Pen or not?

[ToffeeTim]

Aye the consistency on VAR needs a lot of work. They need to get dedicated VAR technicians rather than referees to operate it as sadly the whole VAR thing has exposed further how inept most refs are.

It was a pen last night though, a cheap one, but a pen.

Yes but they cannot give that one and not when Lloris takes out Richarlison. Either none or both.

 

[chicoazul]

Yes but they cannot give that one and not when Lloris takes out Richarlison. Either none or both.

Human error, both were pens.

 

[sdk]

Confusing poll. The thread title asks "Pen or not?" so my first choice was Yes in answer to that question, but then I noticed the poll question itself was "Dive?", which would presumably prompt the opposite response.

But it would be suitable to answer Yes to both: Pickford fouled Kane while Kane was diving.

 

[Brownie]

The most enjoyable aspect of this discussion is that it reminded me of Yerry Mina's E. Honda-esque flying headbutt challenge that was somehow deemed not a penalty.

 

[stamullenblue]

Kane was clever but 100% a penalty ….

 

[Colonel Getafe]

maybe someone should print off this thread and send it to the FA, we might just lose 1-0 instead?

 

[Bez2k2k]

As my red supporting wife always says to me, well it was a pen because it was given.

Take that as you will.