We can only judge Rafael when he has a full squad to pick from plus the players he brings in in January, Gray and Townsend have been decent so I trust in his choices .
People have lost their minds. When Martinez arrived and took over what was a top 7 squad, got given funds and had a full preseason, most people were in agreement on things like ‘he needs a least three seasons to be judged’ ‘he needs time to build his own squad to play the football he wants’ ‘it might have to get worse before it gets better’. He had a very good first season, then a poor second season, most were still in favour of a third season and he then proved it wasn’t getting better. Despite that though there were still some calling for him to get longer and even some calling for him to return every time there’s a managerial vacancy.
Benitez has had a few games with a squad that is not his after being parachuted into a basket case of a club halfway through the summer. He was given hardly anything to spend, and has then incurred a ridiculous injury crisis. But because he managed Liverpool, a load of people now want him out. It’s absolutely ridiculous and honestly resembles the same sort of witch-hunt behaviour that we accuse kopites of.
This is a serious turn around job. The problems that previous managers have stored up for us are not easily solved. Everyone on here recognised that before Ancelotti came, yet now seem to think that all the problems are gone. The parameters are still exactly the same:
A poor squad of players low on pace, power, technique, intelligence, confidence
Most of the squad on long contracts on higher wages than they could command elsewhere. Hardly any of the squad playing well enough to get a move upwards
FFP constraints due to the above point meaning any new manager has to sell players to be able to buy, except they can’t because most won’t go, so we have to loan them or wait until contract ends
We have a terrible injury record meaning any new buys often get injured and we are back to problem number 1.
There is no quick easy way out of this. No magic silver bullet that fixes this in one swoop. The only way out of it is to let a manager be bulletproof, make it clear he’s not being fired no matter how much the players down tools. Back him as much as possible every transfer window to bring new players in. Improve the medical department as much as possible in the meantime, shift players out as contracts end. Wait for the FFP situation to improve.
Firing a manager doesn’t help us do any of those steps at all, in fact it makes it harder because it just reinforces the players belief they can get any manager fired. The funding situation gets worse every time we have to pay out huge compensation. We keep getting mismatched squads of players because of all the different managers.
It’s a massive waste yet loads of fans are almost gleeful in calling for it because they can’t get past petty partisanship when it comes to Benitez.