Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

 

Shani Tarashaj

Status
Not open for further replies.
Eggs said:
.....hoping you're right. My view isn't based on watching him. I'm just thinking he didn't always play for his club and isn't getting much of a look in here. I'd be looking for him to get more playing time if he's such a bright talent.
Click to expand...
Played most games for his club in fairness mr eggs, won swiss youngster of the year ahead of embolo etc so he clearly has talent.

He's only just broke onto the scene for Switzerland in a position where they have very good seasoned pro's, it'd be like asking someone similar to rashford to be playing every game too.

Has plenty of time to become a starter for them.
 
AaronTheBlue said:
Played most games for his club in fairness mr eggs, won swiss youngster of the year ahead of embolo etc so he clearly has talent.

He's only just broke onto the scene for Switzerland in a position where they have very good seasoned pro's, it'd be like asking someone similar to rashford to be playing every game too.

Has plenty of time to become a starter for them.
Click to expand...

....yep, I'm probably being unfair. There is clearly a lot of potential there, let's see if it is realised.
 
Kev50 said:
I haven't got much faith in his judgment. I think there's ample evidence for this. We'll see won't we. Let's hope he's got a bit more about him than Niasse
Click to expand...
tarashaj was scouted for a while. Niasse wasn't, niasse was a snap shot, the other player wasn't.

Martinez on the whole was good at spotting a player, he was just absolutely woeful at getting them playing well together.
 


For all of RM's faults, his transfers were on the whole very good. He has generally brought a higher quality of player barring a few... I think when he first came, he made the mistake of doing what most managers do when switching from clubs, gfoing back to where they came from for easy targets. Most of the players we've brought in under Martinezx you can see have some talent, hell, even McGeady has his moments and makes you see why some managers take to him, but obviously as a whole not good enough..

Deulofeu,
Besic (raw but there is certainly a player there)
McCarthy (Again, bit off recently but you can see what he can do defensively when hes on his game)
Lukaku (Not an unknwon or even a risk but manageed to get 25 goals out of a poor performing team)
Lennon (He's been okay aznd shown glimpses, not a great signing, not a bad one).
Joel (Ditto above)
Kone (Really not sure with this one, Thi8nk he just wanted a back up striker and was an easy buy, knew what he can do and didn't wanna go further)
Barry (Lets face it all of us didnt agree on signing Barry, turned out to be an excellent signing).
Cleverly (Not good enough as a starter, squad player maybe.
Niasse (Strange one, appears to be an awful player in just what, 90 minutes of football for the club, some achievement).
Mori (Excellent signing imo, strong, presence in the air, needs to refine a few things but under the right management...)
Traore (Didn't have any chance to do anything, made 2 appearances, can't judge properly).


Worth givingt this Tarashaj the benefit, hes new to Swiss first team, he's played alot for Grasshopper which is promising. I have no doubt RM could spot talent in a player, hte issues are that he couldn't organise a defence.

Feel like ive missed someone out. On the whole He'd done relatively well in the market barring Kone and Niasse. Not amazing, but the general is good quality of player. His first window was a very good one. Deulofeu, Lukaku and McCarthy.
 
kithnou said:
Don't make me list his signings now mate.
Click to expand...


barry - excellent signing
McCarthy - suffering a dip in form, but a class signing
rodriguez - never seen him so probs crap but you never know
hennen - see above
lukaku - £28 for a 23yr old goal machine with a £65m price tag
Gerry - our most creative winger, signed on the cheap with a buyback barca won't trigger cause they've got this lad who's alright at togger playing his position
kone - mostly shoite
niasse - probably [Poor language removed]
funes mori - class centre half
mo besic - killer robot from the future with enhanced pass optics
joel - potentially very good keeper if given a run in the first team

aswel as bringing stones and barkley to the fore

so we've got kone who we paid 6m for, rodriguez, hennen and niasse who we've barely seen

and the rest
 
andy4efc said:
For all of RM's faults, his transfers were on the whole very good. He has generally brought a higher quality of player barring a few... I think when he first came, he made the mistake of doing what most managers do when switching from clubs, gfoing back to where they came from for easy targets. Most of the players we've brought in under Martinezx you can see have some talent, hell, even McGeady has his moments and makes you see why some managers take to him, but obviously as a whole not good enough..

Deulofeu,
Besic (raw but there is certainly a player there)
McCarthy (Again, bit off recently but you can see what he can do defensively when hes on his game)
Lukaku (Not an unknwon or even a risk but manageed to get 25 goals out of a poor performing team)
Lennon (He's been okay aznd shown glimpses, not a great signing, not a bad one).
Joel (Ditto above)
Kone (Really not sure with this one, Thi8nk he just wanted a back up striker and was an easy buy, knew what he can do and didn't wanna go further)
Barry (Lets face it all of us didnt agree on signing Barry, turned out to be an excellent signing).
Cleverly (Not good enough as a starter, squad player maybe.
Niasse (Strange one, appears to be an awful player in just what, 90 minutes of football for the club, some achievement).
Mori (Excellent signing imo, strong, presence in the air, needs to refine a few things but under the right management...)
Traore (Didn't have any chance to do anything, made 2 appearances, can't judge properly).


Worth givingt this Tarashaj the benefit, hes new to Swiss first team, he's played alot for Grasshopper which is promising. I have no doubt RM could spot talent in a player, hte issues are that he couldn't organise a defence.

Feel like ive missed someone out. On the whole He'd done relatively well in the market barring Kone and Niasse. Not amazing, but the general is good quality of player. His first window was a very good one. Deulofeu, Lukaku and McCarthy.
Click to expand...
All those examples..
Atleast say he was OK .
 

Status
Not open for further replies.

Welcome to GrandOldTeam

Get involved. Registration is simple and free.

Register
Back
Top