Next Manager (Poll)

[BirkenheadBlue]

We dont have the players to play Guardiola football and realistically all Arteta will know is tippy tappy.

It'll be boring Martinez style all over again.

Based on....

Oh right... nothing...

 

[Bob Elstone]

Don’t understand the arteta love in.

bloke puts out the cones for pep. Sits there in silence every week looking petrified.

looks like he has less personality and prescence than Marco.

disaster of an appointment that one.

 

[blue to the bone]

Don’t understand the arteta love in.

bloke puts out the cones for pep. Sits there in silence every week looking petrified.

looks like he has less personality and prescence than Marco.

disaster of an appointment that one.

According to city players he does a lot more

 

[seer]

According to city players he does a lot more

Makes the tea, polishes the cones and tell's Pep "you are wonderful" with doe-eyes and a raging boner?

 

[kiss the crest]

Don’t understand the arteta love in.

bloke puts out the cones for pep. Sits there in silence every week looking petrified.

looks like he has less personality and prescence than Marco.

disaster of an appointment that one.

Sounds exactly like Ferguson with our last 4 managers, but look what happened last week

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

Don’t understand the arteta love in.

bloke puts out the cones for pep. Sits there in silence every week looking petrified.

looks like he has less personality and prescence than Marco.

disaster of an appointment that one.

How long have you been in the City staff? Is the pay decent?

 

[Dharma]

Don’t understand the arteta love in.

bloke puts out the cones for pep. Sits there in silence every week looking petrified.

looks like he has less personality and prescence than Marco.

disaster of an appointment that one.

Just the thought of him trying to b@ll@ck one of our under-performing players makes me laugh.lol

 

[griffla]

Based on what if you don’t mind me asking?

Please don’t say the Chelsea game

Just based on my gut feeling. They both have the same managerial experience (none) and I’m not totally convinced Arteta has the personality that I think we need. while Arteta was a magnificent player for us, I think Dunc has a far clearer understanding of Everton and all it’s nuances. Either appointment would be risky, but my evertonian spider-sense tells me Dunc would be more successful.

 

[ForeverBlue92]

Don’t understand the arteta love in.

bloke puts out the cones for pep. Sits there in silence every week looking petrified.

looks like he has less personality and prescence than Marco.

disaster of an appointment that one.

Exactly - he may well do a decent job at an Arsenal or Man City but we have kin Schneiderlin and Davies in the midfield.

Our club needs a proper manager with experience.

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

Just the thought of him trying to b@ll@ck one of our under-performing players makes me laugh.lol

Hmmmm,...

Re: the Chelsea game

Thank Christ Chelsea have been so wastefull, they could be in double figures here.

We had 30% possession mate, nothing to see here.

Straight from the Allardyce coaching manual.

Excuse me if we don't take your footballing opinion too seriously

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

Just based on my gut feeling. They both have the same managerial experience (none) and I’m not totally convinced Arteta has the personality that I think we need. while Arteta was a magnificent player for us, I think Dunc has a far clearer understanding of Everton and all it’s nuances. Either appointment would be risky, but my evertonian spider-sense tells me Dunc would be more successful.

Cool, so nothing. Fair play for admitting it.

 

[Billysgingham.]

Exactly - he may well do a decent job at an Arsenal or Man City but we have kin Schneiderlin and Davies in the midfield.

Our club needs a proper manager with experience.

We have had proper managers with experience and they didn't work.

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

we have kin Schneiderlin and Davies in the midfield.

Actually we have Gomes, Delph and Gbamin in the midfield (with likely reinforcements in the summer)

Unless you're advocating we rule managers in or out on the basis of a short term injury crisis?

 

[Tony101]

100% record for Dunk that one win is more than Arteta has. Seriously tho I don’t want any of them to be are next manager. I don’t no why people would want Arteta at this moment in time each to there own tho I guess. Me personally think we need a manager with some kind of experience of managing at a high level.

 

[BirkenheadBlue]

100% record for Dunk that one win is more than Arteta has. Seriously tho I don’t want any of them to be are next manager. I don’t no why people would want Arteta at this moment in time each to there own tho I guess. Me personally think we need a manager with some kind of experience of managing at a high level.

Arteta isn't my first choice, but compared to most of the realistic possibilities he's streets ahead. He's been touted as a coach with huge potential (and a future top level manager) since before he's even qualified for his badges... He nearly got the Arsenal job 18 months ago, and since then has another year and a half working with (arguably) the best manager in the world.

Is he a guarantee of success? No (but nor is anyone else). But he has a much higher potential ceiling than most of those we seem to be in the market for.