This is a good point. Whilst the Heysel ban was a blow to us, we must remember that we were not the ONLY club to miss out during the years of the ban. Arsenal missed out and it doesn't seem to have damaged them for nearly 30 years.
Here's the difference.
We had our best team in a generation.....possibly the best team we ever had.
A young team which as the following two seasons showed, had the potential to get even better.
Then we lost the man who masterminded it, due in no small measure to the ban.
If the ban had happened ten years earlier when we were a workmanlike, functional team under Billy Bingham it wouldn't have had the same devastating effect on the club's morale.
We would have just taken it in our stride and moved on with no sense of what might have been if the team of Steve Sergeant, Gary Jones and George Telfer had been allowed to play in the UEFA Cup.
(I revere the memory of those lads BTW....but they were no Stevens, Steven or Sheedy )
The Arsenal team of the era was pretty average......wouldn't even have been in the European Cup never mind win it.
They were denied a UEFA Cup spot after winning the Coca Cola Cup or whatever the League Cup was called then.
But imagine the Invincibles had just wrapped up the Title in 2007 or whenever it was and English clubs had been banned from Europe following the Kopite night of shame in Athens.
And the team proceeded to disintegrate over the next few years as a result.
It would have been a longer way back for them in that circumstance.
The Heysel ban affected Everton more than any other team in England because we were by far the best team in the country in 1985.
In short.....we lost the most because we had the most to lose.
But you are right in suggesting it was more than the Heysel ban which done for us.
Peter Johnson completed the job of leading us into anonymity when he got his hooks into us.
But if we had been allowed to play in the next season's competition and won it....or even gave a great account of ourselves in it and over the next couple years.....who knows how the following six or seven years might have panned out?
The profile would have been lifted, proper investors might have been attracted to the club.
Peter Johnson might never have got anywhere near the joint.
And when the Sky Express left the station circa 1993 a proper commercially managed EFC might have been in the First Class carriage instead of standing on the platform waving goodbye to the big time.
It is all conjecture, I know.
But the one concrete fact is a great Everton team was stopped dead in its tracks by the Heysel ban.
In the very moment we thought we had everything football could offer us as fans it was all snatched away from us.
And I believe it dealt a bodyblow which left a decade long hangover which left us lagging behind Manchester United and Arsenal......teams who had not won as many Titles as us before Howard's team of '85 had its heart ripped out.
And we all know what the last twenty years have been like.