They will 1000% be singing his name in the derby if they're beating us. I mean it's a gift horse isn't it, it's literally the stuff of footballing dreams; mercilessly mock your rivals by crowing that their manager is your reject, who is on record as calling them a small club and saying he loves your club. It's like all your christmases come at once.I have to be honest, from the converstions I have had with reds they fall into 2 categories on this;
1) Heartbroken/angry- wanting to kill Benitez for being a Judas
2) Convinced he is an actual agent sent in to send us down.
The latter not in a sort of jokey/banter way either, like we might joke about how FSG love United/the Glaziers for having their statement on the board but deep down you know it's b/s but it's funny ammo. They genuinely believe Benitez is just here to wind us up for laughs for them.
The 2nd category are going to get a pretty big shock, when they realise their precious "Rafael" actually really wants the job and is not going to call us a small club in the 1st press conference etc etc.
This is not a particularly nuanced fanbase who can sort of look at it and go "well he did great for us, but he's with an opponent now so I am going to dislike him for that but admire what he did for us". They're not Evertonian's who can view things rationally and with a bit of perspective.
I highly doubt they will be singing his name in the derby, and I would imagine the relationship will be long soured by then.
This appointment is mutually assured destruction all around.
The reds I've spoken to are genuinely not bothered at all about him coming here. Some are giving it the head patting 'he'll do alright for you', some are laughing their heads off knowing how it's going to go, and some are mildly put out that he's going to lower himself to our level but not really bothered. Tellingly, not one of them is concerned that he's going to turn us into a really good side, which I think tells you all you need to know about what they really think of him as a manager.