James McCarthy

[Rugby Toffee]

Not the same player , been invisible , is he fully fit?

 

[DanEFC92]

Not the same player , been invisible , is he fully fit?

Close, it rhymes with 'fit' though.

 

[Timak]

When we signed him I said he was a bog average midfielder signed by a less than average manager.

Then at the end of the season I said I'd never been more wrong about a player or a manager.

Now it turns out I was correct on both counts.

 

[quasi modo]

That would be an upgrade for him at the moment....let Stubbs take him to Hibs.

I wouldn't wish him upon anyone really.

 

[quasi modo]

Not the same player , been invisible , is he fully fit?

Are any of them fit or fit to wear the shirt?

 

[MACCA75]

Martinez has signed him twice, has made him a multi millionaire.

McCarthy thanks him by throwing him under a bus with a series of pathetic and shameful performances.

Infuriates me with the casual manner he kicks a football.

Get rid and put a bid in for Schneiderlin instead.

 

[hktoffee]

His fortune is similar to Martinez. Great in his first year below average to bad in his second and third season.

He needs to impose himself and be more direct in his passing. Hope a new manager will change his style a bit.

 

[gianthogweed]

Do Arsenal or Spurs still want him or any of the other clubs the Daily Mirror tried to sell him to

 

[DanEFC92]

 

[ToffeeDoug]

It should be a word close to crab.

 

[jinkyali]

The biggest fraud in the squad.

Runs around snarling at people.

 

[hktoffee]

When we signed him I said he was a bog average midfielder signed by a less than average manager.

Then at the end of the season I said I'd never been more wrong about a player or a manager.

Now it turns out I was correct on both counts.

Same here although I think McCarthy is ok given we have a new great manager to train him.

 

[ah11984]

Hopefully the new manager realises how average he is.

 

[davie clay]

Does nothing. Sell him.

with half the so called logic on this forum we should sell the whole team !!!!!!! is there really anyone currently who can hold there hands up and say they've set the league on fire ? there all playing as if there half asleep and that goes for all the the so called superstars,from barkely to lukaku they've all under performed so in my humble opinion its unfair to blame one or two players.............only one man you can blame is the manager......after all does he not set out the tactics and what the players duty on the pitch is ???????

 

[ProZ]

The first season he ran alot, but I will be honest, since then I dont see him running like people are saying? Infact, I dont see him on the pitch full stop.