Rook
Player Valuation: £80m
I used to count myself among those that didn't rate Dempsey. Not only not for the nats, but even back when he palyed for the NE Revolution. I felt he was better at carrying the ball laterally than he was at penetrating a defense, and that people got caught up in his daring and skill when really he was apt to lose the ball in a dangerous position with the way he was dribbling the ball.
But he has changed a bit. When he does carry the ball laterally he is apt to earn a foul - the guy earns so many dangerous free kicks for us, and the way we depend on them you can't discount his value in that regard -- and he is better at getting forward with the ball on his foot as well.
Is Dempsey essential to this team the way that Donovan or Howard are? No, but it is very close.
Under Hodgson the aspect of his game that has greatly improved is his heading. He's deadly on corners now and has a knack of getting a header across the goal.
I think you have to start Gooch. I'm all for putting players in with little exp, but not in one of USAs biggest matches ever. Gooch was decent against England too the goal he was partially responsible for well Gerrard is talented and he's going to through once in a while.