Why does what happened in 1998 resonate with you more than what happened since? Aside from caretakers, every Everton manager since Moyes was new and they didn't work either. Why does 1998 count but all the failed new managers since then don't prove new managers don't work?
I'm not arguing new managers don't work -- merely pointing out I can provide more factual evidence from reality of new managers failing than you can of returning managers who failed. It doesn't matter how many times you say it ... it doesn't make any logical sense to just say "Kendall didn't work so that proves it" ... it proves nothing. Maybe that one event proves player-manager is better than just manager?
