Edu was never going to be a CB option. I don't know what everyone was watching during the Olympics that year, but he wasn't that good. And that was against lesser competition. He's a midfielder.
Gooch needs to get fit because if he doesn't, our back line is going to stink. There really are no other good options if he sits. Bocanegra has to play LB for this to be successful.
Assuming we're going 4-4-2 (a safe assumption, even though it's probably not the best), I think the starters are:
Spector-Demerit-Gooch-Bocanegra
Holden-Bradley-Clark-Donovan
Dempsey-Altidore
Not sure that Dempsey will start at forward, seems funny that Bradley would take 4 forwards and only start one. But Dempsey is the best option.
Would still like to see 5 in the midfield. If that's the case, maybe Beasley gets a shot over Holden. If anyone but Bocanegra plays LB, I think BB will be forced to play Beasley for his work rate in tracking back.
If Michael Bradley wasn't the coaches son, most people's perspective on him would do a 180. He's 22, has starred in Dutch football, starts for a mid-table Bundesliga club, and has over 40 caps. How many American players have accomplished as much as he has by 22?