2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

[blulouie]

Coleman v Jimenez = bad organisation = poor coaching.

He was actually Richarlisons man Tim.
He should of a least blocked the run of Jiminez.

 

[cronullasharks]

Arouna Kone could defend set pieces better than any of our so called defenders.

 

[banno]

He was actually Richarlisons man Tim.
He should of a least blocked the run of Jiminez.

True. First rule of defending free kicks like that is to prevent a free run and the block is important. Long as it is not an obvious block then it can be defended a lot easier than we make it.

 

[BernieH]

The players have to set themselves up though, Tim.

I'm 100% sure he didn't say to Coleman - stand three yards away from Jimenez, oh, and Richarlison, stand two yards behind him as well.

It's probably a mix of both but if our players literally need putting on the spot to be able to defend a set piece (which let's actually be honest, is not a new issue) then we've got far more many problems than Silva.

Their main striker ghosted inbetween Richarlison and Coleman, Richarlison left him and didn't give any shout to coleman who had his back to him. So why was their #9 being marked by our left wingerand right full back and not a CB, surely that's Silva.

I'd also say in Silvas defence that communication on the field is sorely lacking in this team. There are genuinely no leaders.

 

[TyphooToffee]

Poor bloke can't win on Wednesday, like.

Lose, and it could be a cricket score.

Win, and he'll be hated anyway.

Best we can hope for is a valiant erm, 2-1 City

Win and he'll be hated? I know I don't live among RS fans (although you'd be surprised how many are coming out of the woodwork) but this RS thing is ridiculous.

 

[hetion]

Cough.

Just dropping in here to categorically state that Fonseca is a wildly better choice than Silva, if we plump for Silva it's because our board are STILL (!!!) stuck in the out-dated 'prem-proven' mindset. Silva is a marginally better version of Martinez who will crumble eventually.

Fonseca is no sure-fire choice - no manager is - but he's exciting, smart and much more worth the gamble than Silva is.

 

[nsno-chris]

He was actually Richarlisons man Tim.
He should of a least blocked the run of Jiminez.

It’s an even worse setup, why would anyone think that was in anyway a good idea

 

[BlueToff]

Win and he'll be hated? I know I don't live among RS fans (although you'd be surprised how many are coming out of the woodwork) but this RS thing is ridiculous.

It was half in jest, but tbh, our season is boiling down to trying to stop them win the league.

 

[TyphooToffee]

Their main striker ghosted inbetween Richarlison and Coleman, Richarlison left him and didn't give any shout to coleman who had his back to him. So why was their #9 being marked by our left wingerand right full back and not a CB, surely that's Silva.

I'd also say in Silvas defence that communication on the field is sorely lacking in this team. There are genuinely no leaders.

Isn't it more a case that our defence has its orders of who stands where, and their forwards simply run through the weakest spot?

 

[nsno-chris]

At the end of the day, there's a much more deep-rooted issue at Everton than Silva.

I'm sick of the same old process. Hire a manager, play half-decent, play crap, fans turn, fire a manager, start again.

Whether Silva does go or not, I'm not really arsed now. I'm just saying, there's far more problems than him.

Clubs a mess, has been since Moyes left. People vying for control, no organisation, no direction

Just a small hope is that Brands can somehow rectify this

 

[when i score we riot]

I'm gonna sound like a dumb Brexit Dad here, but i think having a manager who actually speaks good english is important. Silva is, unfortunately, another language butcher. And until someones says bleedin' Sam Allardyce, his english is worse than Koeman's. But OK.

 

[BernieH]

Isn't it more a case that our defence has its orders of who stands where, and their forwards simply run through the weakest spot?

That's zonal marking, you look after your own space. It's no shock that forwards have cottoned on to it and position themselves against our smaller or non defensive players. Zonal marking takes aggression, organisation, leadership and communication, we have non of the above.

 

[TyphooToffee]

It was half in jest, but tbh, our season is boiling down to trying to stop them win the league.

Maybe that's the problem with our fans, and why we always struggle to get a result against them. Silva's Hull beat them 2-0, probably because Hull didn't have any other objective other than to beat them.

 

[BernieH]

I'm gonna sound like a dumb Brexit Dad here, but i think having a manager who actually speaks good english is important. Silva is, unfortunately, another language butcher. And until someones says bleedin' Sam Allardyce, his english is worse than Koeman's. But OK.

Theres loads of foreign coaches, not having that

 

[TyphooToffee]

I'm gonna sound like a dumb Brexit Dad here, but i think having a manager who actually speaks good english is important. Silva is, unfortunately, another language butcher. And until someones says bleedin' Sam Allardyce, his english is worse than Koeman's. But OK.

In this moment I think you might have a point.