The only empirical evidence is how this group has performed pre Dyche/outside of Dyche. It’s pretty grim reading as well.
Repeating myself but Dyche is crap, so are these players.
Pickford - Good
Coleman - over the hill
Tarkowski - career of rele battles
Branthwaite - Good (possibly v good)
Myko - genuinely worst left back I’ve seen for us (pistone/valente included)
Gana - over the hill
Mangala - rele battles/struggling teams
Doucoure - career of rele battles
Harrison - career of rele battles
DCL - pretty much career of rele battles
N’Diaye - first season in the prem, good in the championship, flopped in France (incidentally we all think he’s our best player)
Do you not see any problem with that?
