Sorry macca, Could you enlighten me ?? I'm not sure if your agreeing or not. Is this hatred all from the book or am I missing the bigger picture here. Osman was from a time where ANY flair in an Everton team should have been appreciated...lets be honest if it wasnt Os, Arteta or Pienaar..it didnt exsist. I'm not directly from Liverpool so I really don't get or understand the hatred of a player who would harp on about a manager who gave him his best chance on a football stage...pretty sure all people would thank the person who gave them that....surely ??