Ok, people want to fire Benitez because:
- Former manager of LFC, and said something about us being a small club.
- He is an outdated manager with old ideas.
- He is currently performing marginally below what is expected.
Yes, the Liverpool connection is unfortunate, and especially for those who live in the area. For us other plastic supporters, it means very little.
Outdated ideas? Well, do not have an overview of the training methods of Benitez, but the focus on fast transitions is something that is very central in the thinking of the Ragnick school. They basically do not care so much about ball possession. Zone defense has also not fallen out of fashion, and it is mostly only clubs like Atalanta, Leeds + some outliers that mostly use man marking. Now I understand this is controversial when it comes to dead balls, but Guerdiola, Ragnick and many top managers have used this repeatedly.
I'm a little worried that in recent games we've given the opponent too much space and time on our half of the pitch, and we're starting to approach the Ancelotti era where we mostly defended ourselves within the penalty area. But right now we are performing as expected, maybe a little below what is expected, and the latest trend is not positive. At the same time, key players have been out with injuries, which makes us far less competitive.
But all in all, I see no reason to fire Benitez. The only good reason had to be that they had a top manager ready to take over, or some model like Leipzig. Something I doubt. What the club needs now is stability. It is quite obvious that we are in a period of transition. We have to get rid of players before we get anything new, and we have to professionalize the club. Here I have confidence in Benitez, or it entails considerably lower risk, than any other possible candidates.
I have to laugh even though your points are well structured.
Heres some counter comments:
1: He claimed to have a computer software 'dossier' on players. Had been 'in touch' with Gray since he went to Leverkusen apparently...lets not forget we were scouting Leverkusen for the past 3 seasons lol
This magical dossier enabled us to bring in Gray, Townsend, Begovic, Lonergan and Rondon. Rondon of course he waited all window for...hardly unknowns.
2: He signed Rondon and has continued to play him.
3: He started Gbamin instead of easing him in after a long term injury. Not seen again.
4: Hes taken off Gordon in games where hes been decent and mentioned fitness. This is bizarre when starting Rondon and keeping him on for 90mins.
5: Very eager to move James on but no one else for any type of fee? Surely he could have moved on at least one or two players to generate funds.
6: Not given Simms or Dobbin more of a chance and instead played a lamp post up front.
7: Sent Nkounkou, our only backup left back on loan.
8: Didnt sign a right back.
9: Ripped up Davide Ancelotti's defensive set piece setup which was excellent and instead implemented a mess of set piece 'structure' at both ends of the pitch
10: Appears to make pre-planned substitutions
11: Plays Iwobi.
12: Makes tactical changes far too late. When we are being over run in centre midfield he keeps 2 in there or adds a body after weve conceded one or two goals.
13: Players sitting off and not playing a high energy 'in your face' style while claiming "i know what Evertonians want".
14: Attacking tactics are long balls with barely any link up play.
15: Holding back our left back assist maker and telling him to be more defensive which isnt his strength.
16: Clean sheets are extremely rare due to any defensive system where the back 4 arent in sync at all.
17: 2pts off 16th having yet to endure a nightmare run of games
18: 1 win in 9.
19: Destroyed by Watford and didnt try against City.
20: Out of the cup against a lower league side
I can probably think of a few more...