This was covered in "Chat Box RAW Uncut Pay Per View" on the weekend.
The conclusions were:
1 - He's was massively underwhelming overall and not worthy of spunking loads of money on him.
2 - He was a show pony, who seduced unknowledge posters (they will identify themselves in due course) with step overs but not much else.
3 - He would go missing when the going got tough, boss player to have when you're 2-0 up at home though.
4 - He could have signed for us but did the ultimate snide and went back on his word, flew to Spain, turned his mobile off and signed for Valencia.
5 - We have far better, save your tedious worshipping for someone who plays for the shirt and has genuine quality: ie: Arteta.
6 - Pienaar is twice as effective at a fraction of the price.
7 - Did you see him against Newcastle" argument is void as he was playing a [Poor language removed] team, on the last game of the season in a nothing game. He had plenty of chances to prove his mettle through two loan periods and failed to do so.
8 - He feigned injury to get subbed against City.
9 - He is, without doubt, a massive massive shithouse and we dont need him.
Hope that clears it up x