The worst Everton player of all time?

[ToffeeDan]

Obviously since this kind of thread comes along far too often we enjoy the masochism associated with it...

 

[mawders]

what about Jigsaw? stuey barlow and those amazing ears...i remember him missing about 3 one on ones in the anfield derby...i guess he wasn't quite as bad as frankenstein's monster though (angell)...

claus thomsen is possibly the worst midfielder i have ever seen in a blue shirt....i can't remember him doing anything apart from that OG in the derby at the street end (which penelope redknapp tried to claim)...

thinking about it, we have has some sh1te...and i am with those who say preki...what about bob the pole....and then we had a fat epsen baardsen who let 4 in from spurs.....

i see some people said tyler...am i the only person who thinks he was alright?...

 

[Reidy's Bottle Of Grecian]

never rated Ebrell myself

 

[AdamTheGreatOneB]

Without going back through the whole thread, has anyone said Mike Milligan?

 

[monty]

Without going back through the whole thread, has anyone said Mike Milligan?

Yes and they got barred, see you Adam

 

[padefc]

glen keeleyrcard

 

[padefc]

for me its a no contest PAUL HOLMES the right back biggest pile of sh1t ie ever ever seen make claus thompson look like ronaldo what hk seen in him has always baffled me:confused2:

 

[ForeverEverton]

Tony Hibbert, nuff said

 

[bluebastardo]

Tim isn't a name I associate with great football at the moment.

 

[Reidy's Bottle Of Grecian]

steve mcmahon

 

[evilwebby]

For me, the most disappointing player I've ever seen pull on a Everton shirt was Alex Nyarko. No heart at all - we'd have been better off with 10 men most of the time.

 

[mawders]

never rated Ebrell myself

ebrell was a weird one...i reckon he had a good football brain...it's just for the most part his brain didn't connect with his foot....but he did alright under royle for a bit, and i wouldn't mind having ebrell in the side right now...and least he would fight, unlike felli.

 

[Neiler]

Terry Phealan
Mitch Ward
John O Kane
John Oster
David Burrows
Steve Simonson
Van Der Meyde
Kroldrup
John Spencer
Peter Degn
Alec Clellend
Ginola
Claues Tompson
Blomquivst
Mark Pembridge
Tobias Linderoth
Gary Naismith


And cant beleive no one mentioned Scott Gemmill - shudders.

 

[Muggins]

For me, the most disappointing player I've ever seen pull on a Everton shirt was Alex Nyarko. No heart at all - we'd have been better off with 10 men most of the time.

Remember the shirt swap incident at Highbury....definitely the worst player.

The fella who invaded the pitch and offered to swap shirts was sitting in front of me. one minute he was there....the next he had hopped the barrier, and not one steward tried to stop him.

Nyarko then walked off the pitch....apparantly..."disgusted"....LOLOLOL.

Defo worst player, purely because he had NO HEART which is my main quibble with players.

 

[evilwebby]

Remember the shirt swap incident at Highbury....definitely the worst player.

The fella who invaded the pitch and offered to swap shirts was sitting in front of me. one minute he was there....the next he had hopped the barrier, and not one steward tried to stop him.

Nyarko then walked off the pitch....apparantly..."disgusted"....LOLOLOL.

Defo worst player, purely because he had NO HEART which is my main quibble with players.

Yep. Just had a refresh of the whole saga here: http://www.bluekipper.com/nyarko/nyarko_quits.html

Jesus H. Christ.
I mean, some players were not good enough, but with this guy it was simply a question of heart. He pleaded to be substituted after the shirt swap incident. WTF?!!? That really should have been it as far and we should have cut him loose right then and there. Absolute scum.