Keane - poor signing and vastly overpriced.
Sandro - Seldom played - because when he did play he was shockingly bad.
Klassen - barely played by 3 successive managers - there's a reason for that.
Martina - poor signing
Sigurdsson - decent if played in no. 10 position - never worth £45M, though. If we'd paid half that it would have been steep.
Rooney - past it before he came to Everton
Scherderlin- decent first season, terrible attitude this season. True. £25M wasted there.
Williams - Very poor signing.
Bolasie - poor signing. He wasn't great before the injury but now he's a waste of a shirt. Dreadfully overpriced when we did buy him.
Pickford - good signing
Gana - good signing
Tosun - too early to tell
Walcott - decent signing.
That to me is a flawed transfer policy, we have sold good players (Stones, Lukaku and Barkley) and replaced them with vastly inferior ones, by and large.
The thing is, though, all three players had made it absolutely clear that they wanted to leave. We certainly did all we could to keep Ross Barkley. You could argue that none of them have improved since leaving us - Barkley has hardly played for Chelsea, Lukaku's showing the same on-off form for Man U that he showed with us, and Stones is in and out at City - they paid £50M in January for a player in his position.
Not buying a centre forward is the worst failing. We knew since March that Lukaku was probably off, so why on earth didn't we have a replacement lined up?