Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

  • Participation within this subforum is only available to members who have had 5+ posts approved elsewhere.

Paolo Maldini

One of greatest, or an overrated fraud


  • Total voters
    46
Status
Not open for further replies.
Hi Charlie, still awaiting any evidence on your claim below:
This is right. Maldini waltzed around in a harlem globetrotter type team. I think it was Walters autobiography or maybe archie knox that wrote how ferguson was offered him at United but laughed at the prospect.

So, after not so much digging this is what Alex Ferguson wrote about Paolo Maldini:

“Maldini was an outstanding player. I loved him. I approached his father once, and the look he gave me I knew never to go back to him," said Ferguson.

“I watched Milan in their quarter-final, second leg against Bayern Munich and Maldini went through the entire 90 minutes without tackling. That is an art and he is the master of it. He is a great player. You can’t dismiss the sort of experience he has.“

Other qoutes

Ronald Koeman

“There’s never been a better left-back in the game’s history. Two-footed, and at his peak, brilliant going forward.

“The night Milan annihilated Barcelona in the 1994 Champions League Final, he played centre-half, as Franco Baresi and Alessandro Costacurta were both suspended, and looked like he’d played there all his life.”

Ronaldo

“Paolo Maldini is the best I’ve played against.”

Zlatan Ibrahimovic

“Maldini was the best and toughest defender I ever faced. He had everything: he was a complete defender, who was strong, intelligent, and an excellent man-marker.”

But @Charlie Sweet watched Channel 4 once in the 90’s and declared him crap
 
This is pretty silly. A bunch of 30 and 40 something fan boys straining at the memory of remembering a good looking Italian swan around on a sun basted pitch without an opposition player to challenge or harass him. Of course he looked good. He was good. My point was then and is now its ludicrous to compare him to either of the eras referenced in that thread.

The mid 80s and Everton were the best in the world. Gary Stevens and the likes of mad Pat not only had to actually defend but to cover driving runs from teams set up to challenge us in what was the most competitive league on the planet. And Gary and Pat etc did it. Mastered it. Maldini was no better than either and probably worse but I'm biased so on reflection I'll call it equal.

Where there is no doubt a blue was superior to Maldini was Kevin Ratcliffe - probably the best defender we've ever seen. Different eras but Rats had it all.

More recently Baines clearly had more skill than the aforementioned Italian. Lacking in pace Leighton glided into pockets of space others could only dream of. And he could defend when needed. Plus he had an individuality about him that you didn't get with Filippo Berio man.

Where this comes about is fanboys now reflecting on their spreading girth and harking back to the halcyon days in the 90s when they could touch their toes whilst flexing to Football Italia. Just because James Richardson told you in hushed tones than Maldini was a God doesn't make it true.

The lad was good. Very decent even. But not really special.

Google Dani Behr for context and lay off the biscuits.

I've come out with more sense at the Paradox on a Saturday night after 10 bottles of becks and 5 mitzi's.

I can only assume this is parody.
 

I've come out with more sense at the Paradox on a Saturday night after 10 bottles of becks and 5 mitzi's.

I can only assume this is parody.

Absolutely. I won't put up with (what I presume is) mockery of Dani Behr. Nobody thought she was MENSA material or a master of the art of televisual entertainment, but she filled a dress quite nicely, was easy on the eye in general, and I'd have gladly allowed her to wet my whistle (aka flute) any day of the week and twice on Sunday's. I've no idea what she looks like currently, but thats immaterial. She had her day and it was good.
 
The greatest defender ever.

Without the slightest context of opposition this comment makes no sense.

Tune in tomorrow when Charlie explains to us all how Sharp was better than Van Basten and how Gullit wasn't a patch on Vinny Samways.

Not at all. Sharp was brilliantly effective but clearly had some limitations. Samways was nothing in my eyes. That doesnt take anything away from some of our players being truly world class and the best in their positions (southall, Rats to name but two)


Growing up, Rats was my hero, but Maldini and Baresi were two of the best defenders I’ve ever seen play the game. No question about it. Maldini was a beautiful player to watch.

Thats it. Beauty. You've been lulled and lubed.
 

Without the slightest context of opposition this comment makes no sense.



Not at all. Sharp was brilliantly effective but clearly had some limitations. Samways was nothing in my eyes. That doesnt take anything away from some of our players being truly world class and the best in their positions (southall, Rats to name but two)




Thats it. Beauty. You've been lulled and lubed.
If a John Terry hussle and bustle, last ditch tackle type is your ideal defender, then Maldini is not your man.

If you want a defender that reads the game like no other, identifies the space like no other, prevents the forward getting the ball like no other, all without breaking a sweat because he has already snuffed out the chance before the forward even realises that there was a chance in the first place, then Maldini most definitely is your man.

"If I have to make a tackle, I have already made a mistake"
Have a think about that quote 👍
 
Without the slightest context of opposition this comment makes no sense.



Not at all. Sharp was brilliantly effective but clearly had some limitations. Samways was nothing in my eyes. That doesnt take anything away from some of our players being truly world class and the best in their positions (southall, Rats to name but two)




Thats it. Beauty. You've been lulled and lubed.
Oh, thanks for pointing that out to me, appreciate that. I’ll henceforth change my view.
 
Hi Charlie, still awaiting any evidence on your claim below:


So, after not so much digging this is what Alex Ferguson wrote about Paolo Maldini:

“Maldini was an outstanding player. I loved him. I approached his father once, and the look he gave me I knew never to go back to him," said Ferguson.

“I watched Milan in their quarter-final, second leg against Bayern Munich and Maldini went through the entire 90 minutes without tackling. That is an art and he is the master of it. He is a great player. You can’t dismiss the sort of experience he has.“

Other qoutes

Ronald Koeman

“There’s never been a better left-back in the game’s history. Two-footed, and at his peak, brilliant going forward.

“The night Milan annihilated Barcelona in the 1994 Champions League Final, he played centre-half, as Franco Baresi and Alessandro Costacurta were both suspended, and looked like he’d played there all his life.”

Ronaldo

“Paolo Maldini is the best I’ve played against.”

Zlatan Ibrahimovic

“Maldini was the best and toughest defender I ever faced. He had everything: he was a complete defender, who was strong, intelligent, and an excellent man-marker.”

But @Charlie Sweet watched Channel 4 once in the 90’s and declared him crap

 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome

Join Grand Old Team to get involved in the Everton discussion. Signing up is quick, easy, and completely free.

Back
Top