2018/19 Marco Silva - New Poll Added

Grade Marco Silva's 2018/19 Season

  • A

  • B

  • C

  • D

  • E

  • F

Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.
Silva ain't all that and if he were to leave I for one would not be arsed in the slightest. He can't get a tune out of this gang of players it seems, so maybe we could find somebody else who is capable. Get Bielsa from Leeds if they don't get promoted end of season. Miles, miles better.
 

Funny thing is I remember us getting absolutely snotted 4-1 at home by spurs years ago, first game of a season, these days that'd probably have people on here calling for Kendall to be sacked.
 
bluestevon said:
Funny thing is I remember us getting absolutely snotted 4-1 at home by spurs years ago, first game of a season, these days that'd probably have people on here calling for Kendall to be sacked.
Click to expand...
Yes because the similarities between the greatest manager this club has ever seen and some clown who has failed in every job he’s been at in England are so blindingly obvious.
 
Sacking him makes little effect on the first team as Brands is the DOF and he is the one who sorts out the side/style/signings and philosophy.

Providing he actually gets to appoint the next manager and not the buffoons at the top of our club it should be a relative easy transition.

Its why clubs abroad like Sevilla can chop and change manager with relative ease as they have a strong DOF at the club.

We never had that with Martinez/Koeman/Alladyce
 
N.S.N.O. said:
If you were to drop the absolute wasters, who was on the bench yesterday who would have made any improvement?.....

Let's face it, we still have a very limited squad... One transfer window was never gonna sort the mess out...and we still have no quality striker...

I'm not saying Silva is the right man, but I personally won't judge him till next season (when he's had 3 windows to rebuild the squad)....
Click to expand...

well in my opinion, coleman should be nowhere near the squad, rather have Kenny. ( he's nothing special either ) but coleman has been disgraceful all season and to be honest I don't like his attitude, he fcks up and then turns around and argues with everyone around him, takes no responsibility what so ever

secondly ( and I like davies ) if you've got no gana you go for like for like ( or as close to it ) as possible and that's deffo no davies, that's a McCarthy or even baniginme or whatever hes called
 

judge said:
He's just not a good manager. Look at his track record. Listen to what he says. He tried to blame the disallowed goal, which was a push (look at it in normal speed - we wouldn't have been happy if it had happened to our defender) and doesn't seem to be aware of the 'car crash' football been offered up by his own team. He's like Big Sam last season who tried to convince us that he was laying attractive football. We are going nowhere with Silva. Give him to the end of the season and then get someone in who knows what they're doing!
Click to expand...
At least with Sam you know he is just on the wind up when he talks bollocks!
 
EverBlue92 said:
Sacking him makes little effect on the first team as Brands is the DOF and he is the one who sorts out the side/style/signings and philosophy.

Providing he actually gets to appoint the next manager and not the buffoons at the top of our club it should be a relative easy transition.

Its why clubs abroad like Sevilla can chop and change manager with relative ease as they have a strong DOF at the club.

We never had that with Martinez/Koeman/Alladyce
Click to expand...
I hope we are not aspiring to be “England’s Sevilla.” In fact I find this continental model terrible - the manager being just a cog in a big machine, effectively.
 
Kev The Rat said:
Yes because the similarities between the greatest manager this club has ever seen and some clown who has failed in every job he’s been at in England are so blindingly obvious.
Click to expand...

In the current era - Kendall would have almost certainly been fired before he ever turned that team around, primarily due to people like you, me old mucker.

Taking if you are too young to remember
 

At least in the cold light of day we can look back at the game more constructively. Seriously, it wasn’t as bad as we probably first thought. Now, on reflection, it was even worse than that. It was horrendous and pathetic. At the moment it’s like moonwalking. Silva thinks we are going forward when in reality we are going backwards. This is the first time in his short spell that we don’t actually look like we can beat anyone. Needs a win sharpish.
 
Any talk of dismissing Marco is ridiculously premature but yesterday he definitely planted one foot on the slippery slope that could lead to his sacking. It's all well and good talking about 'long-term projects ' and 'clearing out the deadwood', but no manager in today's football can afford too many results like yesterday without paying the consequences sooner or later, depending on how trigger-happy the owner is, or how irate the supporters become.

His tactics yesterday were ridiculous, bordering on full-blown Martinez. Going toe to toe with a Spurs team who are like a Formula 1 car, whereas we chugged along like my old 2nd hand Volkswagen Beetle, was always going to end in a disaster. They could have scored 10! If the absence of one player, Gana, makes such a difference to the team it's up to the manager to find a way to cope and not just send Tom Davies out there and expect to play the same way.

There's still time for Marco to leap clear of the slippery slope but he needs to start soon by getting back to the disciplined, intelligent, and hard-working performances we saw at places like Stamford Bridge and Anfield. Burnley is now a huge game.
 
polish said:
We had 3 shots on target yesterday. Is that equivalent of having a go?
Click to expand...

For me yes it is, its an embedded philosophy, we are at the start of a cycle. If we want to progress we are going to have to go tow to toe with teams like Spurs, United, City, Arsenal, Chelsea and Mordor. Dont get me wrong we have clear limits now that need to be built on over time. But the philosophy and psychology around it, is important id rather try and have a cut of the big teams, then try and scrape another glories draw to be honest.
 
we're not going to sack him, certainly not any time soon so it's fairly pointless you all discussing it. Moshiri wouldn't have gone through all the effort, just to sack him after 3 weeks of bad results. He needs to go back to Mina and Keane in the centre, maybe try Zouma right back and see if we can be a bit more solid that way, but whatever he decides, he needs to stick with the same back 4 and give it a chance, during the RS game we looked like a solid defensive outfit and it's fallen apart since changing it. It's the players' fault we don't have more wins really because of our poor finishing rather than tactics. We've been badly beaten by the two best teams in the league the last two games, but even against city we really could have won it with the clear openings we created.

As i said yesterday, our season starts again now with a lot of winnable games, let's try and support the guys and get us on a winning run, win these next two away games and we'll be back 7th, so let's not all start hissy fitting all over the place every time we get a bad couple of results, every team has bad results.
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Register

Shop

Back
Top