Tony’s Carp
Player Valuation: £40m
Wouldn't say it didn't work with PSG, he had three decent seasons, played a good amount of football and by all accounts did a good job for them.
Played well yesterday did our Idrissa.
Massively underrated
Maybe 'unreal' is OTT but no doubt we need him in the team as he is a protector. Few loose passes go against him (what Everton player hasn't had loose passes this season) but we have a better Everton team with him playing so not that bizarre shout if you can actually see what he brings to the team
carolinablue232
Player Valuation: £70m
Always has been. He's aging, so he'll keep gradually declining, but he's still comfortably one of our better players.
When he sticks to what he does best, I love him.
When he thinks he's some attacking mid at PSG, not so much.
When he thinks he's some attacking mid at PSG, not so much.
Rita_Poon
Player Valuation: £80m
Plays well, doing his job, suddenly the expectation is there to do more and forget the task he's specialised to.
Dixie1sixty
Player Valuation: £15m
A hugely underrated and underappreciated player.
DualityNSNO
How much for the pair?
Well none of us are asking him to bomb forward or take free kicks really. In fact it's always been best if he stays a long way away from that as his talent is a lot more defensive.Plays well, doing his job, suddenly the expectation is there to do more and forget the task he's specialised to.
Rita_Poon
Player Valuation: £80m
Daytripper
Player Valuation: £35m
He was man of the match for me, best I’ve seen him play in ages. Superb.
Sheedy's right peg
Player Valuation: £750k
Yeah, I don't see him getting down The Brick for a liquid lunch. Long may it continue!
Zatara
Player Valuation: £90m
The issue I have with Gana isnt what he does (like a dog after the ball) its the gaps he leaves. On the one hand hes a DM but on the other hand he isnt.
Whether you go with the old Horne/Parkinson type partnership and bring a 2nd Gana type (Ndidiesque or Ndidi himself if hes not totally finished) into the side so they can hunt as a pair OR you play him with a sitting player (like Onana should be) it works from a defensive perspective.
But then you need attacking play from elsewhere e.g wide or attacking midfield (Doucoure).
Hes out of contract and we should extend but not on the same £80k+ wages.
Bluebonic
Player Valuation: £35m
In fairness, when he did those forward runs at PSG he would have had five or six players moving forward with him, finding space and making themselves available for him to get shut asap. He never sees that with us, if he moves forward, he does so alone and when he looks up to release the ball most of his team mates would be hiding in terror that he might pass it to them. Or owrse, they receive the ball and just pass it straight back.
I see his shortcomings, but like you I love him when he plays the role of the destroyer. But I do feel that if we had a few more players who didn't have a psychological terror of all things spherical he wouldn’t have lost the ball half as many times.
