Whatever who cares whether it was true or not, my point was he never got a chance a few cameo appearances didn't really give anyone an idea how he would do if he had a bit of a run. To be honest how some of our players have played at times in the last six months he couldn't have done much worse. I really hope he does well at hull, then the people that have slated him we be wanting him back, that's how fickle some are. Also how do you know for a fact it was fabricated? He had a cast in Russia how do you know he didn't damage it again? I'm not say he did or didn't, but unless you are on the Everton coaching staff, you don't know for sure either.