Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

2023/24 James Garner

Status
Not open for further replies.

I think Garner is truly under appreciated, at times last season I felt he was a better option than Onana (who I rated) he's got the attributes to be a solid premier league CM.

Gana holding, with Garner & Tim in front of him.

Still think we need an extra DM/CM

We need someone who can spell Gana and okay the holding role with more discipline than he can long term replacement
 
Sorry mate, disagree, think garner was the fulcrum of the team last year and his loss is huge, look at the genes we pressed the best - see who in those games led that press

He's a tidy little player and Dyche loves him, he's the ideal Dyche CM.

But think he's way overrated by some too.

Don't get me wrong, he'll be a miss if he's out for a long time but hopefully he isn't. But he's hardly some exceptional midfielder either. Can't believe the stick Onana got, and it just really does show what a lot of our fanbase like, which is lads who run around a bit aimlessly at times, and Garner really does do that.

Now fortunately, the manager we have really values high energy in midfield, and Garner brings that in abundance.
 
He's a tidy little player and Dyche loves him, he's the ideal Dyche CM.

But think he's way overrated by some too.

Don't get me wrong, he'll be a miss if he's out for a long time but hopefully he isn't. But he's hardly some exceptional midfielder either. Can't believe the stick Onana got, and it just really does show what a lot of our fanbase like, which is lads who run around a bit aimlessly at times, and Garner really does do that.

Now fortunately, the manager we have really values high energy in midfield, and Garner brings that in abundance.

My opinion is Onana was a very good central mid mate, in the system we played somewhat stifled, Gueye is what he is, warts and all.
Garner is imo a Barry, Carrick, carswell type midfielder, one who can be one the fulcrum of a side.

Yeah I'll admit I'm a huge fan, and time may vault me on this but I truly believe he's got way more potential than we've unlocked do far.
 

My opinion is Onana was a very good central mid mate, in the system we played somewhat stifled, Gueye is what he is, warts and all.
Garner is imo a Barry, Carrick, carswell type midfielder, one who can be one the fulcrum of a side.

Yeah I'll admit I'm a huge fan, and time may vault me on this but I truly believe he's got way more potential than we've unlocked do far.
I do think he has a lot of potential but not sure I really see him in that type of mold personally.

His passing, for example, really isn't great, but people have him down as some ball-playing, silky playmaker.

Not saying he can't develop that side of his game and he really is ideal for how Dyche wants his CMs to play right now.
 
Might be unpopular but I don’t really rate him.
To me he seems like James ward prowse minus the set piece.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Back
Top