Thelwell. In or out?

[Goat]

Swear he's like 27

25million pound wasted, in my book, you clearly think he has something to offer, thats fine.

 

[PeregrineT]

He spent 60m on Maupay, Beto and Chermo, not to mention another 20m on JOB.

Thats 80m hes wasted, could have bought us a whole new attack.

Get him gone.

I find it interesting you say you cant judge a striker under Dyche when it comes to DCL but then slot the rest of them, including Chermiti.

He spent 80m on Ndiaye, Onana, Gana, Garner, Tarks, McNeil, and Tim, and with what we sold Onana for the other 5 have cost 33m.

And he sold Iwobi, Gray, Cannon, Dobbin and Godfrey for 56m. 136m for Gordon, Onana and Richy.

 

[Goat]

I find it interesting you say you cant judge a striker under Dyche when it comes to DCL but then slot the rest of them, including Chermiti.

He spent 80m on Ndiaye, Onana, Gana, Garner, Tarks, McNeil, and Tim, and with what we sold Onana for the other 5 have cost 33m.

And he sold Iwobi, Gray, Cannon, Dobbin and Godfrey for 56m. 136m for Gordon, Onana and Richy.

He spent 80m on pub players.

 

[DanEFC92]

Hasn't addressed the glaring issues at full back. Like how do we have a 39 year old as back up to a 36 year old

Hasn't addressed the lack of pace in the side. Lol at signing Harrison twice.

As well as the aforementioned money he's spunked up the wall when given some.

Bin.

 

[Bryan+]

5 year contact, £100m lets see what the fella can do.

 

[hallamblue]

I don't think he's done a terrible job,but he also hasn't pulled up any trees so I'd replace him in the summer. How gutted will @Eggs be at the current results of this poll!

 

[billyblue80]

Not been impressed mostly despite some decent decisions and the fact that he has had his hands tied behind his back. He seems of the BK school of just doing enough being good enough. Backing Dyche and some of the choices of player are highly questionable.

 

[Clarky cat]

January wrestle with Dyche at Finch farm, stripped to the waist. Winner gets to be employed by Everton in February

 

[Exeter_Gently]

January wrestle with Dyche at Finch farm, stripped to the waist. Winner gets to be employed by Everton in February

Willy conkers...loser leaves town.

 

[Clarky cat]

Willy conkers...loser leaves town.

Private school sounds lovely

 

[allen]

Not enough data for me.

If there was a list of players he signed or tried to sign, and a list of players he wasn’t keen on but others at the club were, then I could judge.

But there isn’t and I can’t.

 

[Zezti]

Hasn't addressed the glaring issues at full back. Like how do we have a 39 year old as back up to a 36 year old

Hasn't addressed the lack of pace in the side. Lol at signing Harrison twice.

As well as the aforementioned money he's spunked up the wall when given some.

Bin.

Somehow, the 36 year old has become the backup to the 39 year old.

 

[Bob Elstone]

Get rid asap. Woeful recruitment particularly in forward positions.

 

[MACCA75]

People are very soft on him. Say he’s had no money. It’s like;
Maupay - ‘yeah but that wasn’t Thelwell’
Beto - ‘yeah but he didn’t want him really’ (despite trying to sign him twice)
Chermiti - ‘yeah but you can’t count him’
O’Brien - ‘yeah but that wasn’t him’

Then spending loan money on flops Harrison, Danjuma and Lindstrom.

The truth is he just hasn’t been very good.

 

[Vintage]

Will have to stick with him till the end of this transfer window anyway. Getting rid of him now will screw up any transfer plans even if the plans are crap.
After the window closes don't care either way. Has done well in shifting players out of the club but incomings have been poor but that's with heavy financial restraints. Not sure if he is good enough to keep on