In his second he averaged 27 mins per league game.
I dont need to tell anyone most would have lived through it.
Rooney was one of the best the country ever produced at that age - like i said wasn't guaranteed starts or mins, so id suggest Harrison wont either.
I haven't had a look at the numbesr but going from memory i remember there was some annoyance about the lack of mins Barkley was getting toward the tail end of Moyes first stint here as well.
Glad it's not just me!Off topic, but... Why do we call most players by their surnames yet most times Harrison is referred to by his first name? A tad confusing at times due to the player we have on loan, not on this thread obviously....
Im gonna call him Hazza if he starts playing for us.Off topic, but... Why do we call most players by their surnames yet most times Harrison is referred to by his first name? A tad confusing at times due to the player we have on loan, not on this thread obviously....