Calum Chambers over Keane for me; dominant aerially, great feat, positionally spot on too. Similar to a young John Terry IMO, would be a starter for the senior team by now if he'd gone to somewhere like Spurs instead of the Anglo-cemetery that is Arsenal in 2014.
Not that I don't rate Keane, and I'd even go for both; circa £40m for a decade-long partnership would be a great investment; factor in Pickford and there genuinely could be scope for a solid foundation for any future success.
Really?
Chambers is nowhere near Keane's quality imo.