He was only poor after the restart(as where his whole team) prior to that he played pretty well. Barca need cash, and he is someone they get cash for, nobody is going to give them money for some of the others they have as it's a team full of aging players. If Gibson and Branthwaite are so good then why loan Gibson when we are so lightweight? also on the evidence so far Branthwaite might be able to pass the ball and have a bit of pace but the last thing we need is another CB who can't head the ball, he has cost us a few times already.