Analysing splits in the fan base when it comes to managers i see as people forming opinions on what they personally value in a manager, it’s very evident in the circular streaming mess that is the non sensual Dyche thread on either side of a divide.
Some people want to go to the game, be entertained, feel like football is progressive, but don’t really care or want to consider anything on top of that.
Others look at more 360. They look at thing like managing through limits, budgets, building through adversity etc. These people will sacrifice style for if it’s god for the overall life blood of the club.
The natural tension is between the two.
Dyche is a case point, saved us from a hopeless cause, managed through a massively adverse circumstances last year, doing it all with no governance support, having to have a high - net transfer spend. Possibly making the club 100s of millions through the process.
However - some just want to stylistically play nice football, be entertained and be linked to players and feel we are progressing - so want him out.
As above that’s the tension.
Equally when you apply to Moyes, he built this club, from relegation Candidates, to CL, to European club almost every year. Making the club 100s of millions in recruitment, via his success but also recruitment.
Then, people got bored if the style, felt there was a ceiling, whether he hit it or whether he hit it with what we could provide is debatable.
But again that’s the tension.
Ultimately as a fan base we are very transparent.
So the question is what does the club need and what competences. For me the club needs to be recovered - priority one - the balance sheet needs to be fixed, anyone who think TFG is coming in and suddenly all our problems financially are gone, is fooling themselves. We need someone with the competency Moyes had to recover the club again.
Stylistically will it be different - probably not, so we are back to that natural tension.
That tension will always exist in the fan base. My own take, is I’d have Moyes back in the morning, I don’t view as going back. I’m looking at competency, who is available with the competency in the league, who can recover a club and get into Europe in limits, it’s him.
You mention, him as if he is someone from a time passed, he just recovered WHU and is the last PL manager outside the cartel clubs to go and win a trophy - that’s in the last two years.
I really don’t understand, what doesn’t recommend him for the job, he’s actually exactly what the club need - whether we go that route or not - if your interviewing on competency he’s ticking a hell of a lot of boxes.
But as I say above, the 360 view Vs Stylistic views will always dictate the tension in the fan base.
We generally crave something different here from the style of the last manager - we’re fairly predictable. So be interesting to see what we do. Welcome back Roberto.