Huddlestone or Manny??

[TheDevils2001]

No way you could compare them to each other Fernandes is alot better than him, Huddlestone would only be a squad player for us, I did rather sign Jamie O'Hara from them as Carsley replacement.

Come on let's get Fernandes for next season, even if it had to be loan deal in the mean time.

 

[Dom1878]

Look at last year though pal and see that people were screaming for the signings of Nugent, Smith & Richardson.

Lucky the ginger one is the Manager really isnt it?

Id still take Smith...

 

[chicoazul]

Bonus points for honesty Dom.

But that discounts you from any transfer talk from this point onwards pal.

 

[Cal]

No contest....Manuel imo.

 

[Gufty]

Manny, everytime!

 

[DENNIS STEVENS]

Look at last year though pal and see that people were screaming for the signings of Nugent, Smith & Richardson.

Lucky the ginger one is the Manager really isnt it?

true, but there were also plenty who weren't so keen. i accept that moyes is a far better judge than i'll ever be & is likely to come up with players i know little or nothing of. hence my original comment, moyes seems to generally be very keen on getting good value for money.

 

[chicoazul]

Spot on Dennis.

 

[TX Bill]

Huddlestone.






(Edit: F&*k Manny)

 

[Neiler]

Huddlestone.






(Edit: F&*k Manny)

POTD

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

anyone saying we should sign Huddlestone based either entirely or in part on his tackling and work rate is quite plainly out of their tree, since he can't tackle, and is a feckin lazy bugger...

 

[TsarDiniyar]

i cant even believe this debate has been put forward

 

[MoyesBlueWhiteArmy]

Neither, both are not worthy of a place in the side

 

[Sharpys top lip]

Not mannys biggest fan..........

But would take him all day over huddlestone, He's plain [Poor language removed].

 

[uknightbreed]

this is a strange question.

its like going into tesco's and seeing classy stilton for £10 and tesco value cheese for £1.50.

granted there both cheese and will do what it says on the side of the packet, granted ones a rip off and one is like flavouless rubber but it all boils down to my finances.

if money is tight i would buy the tesco value.but if ive got the money i would buy the luxury stilton.i would enjoy it more than the cheepo rubbish.

id buy fernandes as a first team player.huddlestone as a squad player.

if i couldnt buy fernandes than huddletone would be a pretty poor alternative as a first teamer buy.

ps actually i cant stand stilton but it helped get the point across

 

[DENNIS STEVENS]

just so long as it's blue stilton